Support Torah
Recordings

לקוטי שיחות חלק י״ז, פרקי אבות - פרק ב

Likkutei Sichos Vol. 17 – Pirkei Avos, Chapter 2

Prev Search
0:00 0:00
Next

Pirkei Avos, Chapter 2

1. "רבי שמעון אומר, הוי זהיר בקריאת שמע ובתפלה2, וכשאתה מתפלל אל תעש תפלתך קבע אלא רחמים ותחנונים לפני המקום .. ואל תהי רשע בפני עצמך" ("Rabbi Shimon says: Be careful with the reading of the Shema and with prayer; and when you pray, do not make your prayer a fixed routine, but rather [a plea for] mercy and supplication before the Omnipresent ... and do not be wicked in your own eyes").1

We need to understand:

a) Is there any need for a directive in tractate Avos (which deals with "מיליא דחסידותא" ("matters of piety")3) that one must be careful4 with a positive Biblical commandment (or even a positive Rabbinic commandment5), and all the more so with these two mitzvos, Shema and prayer, which are fundamental and all-embracing mitzvos6 in the service of G‑d?

b) Similarly with the second clause — "when you pray, do not make your prayer a fixed routine, but rather mercy and supplication before the Omnipresent": what does it add to the explicit Mishnah in tractate Berachos7, "העושה תפלתו קבע אין תפלתו תחנונים" ("One who makes his prayer a fixed routine — his prayer is not supplication")?

c) What is the connection of the third directive, "do not be wicked in your own eyes" (that one should not consider himself wicked8, because this leads a person to despair of teshuvah and not to hold himself back from committing (another) sin), to the two preceding directives about being careful with Shema and prayer9?

2. The point of the explanation of the Mishnah:

The three directives in the Mishnah are connected with the fact that the author of the saying — R. Shimon ben Nesanel10 — was one for whom "תורתו אומנתו" ("Torah is his occupation")11, in the manner of R. Shimon bar Yochai12 (as will be explained below in section 8).

Now, one whose Torah is his occupation does not interrupt his Torah study for the reading of the Shema — as Rashbi says in the Yerushalmi13: "כגון אנו שעוסקים בתלמוד תורה אפילו לקרית שמע אין אנו מפסיקין" ("Such as we, who are engaged in the study of Torah, do not interrupt even for the reading of the Shema"); and all the more so he does not interrupt for prayer, as in the ruling12 that those whose Torah is their occupation "אין מפסיקין לתפלה" ("do not interrupt for prayer").

Since he himself did not interrupt for Shema and prayer, he had to caution his students14 that seeing his conduct should not lead them to any weakening in the mitzvos of Shema and prayer.

After that he states a second directive for his colleagues15, for whom (also) Torah was their occupation [but not on his level, and therefore they did have to interrupt for Shema (like the colleagues of Rashbi, as will be explained below in section 3)] — "when you pray, do not make your prayer a fixed routine, but rather mercy and supplication etc.": It is true that "one does not interrupt for prayer"; but "when you pray" — at the times when they do pray16 (as is known, those whose Torah is their occupation also pray from time to time17) — the prayer should not be in the manner of "a fixed routine" (that while praying he thinks "מתי אפרוק מעלי עול זה" ("when will I unload this burden from myself")18, so that he can return to his Torah study19), but it should be "mercy and supplication".

The same applies to the third directive, "do not be wicked in your own eyes" — it, too, is connected with the special quality of Rashbi (whose "Torah is his occupation"), as will be explained below in section 10.

3. On the above explanation of "be careful with the reading of the Shema" one could seemingly ask: Rashbi's view that "for the Shema we do not interrupt" is brought only in the Yerushalmi; but according to the Bavli12 (and so is the halachah12), even those whose "Torah is their occupation" — and even "כגון רשב"י וחבריו" ("such as Rashbi and his colleagues") — "interrupt for the Shema"?

The explanation of this: According to the rule20 that one must reconcile the Bavli and the Yerushalmi as far as possible (even by offering an explanation that is "somewhat forced"21), it is reasonable to say that here too there is no dispute between the Bavli and the Yerushalmi; rather, there is a distinction between Rashbi himself and "his colleagues"22:

The reason why Rashbi holds that one need not interrupt for the Shema is that "זה (ת"ת) שינון וזה (ק"ש) שינון ואין מבטלין שינון מפני שינון" ("This (Torah study) is study and that (the Shema) is study, and one does not set aside study for study")23, and (as the Yerushalmi continues, according to one answer) "רבי שמעון בן יוחי על ידי שהי' חדיד בדברי תורה לפיכך אינה חביבה עליו יותר מדברי תורה" ("R. Shimon bar Yochai, because he was sharp24 in words of Torah, therefore [the Shema] was not more beloved to him than words of Torah").

