Support Torah
Recordings

Vayishlach – Yaakov locked Dinah in a box

Classes, Vayishlach – Yaakov locked Dinah in a box

יעקב נועל את דינה בתיבה, אמון, הגנה, ועזרה אלוקית

Yaakov Locks Dinah in a Box: Trust, Protection, and Divine Assistance

This shiur explores why Yaakov hid Dinah from Esav by locking her in a box, Rashi's explanation of the resulting punishment, and the lesson that while we must take precautions, true protection comes from Hashem. The class connects this idea to Yud Kislev and the self-sacrifice of the Rebbeim.
Prev Search
0:00 0:00
Next

Yaakov Hides Dina: Rashi’s Surprising Explanation

In this week’s parsha, Yaakov prepares to meet Esav by sending gifts, davening, and preparing for war. The Torah says he brought over his two wives, two maidservants, and eleven sons, but does not mention his daughter, Dina. Rashi addresses this omission, explaining that Yaakov hid Dina in a box and locked it, fearing Esav would notice her beauty. This is why the posuk lists only the sons—Dina was hidden away with the packages.

Yaakov’s Punishment: Dina and Shechem

Rashi adds that Yaakov was punished for hiding Dina from Esav, because she might have influenced Esav for the better. Since he prevented this, Dina later fell into the hands of Shechem. This raises questions: Was Yaakov wrong to protect his daughter? Why should Dina suffer as a result of Yaakov’s choice?

Yosef Protects Rachel: A Different Outcome

Later, when the family meets Esav, the Torah says, “And afterwards came Yosef and Rachel.” Rashi notes the unusual order—Yosef before Rachel—and explains that Yosef stood in front of his mother to shield her from Esav’s gaze. For this, Yosef was blessed, as the posuk says, “Ben poras Yosef, ben poras alei ayin.” This seems similar to Yaakov’s action, yet Yosef is rewarded, while Yaakov is punished. Why the difference?

The Difference: Taking Away Choice

The key lies in Rashi’s words: Yaakov “locked the box before her,” taking away Dina’s choice. He did not just hide her; he removed her ability to choose. While it is important to take natural steps to protect our families, we must recognize our limits. We cannot guarantee outcomes or control everything.

The Chossid on Pesach: Trusting in Hashem

This idea is illustrated by the story of the chossid who was so strict on Pesach that he would not eat at anyone’s home, not even his Rebbe’s. When he missed a farbrengen, the Rebbe told others to check his Pesach water and they found chametz. The chossid was devastated and asked the Rebbe why this happened. The Rebbe explained that a person must recognize the limits of their own efforts and rely on the Eibershter for help. Overconfidence in one’s own precautions can lead to failure; we need siayata d’shmaya—Heavenly assistance.

Similarly, Yaakov’s mistake was believing he could guarantee Dina’s safety by locking her away. The lesson is that while we must do our best, we must also turn to Hashem for protection and not believe we can control every outcome.

The Lesson of Yud Kislev and the Rebbeim

On Yud Kislev, the day the Mitteler Rebbe was released from prison, we remember how the Rebbeim dedicated themselves to helping all of Klal Yisrael, often at great personal cost. They could have remained secluded in Torah and Chassidus, but chose to help others in every way. We should strive to emulate them—reaching out, teaching, and caring for others. In this way, we merit Hashem’s blessings and protection, and the coming of Moshiach, when all the tzaddikim will be together again.

Yaakov Prepares to Meet Esav: The Missing Daughter

In this week's parsha, we encounter something very striking and, to a certain extent, surprising. The Torah describes how Yaakov prepared himself for the confrontation with Esav. He took a three-pronged approach: he sent Esav a gift, he davened to Hashem, and he prepared for war if necessary. Yaakov was ready on all fronts.

The posuk then tells us that Yaakov got up that night, took his two wives, his two maidservants, and his eleven sons, and transferred them over the river Yabok. Rashi asks: two wives, two maidservants, and eleven children—but we know that Yaakov also had a daughter, Dina. Where was Dina?

