Purim - Important to listen. Lesson from King Saul and Shmuel

Importent to listen. Lesson from King Saul and Shmuel

King Saul’s failure against Amalek teaches that even "holy logic" cannot replace total devotion to G-d. Intellect is limited, but a foundation of Kabbalas Ol (accepting G-d's yoke) ensures our survival. Like Moshe Rabbeinu, we must lead with a faith that transcends human reason.
← Prev Next →

 

Purim - Important to Listen: Lessons from King Saul and Shmuel

Key Takeaways

  • The Command of Remembrance: Shabbat Zachor, preceding Purim, fulfills the Torah command to remember the actions of Amalek.

  • Logic vs. Devotion: King Saul’s error was prioritizing his own logical reasoning over total obedience to G-d’s command regarding Amalek.

  • Suprarational Faith: True Jewish survival depends on Kabbalas Ol (accepting G-d's yoke) and Mesiras Nefesh (self-sacrifice), which transcend human intellect.

Shabbat Zachor and the Weight of Memory

This upcoming Shabbat is Shabbat Zachor, the Shabbat of Remembrance that immediately precedes Purim. On this day, we fulfill the Torah's command to remember what Amalek did to the Jewish people. This week also marks the yahrtzeit of Moshe Rabbeinu on the seventh of Adar (Zayin Adar), providing us with a powerful backdrop to discuss leadership and devotion.  

 

 

The Mistake of King Saul

In the Haftarah for Shabbat Zachor, we read the story of King Saul and Agag, the king of Amalek. G-d gave Saul a clear command: wipe out Amalek entirely. However, Saul felt compassion for the cattle and spared them. When Shmuel the Prophet confronted him, Saul’s response was startling: "I did listen to Hashem."  

 

 

Saul wasn’t a common rebel; the Gemara describes him as being as pure of sin as a one-year-old child. He was the first king appointed by G-d to lead Israel. He didn't believe he was disobeying; rather, he believed he was enhancing the command through his own logic. He reasoned that by taking the physical animals of Amalek and turning them into korbanot (sacrifices), he was performing the ultimate service of transforming darkness into light.  

 

 

Logic vs. Devotion

King Saul used his intellect where he should have used his obedience. While using our reason to serve G-d is generally a positive thing, the Prophet Shmuel corrected him: "Halo tov shmoia mi'zevach tov"—Listening is better than the best sacrifice.  

 

 

The ultimate level of a Jew is not a religion based on human understanding, but a life based on Kabbalas Ol—the total acceptance of G-d’s yoke. When we rely solely on our own reasoning, we risk reaching the wrong conclusions, no matter how intelligent we are. Saul’s delay in killing Agag allowed for the birth of a child who would eventually become the ancestor of Haman the Agagite. Haman’s threat to the Jewish people was the direct result of a leader prioritizing his logic over a Divine decree.  

 

 

The Legacy of Mesiras Nefesh

To flourish, the Jewish people must stand on a foundation of total dedication that transcends the intellect. This is the secret of our survival. During the time of the Purim decree, the Jews stood with Mesiras Nefesh (self-sacrifice). Logically, they could have found halakhic loopholes to save their lives by appearing to give in, but they chose a devotion that was "beyond the intellect."  

 

 

This same spirit was lived by Moshe Rabbeinu and my late father, of blessed memory. They didn't serve G-d because it was "logical" or "convenient" under the circumstances. They stood strong because they realized that for Judaism to pass to future generations, it requires a commitment that does not bend to the trials of the time.  

 

 

Faith in the Arrival of Mashiach

Today, we require that same Emunah (faith). Logically, we don’t understand why we are still in exile. We have worked through so much, and yet we are still waiting and struggling. But just as the Jews in Shushan were victorious through their unwavering faith, we remain steadfast in the Rebbe’s promise: Mashiach is coming. Even when we cannot understand the "why" or "how" through our human sechel (intellect), our faith sustains us until the redemption arrives, immediately in our days.  

 

 

Discussion Questions

 

  1. Why did King Saul feel that sparing the cattle was a better logical outcome than fulfilling the literal command of G-d?

  2. How does Shmuel's correction, "Listening is better than the best sacrifice," apply to our service of G-d today?

  3. The class mentions that Kabbalas Ol (accepting G-d's yoke) is necessary for survival. What does this look like in modern daily life?

  4. In what ways can we strengthen our Emunah (faith) when current events seem to contradict our understanding of G-d’s plan?

Leave Feedback