Accordingly one can say that only Rashbi himself25 did not interrupt for the Shema (as is precise in the wording — "Rashbi, because he was sharp in words of Torah ... it was not more beloved to him etc.")26, whereas his colleagues did interrupt for the Shema.

Similarly regarding Rashbi himself — one may say that there was a difference for him between before he was in the cave and the time after he came out27: his not interrupting for the Shema began only after he came out of the cave28, when the true elevation in "שינון" (study) and "חידוד" (sharpness) in Torah study was brought about in him, as the Gemara relates in Shabbos29.

And one may say that R. Shimon ben Nesanel was in the manner of Rashbi (as he was after coming out of the cave), as will be explained below, and therefore he did not interrupt for the Shema.

4. This matter — that R. Shimon ben Nesanel [OCR: "Rashbi"] had "Torah is his occupation" like Rashbi, and this is the central point of the three directives of the Mishnah — is alluded to in the fact that the arranger of the Mishnah does not mention here the father's name of the author of the saying — R. Shimon ben Nesanel with his full name (as usual) — but only "R. Shimon" without qualification, and an unqualified "R. Shimon" is R. Shimon bar Yochai30.

Now, although plainly the Mishnah has no need to specify this explicitly here — for this Mishnah follows the preceding Mishnayos of this chapter, where the "five students" of R. Yochanan ben Zakkai are enumerated31, R. Shimon ben Nesanel among them, and afterwards32 it says "הם אמרו שלשה דברים" ("They each said three things") (that each of them said three things), so it is self-evident that "R. Shimon says" here means R. Shimon ben Nesanel33 —

nevertheless, since every matter in Torah is utterly precise [especially since the directives of R. Shimon ben Nesanel are in a separate Mishnah (several Mishnayos away from the place where his name and his father's name are explicit), and consequently it leaves room for error34 for one who learns only this Mishnah35, that the author of the saying is Rashbi], it is understood that, because of the inner reason in the directives of R. Shimon ben Nesanel [OCR: "Rashbag"], what is relevant is (not the fact that he is R. Shimon ben Nesanel, but) the fact that he is "R. Shimon" (unqualified) — one with Rashbi.

5. The explanation of this: The inner reason why an unqualified "R. Shimon" is Rashbi is that the name "Shimon" is from the term "שמיעה" (hearing)36, and the true content of hearing is understanding and comprehension. And the matter of "Torah is his occupation" — where a Jew unites with Torah until it becomes his entire "occupation" — comes about specifically when his intellectual grasp (understanding) of Torah is complete, for then he becomes united with Torah (in the words of the Tanya37) in a "יחוד נפלא שאין יחוד כמוהו .. להיות לאחדים ומיוחדים ממש מכל צד ופנה" ("wondrous union, like which there is no other ... to become truly one and united from every side and angle").

From this it is also understood regarding all who bear the same name — as is known37*, the names of a Jew, and especially of the Tannaim38 etc., express the content and point of their service — that they have (at least in a concealed way) a "semblance" of the unqualified39 R. Shimon — Rashbi (whose Torah is his occupation).

And this is why the Mishnah is precise to say here "R. Shimon" without qualification: R. Shimon ben Nesanel said these directives by virtue of having within himself the quality of the unqualified R. Shimon — Rashbi — "Torah is his occupation".

6. The definition of "Torah is his occupation" in its plain sense is: (a) it is a matter of time — he studies Torah without stopping and does not interrupt for anything40; (b) it exists (also) in the study of the revealed part of Torah40*, and as we find with Rashbi himself, that even in the cave his main occupation was in "the teaching of the Mishnayos" (and not in "the book of the Zohar and the Tikkunim")41.

The Zohar42, however, states that "תורתם אומנתם" ("their Torah is their occupation") refers to those from whom "לא זזת שכינתא מנהון כל יומיהן" ("the Shechinah does not depart all their days"), and they are "דירה לשכינתא" ("a dwelling for the Shechinah"). From this it is understood: (a) the elevation of "Torah is his occupation" consists in a qualitative bond43 to Torah, such that his entire being is permeated with Torah, and his whole concern is only that he be a "dwelling for the Shechinah"; (b) this bond is not only to the wisdom of the Torah, but (mainly) to the Giver of the Torah — the "Shechinah", and such study is connected specifically with the inner dimension of the Torah, as is stated explicitly in Tikkunei Zohar44 that (specifically) "מארי קבלה .. עבדין לה דירה" ("the masters of Kabbalah ... make for her (the Shechinah) a dwelling").

This is also the basis of the way Chassidus45 explains the matter of "Torah is his occupation": the Torah study is in the manner of "ואשים דברי בפיך" ("I have placed My words in your mouth")46 — the words of Torah that the learner utters with his mouth are attributed to G‑d: he repeats the words of Torah that G‑d, as it were, says. Such a manner of study stems from utter self-nullification to the Giver of the Torah, to the point of being "a dwelling for the Shechinah".