Rashi brings down something very interesting and, at first glance, surprising. Rashi says that Yaakov actually put Dina into a box and locked the box in front of her. He did this because Dina was a beautiful young girl, and he was afraid that the wicked Esav would set his eyes upon her. So, according to Rashi, Dina was not present with the rest of the family when Yaakov transferred them over the river. The posuk alludes to this: it lists only the sons, because Dina was hidden away—she was with the packages, so to speak, locked up in the box, and carried over separately. That is why she does not appear in the posuk.

Rashi: Yaakov's Punishment and Dina's Fate

But then Rashi adds something even more surprising. Rashi says that Yaakov was punished for preventing Dina from meeting his brother Esav. Why? Because perhaps Dina would have had enough influence to change Esav, to turn him into a better person. Since Yaakov locked her away and did not allow that possibility, he was punished. What was the punishment? Dina fell into the hands of Shechem.

Rashi is alluding to what the Torah relates later on: the story of Dina being taken by force into the house of Shechem. The posuk tells us that Shechem ben Chamor raped her, and the Torah goes on to describe the entire episode.

This raises several questions. First, for what exactly was Yaakov punished? Was he punished for trying to protect his daughter from Esav? He had a reasonable concern—perhaps Dina could have influenced Esav for the better, but perhaps not. Could Yaakov really afford to take such a chance with his daughter? Should he be punished for that?

Second, what does it mean that Dina fell into the hands of Shechem? That seems like a punishment for Dina, not for Yaakov. She is the one who suffered. Why should she fall into the hands of Shechem because Yaakov prevented her from meeting Esav? Why should the consequence of Yaakov's action come upon Dina?

The Encounter with Esav: Yosef and Rachel

Later in the parsha, when the Torah describes how the family approached Esav, the posuk says that the maidservants and their children came to Esav first. Then it says Leah and her children came to Esav. Finally, it says, "And afterwards came Yosef and Rachel." It does not say Rachel and Yosef, but Yosef and Rachel. Rashi notes this change in order and asks why, in this case, the son is mentioned before the mother, when everywhere else the mother is mentioned before the son.

Rashi explains that Yosef said to himself, "My mother is a beautiful woman, and perhaps that wicked man will set his eyes upon her." Therefore, Yosef decided to stand in front of his mother to block Esav's view. He went ahead of his mother to protect her from Esav. Rashi concludes that this act brought Yosef a special blessing later on, as the posuk says, "Ben poras Yosef, ben poras alei ayin"—Yosef was blessed beyond the eye, without ayin hara.

But this raises another question. Yaakov hid Dina so that Esav would not look at her or take her, and for this he is considered to have been punished. Yosef, on the other hand, protected his mother from Esav and was rewarded with a blessing. Of course, there is a difference—Rachel was married, she was Yosef's mother—but the basic concept is the same: protecting a woman from Esav. Why, then, is Yaakov punished for his action, and why does the punishment seem to fall on Dina rather than on Yaakov? Meanwhile, Yosef is rewarded for his similar action.

The Key: Taking Away Dina's Choice

I think the key to understanding this lies in Rashi's words: "He locked the box before her." In other words, Yaakov took away Dina's choice. Rashi does not merely say that he hid her so Esav would not see her; he says that Yaakov locked her in the box, closing her in and not giving her any say in the matter.

Yaakov was afraid that Dina, as the Torah later describes her, was a "yatzanis"—she was outgoing, like her mother Leah. He was concerned that she might get involved with Esav. So it was not just a matter of protecting her or hiding her; he locked her in, taking away her choice entirely.

It does not say that this is why she fell into the hands of Shechem, but what Hashem was saying to Yaakov is that although we must do everything in the natural way to protect ourselves and our families—to take all the necessary steps, to hide, to cover, as is appropriate—we must not believe that we have the ultimate ability to protect. There is a limit to what we can and should do.

The Story of the Chossid on Pesach

There is a story told about a very religious man who, on Pesach, was so strict that he would not eat in anyone else's home—not even at his Rebbe's home. His Rebbe was a great tzaddik, but this chossid would not eat there. When the Rebbe made a gathering, a farbrengen, on Pesach, this chossid would not attend, even though he was a devoted follower.

