Support Torah
Recordings

Classes, Shemini - A fire came out from before Hashem

This heartfelt class reflects on personal loss and connects it to Parshas Shemini. Through Aharon’s silent acceptance, it teaches how to להתמודד with pain, honor loved ones through mitzvos, and find comfort in faith and the hope of techiyas hameisim.

It is always a difficult time to deal with death—with pain, with the disruption of life.

And especially when we are speaking about someone in middle age, someone who has not yet reached a ripe old age. When people grow old, it is somewhat expected that eventually they will pass on from this world. But when it happens to someone young, in the prime of their life, it is that much more painful.

We have with us Morris Winman, who unfortunately lost his sister. She was only 47 years old. He just got up from shiva—either this morning or yesterday—and we all share in his pain.

Of course, we do not have explanations. We do not understand why Hashem does what He does. It seems unfair, something we cannot grasp or comprehend. But these are, at times, the realities of life.

We are here to support you. And the person who passed on is in a better place. Hopefully, they are no longer in pain. They are surely under the wings of the Divine, protected and cared for. But those who remain—the ones left behind—are the ones who carry the pain, the ache, the loss.

After Maariv, those who wish, even though it is after shiva, it is still within the time of shloshim. Although shloshim will be shortened due to Pesach, it is still currently within that period, and we can still offer the traditional blessing of Hamakom yenachem etchem—that Hashem should comfort and heal the broken hearts.

May the memories of the deceased, and the time spent together, serve as a meaningful remembrance and bring some measure of peace and comfort after this loss.

Following davening, we will say Hamakom yenachem etchem.

Additionally, today is the yahrzeit of a very special individual, someone I can call a dear friend—Sinai Posner, Sinai ben Chayim Posner. Over the last few years of his life, he would come visit his son, Dr. Posner, and I had the good fortune to spend meaningful time with him.

He was a short, thin man, but truly a giant. He possessed deep wisdom and rich life experience, but more than anything, he radiated goodness. You could see it in his eyes, hear it in his speech—he was humble, kind, and warm. Being in his presence felt comfortable and uplifting. We had many meaningful conversations together.

His yahrzeit is tonight, at Maariv.

Dr. Posner has also prepared a special breakfast for tomorrow. Please make sure not to eat before coming, and join us. He has put tremendous effort into it—calling multiple times to ensure everything is properly prepared, kosher, and complete. This is not for his own honor, but entirely to honor his father. That itself is something very meaningful and inspiring to learn from.

I would like to briefly connect this to a dvar Torah from today’s parsha.

We are learning Parshas Shemini—specifically the third portion. I want to connect this to the events we are commemorating today.

In the parsha, we read about a terrible tragedy that occurred at this very time of year, when the Jewish people were in the desert. The Torah tells us that a fire came forth from before Hashem and consumed them—referring to Nadav and Avihu, the two sons of Aharon.

They were young, in the prime of their lives, and they were great tzaddikim. Yet a fire came out from Hashem and they passed away—vayamusu lifnei Hashem.

The Torah’s language here is striking. It does not simply say they died. It emphasizes that the fire came from Hashem, and that they died before Hashem. From the commentaries, we understand that these were exceptionally great individuals.

Sometimes, a young life is cut short in a way that we cannot explain. But there is a powerful verse that follows.

Aharon, their father, was devastated. At that very moment, he was at the height of joy—the Mishkan had just been inaugurated, he had become the Kohen Gadol, and there was great celebration.

And suddenly, in the midst of all this joy, tragedy struck.

It is similar to our situation—during a time like Pesach, when there is excitement and preparation, and then suddenly such difficult news arrives. It is very hard to accept.

Moshe says to Aharon: this is what Hashem meant—bikrovai ekadesh—through those closest to Me, I am sanctified.

And then the Torah concludes: Vayidom Aharon—Aharon was silent.

He said nothing.

Aharon could have protested. He could have complained. He could have said, “If this is how You treat my children, I will not continue.” He could have been angry—and perhaps justifiably so.

Yet he remained silent. He accepted Hashem’s judgment.

We see a similar response in Jewish history. After the Holocaust, after such unimaginable loss, one might have expected a reaction of rejection. Yet the Jewish people continued with faith—Hashem natan, Hashem lakach, yehi shem Hashem mevorach.

This is the meaning of Vayidom Aharon—a quiet acceptance, a deep trust.

And this is the message for us.

When we face difficult and painful situations, we must respond by honoring the memory of those who passed. We continue to remember them, to say Kaddish, to do mitzvos in their merit, to give tzedakah, and to elevate their souls.

Through this, we find strength and eventually comfort.

And we hope—and believe—that we will merit the time of techiyas hameisim, when all those who have passed will return, and we will be reunited with our loved ones.

May Hashem remember these souls: Sally Esther bas Rivka and Yaakov, and Sinai ben Chayim.

May all the good deeds, the Kaddish, the prayers, and the charity done in their merit bring them elevation. And may Hashem bring comfort to all those who mourn.

And as we approach the Yom Tov of Pesach, may we all merit a kosher and joyous Pesach.

Leave Feedback