Accordingly it is understood that Rashbi's being one whose "Torah is his occupation" is connected with his being one of the "masters of Kabbalah" — and moreover: he was the one who imparted the inner dimension of the Torah to the other Tannaim47 (which is why he was on the loftiest level within "Torah is his occupation" itself).

7. With this we will also have an additional explanation of why specifically Rashbi did not interrupt for the Shema:

In order for Torah study to be in the manner of "I have placed My words in your mouth", as above, one must first stand in utter self-nullification to G‑dliness, and this is accomplished through the service of the Shema, whose essence is mesiras nefesh (self-sacrifice)48.

Rashbi, however — and especially after he had been in the cave — always stood in utter self-nullification to G‑dliness49, as he said50, "אנא סימנא בעלמא" ("I am merely a sign") — of himself he is no entity at all, and his entire existence is only that he is a "sign" of G‑dliness. He was a "dwelling for the Shechinah" in the fullest sense, which is why it is said51 of him, "מאן פני האדון הוי' דא רשב"י" ("Who is 'the face of the Master, the L‑rd'? This is Rashbi").

Therefore he did not need the preparation of the Shema in order for his Torah study to be in the manner of "Torah is his occupation"52.

8. The Gemara53 relates that R. Elazar ben Arach asked permission of R. Yochanan ben Zakkai to repeat before him "דבר אחד שלמדתני" ("one thing that you taught me") in Maaseh HaMerkavah (the Account of the Chariot), and after "פתח ר"א בן ערך .. ודרש" ("R. Elazar ben Arach opened ... and expounded"), "ירדה אש מן השמים וכו'" ("fire came down from heaven etc."). And the Gemara there continues that when R. Yosei54 HaKohen and R. Shimon ben Nesanel55 heard of this — "אף56 הם פתחו במעשה המרכבה, אמרו יום א' בתקופת תמוז הי' ורעשה הארץ ונראתה הקשת בענן ויצאה בת קול ואמרה וכו'" ("They too opened in the Account of the Chariot. They said: It was a day in the season of Tammuz, and the earth quaked, and a rainbow was seen in a cloud, and a heavenly voice came forth and said etc.").

We see from this that R. Shimon ben Nesanel was one of the "masters of Kabbalah", and in such a way that his speaking about Maaseh HaMerkavah brought about that "the earth quaked etc., and a heavenly voice came forth and said etc." — it drew down57 the Shechinah below58. From this it is understood that he was a "dwelling for the Shechinah".

Among the above-mentioned Tannaim themselves there is an elevation in R. Shimon ben Nesanel (which is why specifically he, in the manner of Rashbi, is called "Shimon", as above in section 3 [?]):

R. Elazar ben Arach only repeated a matter that R. Yochanan ben Zakkai had taught him ("that you taught me"59), and not something he himself had originated. As for R. Yosei HaKohen and R. Shimon ben Nesanel — who expounded Maaseh HaMerkavah in a manner of "they opened"60, by their own power (and especially according to the well-known61 explanation of "פתח ר' שמעון" ("R. Shimon opened") and the like, that it means that he opened up a new matter and channel etc.) — there is an elevation in R. Shimon ben Nesanel [OCR: "Rashbi"] over R. Yosei HaKohen62:

Kehunah (priesthood — the readiness63 "to stand and serve before G‑d") — R. Yosei HaKohen — is received by inheritance. Therefore his64 "opening" in Maaseh HaMerkavah, too, is not entirely a matter of "opening" by his own power:

The complete proof that one is "a dwelling for the Shechinah" — that the person's entire being is united with the "Shechinah" — is when the opening in Maaseh HaMerkavah, in a manner that brings about "the earth quaked etc.", comes entirely from his own power. And this is found specifically in R. Shimon ben Nesanel [OCR: "Rashbi"], who is not called "HaKohen" (he was not a kohen65), and nevertheless he "opened" in Maaseh HaMerkavah in the above-mentioned manner.

9. The elevation of R. Shimon ben Nesanel's expounding of Maaseh HaMerkavah (over R. Elazar ben Arach) is also emphasized by the fact that specifically when he opened in Maaseh HaMerkavah, "the earth quaked and a rainbow was seen in a cloud" (which was a miracle, for it was the season of Tammuz, when clouds are not a usual thing66). But seemingly this requires explanation67:

The Gemara68 relates, as a virtue of R. Yehoshua ben Levi, that "לא נראתה קשת בימיו" ("no rainbow was seen in his days") (for the rainbow is an effect and a sign "שלא יחרב העולם" ("that the world will not be destroyed"), "ואם יש צדיק גמור בדור אין צריך אות" ("and if there is a completely righteous person in the generation, no sign is needed")69). If so, what is the virtue in that through his expounding of Maaseh HaMerkavah "a rainbow was seen in a cloud"?

