Support Torah
Recordings

Torah and Tea – Lessons from Yaakov's preparations and the story of Dina

Classes, Vayishlach – Torah and Tea – Lessons from Yaakov's preparations and the story of Dina

לקחים מהכנות יעקב וסיפור דינה

Lessons from Yaakov's Preparations and the Story of Dina

This shiur explores Parshas Vayishlach, focusing on Yaakov's multifaceted approach to facing Esav and the episode of Dina. It discusses the balance between human effort and trust in Hashem, drawing lessons from Rashi's commentary and personal stories about faith, humility, and letting go of absolute control.
Prev Search
0:00 0:00
Next

Yud Kislev and the Lesson of Divine Providence

Today is Yud Kislev, the day the Mitteler Rebbe, Rabbi Dovber—the second Chabad Rebbe—was freed from imprisonment. Though his arrest was less severe than the Alter Rebbe’s, it was still a serious ordeal. The Mitteler Rebbe was 54 years old at the time, and his liberation is a day of celebration in the Chabad calendar. These events remind us that nothing happens by accident; everything is orchestrated by Hashem. When facing difficulties, we must look for the spiritual dimension, not just the material one. Hashem’s blessings come through natural means, but it is the blessing itself, not the means, that brings the solution. We must make the vessel, but always recognize that success is from Hashem.

Yaakov’s Threefold Approach to Crisis

In Parshas Vayishlach, Yaakov faces a grave threat: his brother Esav, still angry after 34 years, is coming to confront him. Yaakov prepares in three ways: first, he prays to Hashem, recognizing that every challenge has a spiritual root and requires spiritual response. Second, he sends gifts to Esav, hoping to appease him. Third, he prepares for war if all else fails. This balanced approach—spiritual effort, material effort, and practical preparation—serves as a model for us. When we face problems, we must pray, improve ourselves, and also act in the natural world, making the necessary efforts while relying on Hashem for success.

The Mitteler Rebbe’s Liberation and Its Aftermath

The Mitteler Rebbe’s vindication in court was a spiritual victory, though its physical aftermath differed from the Alter Rebbe’s. After the Alter Rebbe’s release, there was a tremendous increase in Chabad activity. The Mitteler Rebbe, however, passed away one day before the anniversary of his liberation, at age 54. Still, his case established an important legal precedent: the courts ruled that a Rebbe is not a community rabbi and may be supported by his followers, laying the groundwork for future generations. This shows that even when the physical outcome is not as dramatic, there can be lasting spiritual and practical achievements.

The Mystery of Dina’s Absence

When Yaakov prepares to meet Esav, the Torah says he took his two wives, two maidservants, and eleven children across the river (Bereishis 32:23). But Dina, his daughter, is missing from the count. Rashi addresses this: Yaakov hid Dina in a chest so Esav would not see her. For this, Rashi says, Yaakov was punished—because perhaps Dina could have influenced Esav for the better, and since she was withheld, she later fell into the hands of Shechem. This raises troubling questions: Was Yaakov wrong to protect his daughter? Why should he be punished for an act of caution? And why should Dina suffer for his decision?

Rashi’s Sensitivity to Truth and the Nature of Yaakov’s Actions

Rashi is careful to distinguish between outright deception and ambiguous speech. For example, when Yaakov tells Yitzchak, “I am Esav your firstborn,” Rashi explains that Yaakov’s words can be read in two ways, avoiding a direct lie. Similarly, with Dina, Yaakov’s action is not a deception but a concealment for protection. Yet Rashi still notes a punishment, suggesting there is more to the story than meets the eye.

Why Was Yaakov Punished for Protecting Dina?

It seems unfair that Yaakov is punished for trying to protect Dina, and even more so that Dina suffers as a result. Rashi’s comment goes beyond simply explaining Dina’s absence; he connects it to later events, implying a deeper lesson. This is highlighted by a contrast: when Yosef stands in front of his mother Rachel to shield her from Esav’s gaze (Bereishis 33:7), Rashi says Yosef was blessed for this act. Why, then, is Yaakov punished for a similar act of protection?

The Difference Between Protection and Certainty

The key lies in the details of Rashi’s words: Yaakov not only hid Dina, but “locked her in.” This act reflects a sense of absolute certainty and control—Yaakov believed he could guarantee the outcome by his own efforts. The lesson is that while we must do our part, we cannot rely solely on our own strength or planning. There must always be room for Hashem’s will. By locking Dina in, Yaakov left no possibility for a different outcome, not even the chance that Dina could have influenced Esav for the better. His punishment was for this certainty, for thinking he could control everything without leaving space for Hashem’s plan.