One time, as the Rebbe sat at the table with all the chassidim, he noticed that this chossid was missing. The Rebbe asked the others, "Where is he?" They explained that he was so strict that he would not even trust the Rebbe's home for Pesach. The Rebbe said, "Go tell him that if he opens the cover where he keeps the water prepared for Pesach, he will find that there is some chametz there." In those days, they would prepare water before Pesach and keep it covered, so it would be ready for use during the holiday. The Rebbe was telling him that despite all his precautions, he could not guarantee absolute protection from chametz.

Relying on Hashem, Not Only on Ourselves

They went and told the Chossid what the Rebbe had said. He came and, indeed, it was true—he found chametz where the Rebbe had indicated. The Chossid was devastated. He came running to the Rebbe and cried out, "Rebbe, why did this happen to me? I try so hard to keep Pesach, and I do it all l'shem Shamayim—for the sake of Hashem. Why was I caused to stumble? And another thing, Rebbe, if you knew that I had chametz there, why didn’t you tell me before Pesach? You know how careful I am. Why didn’t you warn me?"

The Rebbe answered him, "Of course, if I had known you had chametz there, I would have told you. That’s not even a question. But I didn’t know. When everyone was sitting at the table, and we were having a good Chassidic gathering, and you were missing, I knew something was wrong. It couldn’t be that, for religious reasons, you would not participate. So something told me there must be a problem. But if I had known, I would have told you. It was only the fact that you didn’t come together with everyone else that made me suspect something was amiss."

The Chossid then asked the Rebbe to help him do teshuvah. The Rebbe said, "You want to know why this happened to you? Because a person needs to know that he has limited abilities to make things absolutely certain. You have to rely a little bit on the Eibershter. You can’t say to yourself, 'I am guaranteed, I know that I can do it myself.' That’s arrogance. That’s putting too much on yourself, thinking you can figure out everything and nothing will ever go wrong. Hashem showed you that you can’t guarantee anything. You need siayata d'shmaya—Heavenly assistance. If you go overboard and really start believing in yourself, that you’re going to protect everything, then something wrong might come out."

This connects to what we discussed about Yaakov locking Dinah in the box. When he locked her in there and didn’t give her the choice, he was saying, "I am going to guarantee that she will not fall into the hands of Esav." But the lesson is, you think you can guarantee these things? Hashem shows us that you need to pray to Hashem for siayata d'shmaya. You need to pray. You have to do the best you can, but you still need the support of Heaven. You need Hashem to help you and protect you. If you think you can protect everything on your own, it doesn’t work that way.

The punishment here doesn’t mean, God forbid, what happened to Dinah. The punishment here is for the idea that "I can lock her up and guarantee the outcome." Hashem punished him and showed him, "No, you don’t have control over the world. The heavens are in control." Of course, you try to protect, you do your best, but there are no guarantees.

The Lesson of Yud Kislev and the Rebbeim

I want to conclude with a thought, since today is Yud Kislev, the day the Mitteler Rebbe was released from prison. He, like all the Chabad Rebbeim, did not only work for their own Chassidim, for teaching Torah and spreading Yiddishkeit, but first and foremost, their love for all of Klal Yisrael was so strong that they labored and worked with the governments and against the governments. They raised a lot of money to help many people. People were destitute in those times—they helped them settle, helped them financially, and also emotionally in various ways. Many times, they paid a severe price for it. The Mitteler Rebbe passed away at the age of 54, after going through much mesiras nefesh—self-sacrifice.

As the Rebbe writes, the Rebbeim had the ability to connect to Hashem in seclusion, to study Torah, to teach Chassidus and Nigleh. But they took from their precious connection to Hashem to help another Jew, to see to it that others had what they needed in all aspects. On this day, Yud Kislev, the Eibershter certainly allows us to get closer to this particular tzaddik, to the Rebbe, to the Mitteler Rebbe, as well as to all the Nesi'ei Chabad and all the holy leaders.

For us, it is a time to try to connect, to emulate, and to the extent possible, to follow in their directives—to reach out to another person, to teach, to educate, to love a fellow Jew, and to do whatever you can to better your community, your environment, your family. Then Hashem will certainly send us the blessings and all the protection that we need, and we will merit the coming of Moshiach, when all the tzaddikim will once again be together.

Leave Feedback

{# Keyboard shortcuts: Alt+Left = previous shiur, Alt+Right = next shiur. Ignored while typing in a box or editor so Alt+arrow word-jumping still works there. #}