The explanation of this:

Regarding the "rainbow" we find two matters: (a) it is a sign of the covenant "שלא יהי' עוד מבול" ("that there will not be another flood")70; (b) it is said71 of the "rainbow" that it is "דבר שהוא מוקש לי'" ("something that is compared to Me") (it was likened to G‑d), and therefore the law is72 that it is forbidden to gaze at a rainbow (because "לא חס על כבוד קונו" ("he has no regard for the honor of his Maker")73). And further, and principally, (c) it is stated explicitly in the Merkavah74 itself (which is our subject): "כמראה הקשת אשר יהי' בענן גו' כן מראה גו' הוא מראה דמות כבוד ה'" ("As the appearance of the bow that is in the cloud ... so was the appearance ... that was the appearance of the likeness of the glory of G‑d"). It is thus understood that

it is a lofty revelation of the Shechinah that brings about the "rainbow in the cloud"75.

The first aspect of the "rainbow" applies only when it comes on a cloudy day, where the clouds show that it is a day of harsh judgments76;

but the clouds (and the rainbow) that come about through expounding Maaseh HaMerkavah are (not a sign of nullifying "judgments"77, but) merely a sign of a lofty revelation of the Shechinah.

Accordingly it is understood even more how R. Shimon ben Nesanel [OCR: "Rashbi"] was one whose "Torah is his occupation" in a manner of being "a dwelling for the Shechinah".

10. One of the matters that describe the lofty level of Rashbi was his saying78, "יכול אני לפטור את כל העולם כולו מן הדין" ("I can exempt the entire world from judgment"). And since the essence and virtue of Rashbi was expressed in the fact that his Torah was his occupation, it is understood that his being able to exempt the entire world from judgment is connected with the matter of "Torah is his occupation"79.

It has already been discussed at length80, regarding Rashbi's saying "I can exempt the entire world from judgment", that this was not through his being able to influence the people of his generation and bring them to do teshuvah81, but rather that his merit was so great that, notwithstanding the sins of the generation, he "סובל כל עוונותיהם ופוטרן מן הדין" ("bears all their sins and exempts them from judgment")82.

Since R. Shimon ben Nesanel [OCR: "Rashbi"] had the elevation of "Torah is his occupation" in the manner of Rashbi, as above, his effect in the world was also along the lines of (what Rashbi said) "I can exempt the entire world from judgment".

Accordingly, the connection of the third directive in the Mishnah — "do not be wicked in your own eyes" — to the two preceding ones will also be understood:

Precisely because R. Shimon ben Nesanel [OCR: "Rashbi"] was one whose "Torah is his occupation" like Rashbi (as is expressed in the first two directives of the Mishnah), by virtue of which he protects his generation and "bears all their sins" — there is a need for the caution "do not be wicked in your own eyes":

In general, with one who considers himself wicked (and consequently will not seek to do teshuvah on his own), the conduct is "יאה עניותא ליהודאי" ("poverty befits the Jews")83 — that afflictions and sufferings, Heaven forbid, are brought upon the person, which break his ego and bring him to teshuvah;

whereas in the generation of R. Shimon ben Nesanel [OCR: "Rashbi"], whose merit shielded and protected from afflictions,

it was therefore necessary to caution specially, "do not be wicked in your own eyes" — that one should know that every person can and must and (ultimately, since "בל ידח ממנו נידח" ("no one banished will remain banished from Him")) will do teshuvah; and moreover: he need not come to sufferings etc., but can do teshuvah out of expansiveness and a life of rest, tranquility and peace.

(From the sichos of Shabbos Parshas Behaalosecha, Shelach and Balak, 5728)


Notes

1) Mishnah 13.

2) Rashi and Machzor Vitry do not have the reading "and with prayer" (see Rabbeinu Yonah and Tosafos Yom Tov). But the Alter Rebbe in his Siddur adopted the reading in the text. See below, note 15.

3) Bava Kamma 30a.

4) See the commentators on the Mishnah.

5) According to the views that the mitzvah of prayer is Rabbinic (Ramban in his glosses to Sefer HaMitzvos, positive mitzvah 5; and so is the view of most of the poskim — Magen Avraham, Orach Chaim 106:2; see Likkutei Torah, Balak 70c, end, ff.). But see Tanya ch. 53; the letter of the Alter Rebbe to R. Aharon of Shklov (printed in Beis Rebbi I, 20a (Igros Kodesh of the Alter Rebbe (Kehot, 5740) p. 32 ff.)); and elsewhere. This is not the place to elaborate.