Dina’s Responsibility and Identity

When Dina is later taken by Shechem (Bereishis 34:1), the Torah calls her “the daughter of Leah.” Rashi explains that Dina inherited Leah’s trait of “going out,” suggesting that Dina’s own actions contributed to her vulnerability. The Rebbe notes that this trait is not necessarily negative, but in the simple reading, Dina’s suffering is linked to her own choices as well. Thus, the consequences are not solely a punishment for Yaakov, but also reflect Dina’s identity and actions.

The Danger of Overconfidence: A Chassidic Story

This lesson is illustrated by a story of a Chossid who was so careful about Pesach that he would not eat even at his Rebbe’s table, believing he could guarantee his own spiritual purity. When it was discovered that he had overlooked chametz in his own home, the Rebbe explained that his downfall came from his certainty and self-reliance. We must do our best, but never believe we can succeed without Hashem’s help. Overconfidence and the illusion of control are themselves a failing.

Balancing Effort and Trust in Hashem

In life, we must balance effort with trust. We should make every reasonable effort—whether in raising children, choosing schools, or preparing for challenges—but we must recognize our limitations and rely on Hashem. Trying to control every outcome, to “lock the box,” is a mistake. We must pray, make our efforts, and then trust Hashem to bless our work.

The Personal Lesson

Even in everyday matters, like cleaning for Pesach, we may try to ensure perfection, yet something unexpected can always happen. This reminds us that our efforts alone are not enough; we need Hashem’s help. The same applies to raising children and making life decisions. We must follow the guidance of our Rav (Rebbe), do our best, and have faith that Hashem will bless our efforts. The lesson from Yaakov and Dina is not to stop trying, but to avoid the arrogance of certainty. Success comes from a partnership: our effort and Hashem’s blessing.

Lessons from Parshas Vayishlach and Yud Kislev

Let's have a discussion about this week's parsha, Parshas Vayishlach. I want to focus on something that was bothering me as I was reading it, and perhaps we can expound on it together and get some input. The Torah is meant for us to try to expound and bring out lessons that help us come closer to the service of Hashem and to doing what's good and right. If anyone has ideas or thoughts that lead in that direction, it's always appropriate to share them.

Before we get into the parsha, I want to mention that today was Yud Kislev. This is the day that the Mitteler Rebbe—the second in the line of the Chabad Rebbeim—was freed from imprisonment. His name was Dovber, named after the Maggid of Mezritch, who was the successor to the Baal Shem Tov and the teacher of his father, the Alter Rebbe, the founder of Chabad. The Mitteler Rebbe was named after his father's teacher, Dovber the Maggid. Yud Kislev is the day he was freed from his imprisonment. It wasn't as severe as what happened to his father, the Alter Rebbe; it was more like a house arrest, not a prison cell, but it was still a serious situation with real accusations. That's why it's a big celebration in the Chabad calendar. On Yud Kislev, as well as on Yud-Tes Kislev and Yud Beis Tammuz, we don't say Tachnun, and we celebrate these days.

The Mitteler Rebbe was 54 years old when he passed away, and this imprisonment and release took place when he was 54 years old. There was a thought that it happened in the year Tafkuf Nun Zayin (5577) and that he was 53, but it turns out he was 54 at the time. Of course, nothing in the world happens by accident. Everything is ordained and destined by Hashem. Hashem orchestrates and runs everything. When there is a problem, there must be something spiritual behind it, and when there is a salvation, there must be something spiritual behind that as well.

We have to be sensitive and try to approach a problem not just from one angle. When a person gets into trouble—whether it's imprisonment, a family issue, problems with children, finances, or anything else—we shouldn't see it as just a natural phenomenon. The way to resolve the problem isn't only by using natural means and trying to fix it in a material way. There is a balance: of course, we have to work on all angles, because Hashem's blessings come through natural means, but it's Hashem's blessings, not the natural means themselves, that bring the solution. The natural means are our effort, our vessel for Hashem's blessings.

There's an old saying about a fellow who wanted to become a millionaire and prayed to Hashem to win the lottery. He kept praying, but nothing happened. Finally, a voice came from heaven: "Why don't you buy a ticket?" The point is, Hashem will help that your ticket wins, but you have to buy the ticket—you have to make the vessel so Hashem's blessings can come through. There's another story about the boat, but the point is the same.

