3874 —על הדעה בנוגע למיקום הסוכה מחוץ לבית

On the Opinion Regarding Sukkah Placement Outside the House

יצחק אייזיק קרסיק — Yitzchak Eizik Krasik   ב"ה, י"א מ"ח, תשט"ז ברוקלין.
The Rebbe addresses a claim that it is preferable for a sukkah to be outside the house, stating he has never heard such an opinion and considers it strange. He notes that even in Lubavitch, there was a sukkah within a room whose roof was removed for Sukkos.

ב"ה, י"א מ"ח, תשט"ז

ברוקלין.

הוו"ח אי"א נו"נ כו' מו"ה יצחק אייזיק שי'[1]

שלום וברכה!

...מ"ש בענין סוכה שיש כאלו שאומרים שיותר טוב שתהי' הסוכה חוץ מהבית, ולא כענין תדורו, מעולם לא שמעתי דיעה מוזרה זו, והרי ידוע שגם בליובאוויטש היתה אחת הסוכות מלפנים חדר בהדירה שלימי הסוכות היו מסירים את גגו.

בברכה לבשו"ט.

  1. 1 קרסיק

B"H, 11th of Menachem Av, 5716. Brooklyn.

Havavch iy"a nu"n etc. Yitzchak Eizik Krasik

Shalom u'Vrachah!

...Regarding what you wrote about the sukkah, that there are those who say it is better for the sukkah to be outside the house and not in accordance with 'teishvu k'ein taduru' (you shall dwell as you live), I have never heard of such a strange opinion. It is well known that even in Lubavitch, one of the sukkahs was in front of a room in the residence whose roof would be removed for Sukkos.

With blessing for good news.


Summary

The Rebbe clarifies that there is no basis for preferring a sukkah outside the house and cites precedent from Lubavitch where a sukkah was created by removing a room's roof, aligning with traditional practice.

Leave Feedback