6) For the content of the Shema is the acceptance of the yoke of the Kingship of Heaven (Berachos 2:2; ibid. 20b, beginning; and in many places), and prayer is "service of the heart" (Taanis, beginning) and "it is [a plea for] mercy" (Berachos ibid.), and more. See the commentators on the Mishnah.

7) 4:4. See Shulchan Aruch of the Alter Rebbe, Orach Chaim 98:3, and the sources indicated there.

8) As explained by the Rambam and others (see Midrash Shmuel). See Tanya, beginning of ch. 1.

9) In Avos deRabbi Nosson, end of ch. 10, this clause is not brought.

10) One of the students of R. Yochanan ben Zakkai enumerated in Mishnah 8 (according to the Alter Rebbe's version — Mishnah 9), and as it says (Mishnah 10), "They (the five students) each said three things." It requires much study in Seder HaDoros, entry Rashbi (sec. 1), which refers to this Mishnah (see there, sec. 2, from Sefer HaYuchasin). See Midrash David on Avos (by R. David HaNagid — grandson of the Rambam), who explains that the R. Shimon here is Rashbi [note that only on the Mishnah "R. Yehoshua says: An evil eye etc." does he specify and explain, "R. Yehoshua, of blessed memory, was among the five students mentioned above"]. See below in the text, sections 4–5.

11) See Derishas Mordechai (Amsterdam, 5526) on Avos, that the three directives of the Mishnah refer to one who studies Torah steadily: do not say that even at the time of Shema and prayer you should study Torah because Torah is your occupation; do not hurry your prayer in order to study; and do not say that you become a wicked person who neglects Torah — for only Rashbi and his colleagues do not interrupt for Shema and prayer, but we do interrupt. See also Zeroa Yamin on Avos (by the Chida), that the Mishnah's directive "be careful with the reading of the Shema and with prayer" "speaks to one whose Torah is his occupation" [except that there he explains that even one whose Torah is his occupation must interrupt for the Shema — contrary to the Yerushalmi brought below in the text — and must also be careful with prayer, for they too pray when they wish. He refers to his Birkei Yosef, Orach Chaim sec. 90; see there].

12) Shabbos 11a. Tur and Shulchan Aruch (and the Alter Rebbe's Shulchan Aruch), Orach Chaim, end of sec. 106. Hilchos Talmud Torah of the Alter Rebbe 4:4–5.

13) Berachos 1:2, end. Shabbos 1:2, end.

14) Who are not in the category of those whose Torah is their occupation. See Shabbos (and the Yerushalmi) ibid.: "R. Yochanan said: such as we interrupt for Shema and for prayer." Note Rema, Orach Chaim 90:18, and the Alter Rebbe ibid., 16.

15) According to those who have the reading (see above, note 2) "be careful with the reading of the Shema" (without "and with prayer") — one may say that the first two clauses are directives to his colleagues: the first — that they be careful with the Shema (although he himself does not interrupt for the Shema); and the second — "and when you pray etc.", as in the text.

16) See an explanation along these lines in Midrash Shmuel, that "when you pray" refers to a voluntary prayer.

17) See the end of Rosh Hashanah. And in Rabbeinu Yonah on the Rif, Berachos (8a), that Rashbi would pray from year to year.* See Nitzutzei Oros (by the Chida) on Zohar II 168a. And elsewhere.

*) See also Shabbos (33b): "בעדן צליי .. ומצלו" ("at the time of prayer ... and they prayed"). And although Tosafos s.v. Kegon Rashbi (Shabbos 11a) explains that "they prayed" means the Shema — it has already been asked that Rashbi's view is that even for the Shema one does not interrupt (as above in the text, from the Yerushalmi). See Yefeh Mareh on the Yerushalmi, Berachos ibid.; Birkei Yosef ibid.; Yitzchak Yeranen (Salonika, 5546) on the Rambam, Hilchos Krias Shema 2:5 — that "at the time of prayer" can be explained as the time when they wished to pray etc.; see there.

18) Rashi, Bartenura and others here. Based on Berachos 29b.

19) See also Derishas Mordechai — quoted above, note 11.

20) Yad Malachi, rules of the two Talmuds, sec. 10, and the sources cited there.

21) In Yad Malachi: "forced". But in the Kesef Mishneh before us (Hilchos Gerushin 3:18) it is as in the text.

22) Who are below his level. See along the lines of Chassidus — Maamarei Admur HaZaken Ethalech-Liozna p. 211; Or HaTorah, Vayikra p. 257; Sefer HaMaamarim 5626 p. 274.

23) Yerushalmi Berachos and Shabbos ibid. Cited in Baal HaMaor, Shabbos ibid. Tosafos s.v. Kan — Moed Katan 9b, beginning (and according to what is explained in the text, that the statement of the Yerushalmi concerns only Rashbi himself, the question of the Gilyon HaShas on Shabbos and Moed Katan ibid. is resolved).