Yaakov's Approach to Facing Esav

In the parsha, we see something very interesting. We can learn from how our forefathers behaved. Yaakov was faced with a problem: his brother Esav was trying to kill him. After all these years—20 years by Lavan, plus 14 years that he spent, as we spoke about last week, in the house of Shem and Ever—that's 34 years. Still, his mother had told Yaakov when he left that maybe Esav would calm down after some time, maybe he would forget what Yaakov had done to him. But no, not Esav. Even 34 years later, Esav was just as determined to get back at his brother Yaakov for taking his blessings.

What did Yaakov do in that situation? He prepared himself in three ways. He didn't just do one thing—he prepared all three. Of course, the first and foremost thing he did was pray to Hashem. That's the first thing: he prayed to Hashem, because he knew that if there is an incarceration, if there is an Esav, if there is a problem, we have to turn to Hashem. We have to pray, we have to better ourselves spiritually, and try to remove the reasons why these problems come to us. The first thing is prayer and turning to God.

The second thing is that Yaakov tried to make up with his brother by sending him a large gift, hoping to win him over with love. And if that didn't work, he was also ready to wage battle, to go to war. So it was a combination of all three approaches.

This is very important to remember when we have an issue or are struggling with something—not to look at it only from the material or physical perspective, but to look at it from a deeper perspective. Whenever there's a problem, the first thing Mrs. Wolosow says to me is, "We're going to write to the Rebbe." There's no such thing as a problem that's just physical; there's always a bracha, a spiritual need to do something spiritual. She says, "Let's do more outreach, let's try to bring God's word to more people." There's always a spiritual response. But of course, you can't just sit back with your hands folded and say, "God, send me the million dollars." God wants you to buy the ticket. We still have to go and do things in the natural way, try to work it out.

This is an important lesson from the parsha. This is what Yaakov did, as Rashi says. That's why I wanted to mention Yud Kislev—the Mitteler Rebbe was arrested and freed—and the lesson we learn from Yaakov's approach to facing Esav.

The Aftermath of the Mitteler Rebbe’s Liberation

This tells us that there was something spiritual happening here—it was the prayers. The fact that the Mitteler Rebbe was vindicated at the end proved that he was right, and he was given a stamp of approval. Now, the outcome was a little different in the physical sense for the Mitteler Rebbe than it was for the Alter Rebbe. After the Alter Rebbe was freed from prison, he actually opened up a new era of increased activity—he doubled and quadrupled his efforts. The impact on the Jewish community and on others was tremendous after Petersburg, after he was arrested. He moved to Lyadi, and the Chabad community flourished there until, unfortunately, the war with the French—Napoleon against the Tsar—forced them to leave. The Alter Rebbe moved, and then he passed away on the way, running from Napoleon. He passed away there. But there was a tremendous increase in activity after the incarceration. That vindication, that spiritual mandate given to him after the victory, was something he used to increase, to expand, and to burst out to the east, west, south, and north—all over, to do even more.

But with the Mitteler Rebbe, it didn’t work exactly that way, because he passed away shortly thereafter. As I mentioned, he was incarcerated—up until recently, people thought it was at age 53, but it was actually at age 54. He passed away at 54, one day shy of the anniversary of his release. So yesterday, on the ninth day of Kislev, was actually his passing. Usually, it was said that he was freed at age 53, and before the next year came—a day short of his day of liberation—he passed away. Now, because we have the original documents from the archives, we see that it actually took place when he was 54 years old. But still, we didn’t see, physically, the same kind of increase as with the Alter Rebbe.

However, something that he accomplished—one of the issues at hand—was the legal status of a rabbi in Russia. The law was that a rabbi was not allowed to take money from the community for his salary; rather, he had to be on a fixed salary. But the real question was: what is the status of a rabbi? Is a rabbi a hired rabbi of a community, or is he a spiritual leader—a leader of the generation, a different status altogether? The Mitteler Rebbe did not serve as a rabbi of a community, but rather as a Rebbe, as a head. Because that wasn’t clear, that was part of the debate. The chassidim, of course, wanted to support the Rebbe, and would provide for his personal needs on a voluntary basis, to support the house of the Rebbe. The question was: is that illegal or not? Some people argued that it was illegal for the Rebbe to take these funds because he was a rabbi. On the other hand, the courts actually ruled with the Mitteler Rebbe, that a rabbi does not fall under that category—he is a category by himself, and he is permitted to be supported by the chassidim, or by the followers who want to support him. That actually laid the groundwork for the following Rebbeim—the Tzemach Tzedek and later on—and proved the legality of their sustaining themselves. That was something very necessary. So you can say, at least on the legal and simple level, there was a lasting victory from that court case, because it turned out that this was okay.

