ב"ה, ז' אדר, תשי"ח
ברוקלין.
שלום וברכה!
במענה למכתבו, בו שואל באיזה אופן לנהוג כמנהגי חב"ד.
אין שאלתו מפורטת כיד צרכה, וחסרים גם כן פרטי סביבתו, ויתייעץ עם זקני אנ"ש אשר להם יציע הנ"ל ויעשה כהוראתם.
ב) שואל מהו שרש נשמתו למעלה.
הנה ידועה הוראת תורתנו הק' לא ברא הקב"ה בעולמו דבר אחד לבטלה, וה"ה בהנוגע לידיעות האדם שעליו להוודע הענינים בהם תלוי' תורתו ומצותיו ית' ואופני קיומם, ובהנוגע אליו מאי נפק"מ בזה בירור שאלתו האמורה, והרי ישנו לפניו השו"ע ובו נאמר כל מה שעליו לעשות ומה לו עסק בנסתרות?
ג) מבקש עזרה ללימוד תורה בנגלה ובנסתר.
ידוע מאמר רז"ל יגעת ולא מצאת אל תאמין, ובמילא בו הדבר תלוי להיות עמל בתורה ומהדר בקיום המצות, ואז יצליחו השי"ת.
בברכה,
בשם כ"ק אדמו"ר שליט"א
Practical Growth Over Mystical Speculation: Insights from Igros Kodesh, Vol. 16
Letter No. 6,096 | 7 Adar, 5718
In this candid letter, the Lubavitcher Rebbe responds to an individual who seems to be searching for spiritual identity through abstract questions. The Rebbe’s answers serve as a "reality check," redirecting the seeker toward the tried-and-true path of action and effort.
1. Seeking Guidance on Chabad Tradition
The writer first asks how he should follow Chabad tradition. The Rebbe’s response is telling: he notes that the question is too vague and that he lacks specific details about the writer's community and surroundings.
Rather than giving a generic spiritual discourse, the Rebbe directs him to the elders of Anash (the Chassidic community) in his own area. He advises the writer to present his specific dilemmas to those who know him and his environment, and to follow their instructions. This emphasizes the importance of local mentorship and grounded, practical guidance.
2. The "Root of the Soul" vs. The Shulchan Aruch
Next, the writer asks a deeply mystical question: "What is the root of my soul above?"
The Rebbe’s reply is a classic Chassidic lesson in utility. He explains that Hashem created nothing in vain; therefore, any information we possess should be applicable to our Divine service. Knowing the celestial "root" of one's soul is largely theoretical. Instead, a person’s responsibility is to focus on what the Torah and Mitzvos require of them here on earth.
The Rebbe points the writer toward the Shulchan Aruch (the Code of Jewish Law). Why occupy yourself with the mysteries of your soul when the path of life is clearly mapped out in the Law? The "will of Hashem" is found in how we live our daily lives, not in our spiritual lineage.
3. The Secret to Success: Hard Work
Finally, the writer asks the Rebbe for help in learning both the revealed and esoteric parts of Torah. The Rebbe’s answer is empowering yet demanding: the "secret" to learning Torah is simply effort.
Quoting the Sages, the Rebbe cites the famous dictum: "Yagata v’lo matzasa, al ta’amin"—If someone says, "I have toiled but not found," do not believe him. The Rebbe makes it clear that success in Torah isn't a gift handed down from a leader; it is the result of one's own "toil and effort." If you work hard and observe the Mitzvos with perfection, Hashem will naturally grant you success.
Summary of Key Lessons
-
Local Mentorship: For practical questions on how to live as a Chassid, consult the elders and mentors in your immediate community.
-
Focus on Action: Don't get lost in "off the ground" mystical questions like the root of your soul. Focus on the Shulchan Aruch—what Hashem actually wants you to do.
-
No Wasted Information: Seek knowledge that is applicable to your growth. Abstract information without application is "wasted."
-
Effort is Everything: There are no shortcuts to Torah knowledge. The Rebbe’s blessing for success follows your personal decision to work hard.