24) So in Yerushalmi Shabbos ibid., and similarly in Baal HaMaor ibid. In Yerushalmi Berachos: "tadir" (constant). See Shiyarei Korban on Yerushalmi Shabbos ibid., that the reading "chadud" seems to be the primary one [and it follows the Yerushalmi's answer "this is study (shinun) and this is study", which is a term of sharpness, as Korban HaEdah writes there].

25) See also Hemshech 5672, vol. 2 (p. 1116), which connects Rashbi's view that one does not interrupt for the Shema with his level of "Torah is his occupation", that "he was on a supernal level and degree". See also Or HaTorah, Vaeschanan p. 79 [?].

26) And even according to the second answer in the Yerushalmi, "Rashbi follows his own view etc." — one may say that it applies only to "Torah is his occupation" on the level of Rashbi.

27) Accordingly one may explain the wording of the Bavli, "such as Rashbi and his colleagues" — until he came out of the cave.

28) See similarly Yad David on Tosafos, Moed Katan ibid. (and there, that this is why he interrupted for the Shema while he was in the cave, as Tosafos writes (cited above in the gloss to note 17)).

29) Ibid., at the end of the page.

30) Rashi, Shevuos 2b, s.v. Mishmo. Rambam in his introduction to the Commentary on the Mishnah, s.v. HaPerek HaShishi. And elsewhere.

31) Mishnah 8 (according to the Alter Rebbe's version — Mishnah 9).

32) Mishnah 10.

33) Just as it did not record the fathers' names of the other students of R. Yochanan ben Zakkai — from Mishnah 9 (according to the Alter Rebbe's version — 15 [?]) onward.

34) Note Sefer HaYuchasin (cited in Seder HaDoros, entry Rashbi, sec. 2): "Although the unqualified R. Shimon in the second chapter of Avos, who said 'be careful with the reading of the Shema', is R. Shimon ben Nesanel — something learned from its context." See the sources cited above, note 10.

35) For the division of the Mishnayos is a division according to Torah (and relevant to halachah — see Likkutei Sichos vol. 4, p. 1175, in the note, and the sources cited there) — and one must say [OCR unclear] that the study of this Mishnah as it stands on its own is a matter on its own.

36) Vayeitzei 29:33. See Likkutei Levi Yitzchak, Letters (end of p. 339), regarding Rashbi.

37) Ch. 5. And it is explained (Hemshech 5672, ch. 275; Likkutei Sichos vol. 9, p. 82 ff., and the sources cited there) that the main matter of the inner dimension is in hearing. And although it is explained (Or HaTorah, Vaeschanan p. 74 ff.; and briefly in Hemshech 5672 ibid.) that "Torah is his occupation" is the level of sight, which is higher than hearing — "אעברה נא ואראה גו'" ("Let me cross over, please, and see ...") — perhaps one may say: the "hearing" (comprehension) is in Torah, and the "sight" — in G‑dliness (within the comprehension). Note the matter of "רואין את הקולות" ("they saw the sounds").

37*) See Or Torah of the Maggid, end of Bereishis; Likkutei Torah, Behar 41c; and elsewhere; above p. 349, note 27, and the sources cited there.

38) Note the Shelah 13a ff. (in the gloss) regarding knowing the names of the six orders of the Mishnah and the Midrashim of our Sages (but he does not mention the names of the Tannaim etc. — since he is speaking about the study of the above-mentioned books; see there).

39) Similar to what is written in the Tanya (ch. 37 — 48b), that "throughout the Jerusalem Talmud it (the mitzvah of tzedakah) is called simply 'the mitzvah' ... because it is the principal of the active mitzvos ... for in all the mitzvos only one faculty of the vital soul is invested ... but in tzedakah ... all the faculties of his vital soul are invested etc."

40) See Magen Avraham, Orach Chaim 106 [?], sub-par. 4; Shulchan Aruch of the Alter Rebbe ibid., 4; ibid. 90:17; Tanya, end of ch. 23; and elsewhere.

40*) See Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim, and Hilchos Talmud Torah of the Alter Rebbe, cited above in note 12.

41) Iggeres HaKodesh, sec. 26 (143a). See Likkutei Torah, Acharei 28a: "and all of Rashbi's occupation was in the revealed [part of Torah] etc."

42) III 238b — about whom specifically it is said (Teitzei 22:6), "לא תקח האם על הבנים" ("Do not take the mother together with the young").

43) Note the matter of the Patriarchs being a "chariot", that not only were they a chariot "all their days" (Tanya ch. 23; beginning of ch. 34; ch. 39), but also "all their limbs" (ibid. ch. 23), and "they and all that was theirs" (ibid. ch. 39) were a chariot.

44) In the Introduction (1b) — "regarding the masters of Kabbalah it is said, 'Do not take the mother together with the young.'" And what the above-mentioned Zohar says, "there are masters of Mishnah" — one may say it refers to those who combine the hidden and the revealed (see below, note 47; Kisei Melech on Tikkunei Zohar ibid.).

45) Torah Or 35d. Or HaTorah, Vayikra p. 256. Sefer HaMaamarim 5627, p. 271 ff. And elsewhere.

46) Yeshayahu 51:16.

47) See Siddur 304, end of col. b; the maamar for Lag BaOmer and the one following it in the Hemshech VeHecherim 5631. "And also Rashbi's Torah in the revealed part, which was 'his Torah is his occupation' — meaning his instrument — for he knew the inner dimension in all the plain halachos, and when he studied he would draw down the Essence of the Ein Sof light ... through the inner dimension of the Torah" (Hemshech 5666, end of p. 45; and elsewhere), as is known that Rashbi combined the hidden and the revealed (cited below, note 49; and elsewhere; see at length Likkutei Sichos vol. 5, p. 129 ff.). See Likkutei Torah, Matos 84c, end. And elsewhere.

48) Or HaTorah ibid. (near the top of the page). Sefer HaMaamarim 5627 ibid.

49) See Or HaTorah (p. 257) and Sefer HaMaamarim 5627 (p. 274) ibid., that Rashbi was always in a state of self-nullification ... and [OCR unclear] specifically Rashbi, because he combined the hidden and the revealed.

50) Zohar I 225a.

51) Zohar II 38a. See the sources indicated in Nitzutzei Zohar (Margaliyos) ibid.

52) See Hemshech 5672 (cited in note 25), that Rashbi held that one does not interrupt for the Shema because his Torah was his occupation, "for Rashbi was on a supernal level and degree such that even in the revealed part the G‑dliness within the halachah shone for him" — and this stems from the intensity of Rashbi's self-nullification, as explained in Hemshech 5666 ibid.

53) Chagigah 14b. Yerushalmi ibid. (2:1).

54) The Yerushalmi ibid. has the reading "R. Yosef HaKohen" — but plainly this is R. Yosei HaKohen, the student of R. Yochanan ben Zakkai (see also Seder HaDoros, entry R. Yosei HaKohen). This is not the place to elaborate.

55) So in the Yerushalmi ibid. In the Bavli — R. Yehoshua.

56) The wording of the Yerushalmi ibid.

57) See the Siddur (75c; Hemshech 5666 ibid.) on the explanation of "Torah is his occupation" — that through studying the halachos one draws down from the Ein Sof light ... "like the analogy of the tools of a craft etc."

58) See below in the text, section 9, and the sources cited there.

59) In the Yerushalmi the words "that you taught me" are absent. But it is forced to say that they disagree about the facts — [as] in Chiddushei Aggados ibid. (in the second answer), that he said "... that you taught me" out of humility. But seemingly that is forced. See Iyun Yaakov ibid.

60) Although the term "opened" is also found regarding R. Elazar ben Arach — it is stated explicitly there, "one thing that you taught me" (as in the text). See Iyun Yaakov cited above.

61) The discourse beginning "Ki Ka'asher", 5678.

62) Note that the Bavli implies that only R. Yehoshua expounded, and not R. Yosei HaKohen. But in the Yerushalmi — "they too opened".

63) Whereas in the other tribes it must be one "whose spirit moved him and whose understanding gave him to understand etc." (Rambam, end of Hilchos Shemittah veYovel).

64) And similarly that of R. Yehoshua (according to the version of the Bavli) — who was a Levite (Arachin 11b; and elsewhere).

65) In the Tosefta, Avodah Zarah (3:3): "It happened that Rabban Gamliel the Elder married his daughter's daughter to Shimon ben Nesanel HaKohen." And since Seder HaDoros (from Sefer HaYuchasin) brought this in the entry Rashbi [?], it is evident that he held that this is the R. Shimon [OCR: "Rashbi"] who was the student of R. Yochanan ben Zakkai.

But plainly, the Shimon ben Nesanel HaKohen of the Tosefta there was an am ha'aretz (unlearned), since the above story comes in continuation of the law that "they gave him (an am ha'aretz) greatness and make agreements with him etc."* [See Chasdei David on the Tosefta there (and there: "and perhaps he is Shimon ben Nesanel, the student of R. Yochanan ben Zakkai, for perhaps he was a kohen")].

This is also somewhat implied by the fact that specifically R. Yosei is called "(R. Yosei) HaKohen"*, and not R. Shimon [OCR: "Rashbi"].

*) For one cannot say that this is how people called him until it became his name — since in Mishnayos 10 and 12 it says simply "R. Yosei" (without the addition "HaKohen"), which proves that this addition is to make known which R. Yosei this is. If so, why is R. Yosei's identifier "HaKohen", and R. Shimon's — (his father's name) "ben Nesanel"? (Accordingly, this Mishnah also proves that R. Eliezer ben Horkenos was not a kohen (see the Radal in his introduction to Pirkei deRabbi Eliezer), since here too "HaKohen" is not said of him.) But this is not a conclusive proof, for one may say that present on that occasion (though not counted among the students) was another person named Shimon who was a kohen (and [OCR unclear] one named Yehoshua who was a Levite — and therefore R. Yehoshua is not called "HaLevi" here (see the previous note)).

66) Rashi, Chagigah ibid. Korban HaEdah on the Yerushalmi ibid.

67) See also Chiddushei Aggados, Chagigah ibid.

68) Kesubos 72b [?].

69) Rashi, Kesubos ibid.

70) Noach 9:9 ff.

71) Bereishis Rabbah 35:3.

72) Chagigah 16a. Tur and Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 229:1.

73) Chagigah ibid. See Zohar I 91b; Zohar II 66b; Zohar III 84a, end; and elsewhere.

74) Yechezkel 1:28 (as cited in Chiddushei Aggados ibid.).

75) See Zohar I, Introduction (1b), and the sources indicated in Nitzutzei Zohar (ibid.) and in Shaarei Zohar (Margaliyos) on Chagigah 14b.

76) See Berachos 32b. And elsewhere.

77) In Korban HaEdah on the Yerushalmi ibid., [he writes] that the rainbow's being seen in the cloud is "to say that these words are worthy of having mercy on the earth and making a covenant over them etc." But in my humble opinion this requires study: 1) how would he explain the rainbow in the Merkavah (in Yechezkel ibid.)? 2) why liken it to the rainbow of the Flood and not to the rainbow of the Merkavah, which is our subject?

In any event, even according to his explanation one may say, based on what is explained in Likkutei Sichos vol. 4 (p. 1235 ff.), that the rainbow's not being seen in the days of R. Yehoshua ben Levi is because he was "a completely righteous person in the generation" (Rashi, Kesubos ibid.) who is involved with the generation, rectifying, refining and purifying the people of his generation; whereas the rainbow's not being seen in the days of Rashbi (Yerushalmi Berachos 9:2; Bereishis Rabbah ibid., 2; Rashi, Noach 9:12; Zohar III 15a, 36a; and elsewhere) — one may say that this is due to his virtue of being on the level of "Yesod Olam" ("foundation of the world") (Zohar I 255a, end; Zohar Chadash, beginning of Vayeira), which is higher even than the level of "בני עלי'" ("people of ascent") (Sukkah 45b), and his effect that "wherever R. Elazar would strike, R. Shimon would heal", and his saying "there is something that needs fixing etc." (Shabbos 33b, end) [note Nitzutzei Oros on Zohar I (225a), that only in Rashbi's region was the rainbow not seen];

whereas by virtue of the elevation of "Torah is his occupation", whose content plainly is involvement in Torah and not with his generation, the people (the world) around him (see Siddur 75c–d) — one may say that by virtue of this elevation there came about only "I can exempt the entire world from judgment" (Sukkah ibid.), as below in the text, section 10.**

*) Note that he brought down rain in his generation (Taanis 29b [?]) not through speech (and prayer) about the needs of the generation, but rather through Torah, and as a result rain fell.

**) In the places cited in note 49 it says that the rainbow's not being seen in his days was due to the elevation of his Torah study. Perhaps one may say that this is due to what he effected thereby upon the people of his generation (as is implied in Sefer HaMaamarim 5627 ibid. — regarding Chizkiyahu). See above p. 309 on the explanation of "די לעולם אני ואתה" ("You and I suffice for the world") (Shabbos ibid.).

78) Sukkah ibid.

79) See also Likkutei Torah, Matos 66d.

80) Likkutei Sichos vol. 4 ibid. (and in notes 40, 43). See also Likkutei Sichos vol. 20, p. 152.

81) For then the wonder is great: he should have actually done so, and not only [said] "I can".

82) Rashi, Sukkah ibid.

83) Chagigah 9b, and the commentary of Rabbeinu Chananel there.


Key Lesson

Even one whose whole life is Torah study must guard the Shema and heartfelt prayer, and must be mindful of the example he sets for others. And no Jew should ever see himself as beyond hope: every person can and will return, and can do so not through suffering but out of blessing, tranquility and peace.

Leave Feedback

{# Keyboard shortcuts: Alt+Left = previous shiur, Alt+Right = next shiur. Ignored while typing in a box or editor so Alt+arrow word-jumping still works there. #}