In any event, I wanted to mention that whenever we have a difficulty, of course we have to try to figure out how to deal with the difficulties in the natural way, but we can’t forget that everything comes from Hashem. Therefore, we need to pray, and we need to increase our own good activities, to become closer and better Jews. Hopefully, together with our activities, Hashem will send His blessings and help—just like Yaakov did, combining all these things together.

Yaakov’s Preparation for Meeting Esav

Today, I want to discuss an idea that Rashi comments on here, in the preparation for meeting his brother and in preparation for war. Yaakov actually split the groups—he divided the camp and took all kinds of technical steps, trying to be savvy about how to confront his brother. For someone who might seem a simpleton like Yaakov, he was actually pretty sharp. He knew how to arrange the presents in a way that would look huge—he put each group by itself.

Yaakov's Preparations and the Mystery of Dina

Yaakov did all kinds of things to try to get his brother Esav to be satisfied with such a big gift. He was working on that, but as he was getting ready to meet his brother, he sent agents, as we learned in the beginning of the parsha. Rashi says those agents were actually angels, so Yaakov had at his disposal these angels and he sent them to Esav. He saw that his brother was coming with 400 men, and now he was going to meet Esav. It would be helpful to understand why Yaakov wanted to meet Esav. Well, I don't know that he wanted to meet him, but I know that Esav wanted to meet him. Yaakov was sending out to see what was going on, and he saw that Esav was coming towards him, so he got ready to confront him. He had no choice; he was put into that situation. He was heading back and wanted to know if his brother was still angry at him. When he sends the messengers, which are really angels, he hears that not only is Esav still angry, but he's coming towards him.

It's also interesting that we read about the fact that Hashem had just come to Yaakov and blessed him, telling him not to be afraid and that He would protect him. But still, righteous people do not rely on their merits. They always think that maybe they've erred, maybe they've already gotten their reward, so Yaakov was not sure. He was afraid. Rashi says he didn't want to get killed, but he also didn't want to kill. He didn't want either outcome; he wasn't happy with this, but he was confronted and had to prepare.

Let's look at verse 23: "And he arose during the night and took his two wives, his two maidservants, and his eleven children, and he crossed the ford of the Yabok river." (Bereishis 32:23) The question is, it says here that he transferred his two wives—that's Rachel and Leah—the two maidservants, Bilhah and Zilpah, and his eleven children. Now, we read before, in the previous parsha, that there was a girl too—her name was Dina. What happened with Dina? It's strange that the verse should specifically talk about everybody, but not mention her.

In the Midrash and in Rashi, there are indications that there were other girls as well. For example, there's a verse that states, when Yosef was lost, "all his sons and all his daughters came to comfort him" (Bereishis 37:35). What does it mean, all his daughters? There's just one daughter mentioned. So, Rashi explains that 'his daughters' refers to his actual daughter Dina and his daughters-in-law. In several places later on, when they went down to Egypt, there's a question—according to one interpretation that Rashi brings down—that actually the tribes married each other's twins, that they had twins. But that wouldn't be the main point here. The point I'm trying to make is that there may have been other people there as well that the verse doesn't mention. That wouldn't be such a problem, because since the Torah doesn't talk clearly or mention them before, we don't have to mention them now; the Torah may ignore some details. But Dina was mentioned before, so where is she?

There's also speculation that Dina would have been a male, except that Hashem miraculously, as Rashi says, turned her into a female because of the prayers of Leah, so that she should not be less than the other maidservants. But the fact remains: where is she? Why is she not transferred with the others?

Rashi has an interesting comment here. Rashi says: "And his eleven children—but where was Dina? Binyomin was not yet born, but Dina should have been counted. He put her—that is, Yaakov put her—into a chest and locked her in, so that Esav should not set eyes on her. Therefore, Yaakov was punished for withholding her from his brother, because had he married her, perhaps she would have caused him to improve his ways. And she fell into the hands of Shechem later, as we read later on."

This is really a troubling commentary. At first glance, Yaakov was trying to protect Dina from Esav. The question is, did Yaakov do the right thing by putting Dina in a box? Maybe he did the right thing. I don't blame Yaakov here. He's coming to meet his brother, who's wild, who takes other women from other men's wives—Rashi said that before, and Yaakov experienced that firsthand. Here he has one daughter, a beautiful young girl, and he knows her personality. I would have done the same thing—I would have taken my daughter and hidden her. He didn't want Esav to see her, because what would he do? If Esav wanted his daughter, Yaakov would have no choice.

On that premise, if Leah had married Esav, maybe she could have turned him around. But that wasn't up to Yaakov. The question is not that, but rather, look carefully into what Rashi says. Rashi doesn't say that she would have changed his mind—maybe yes, maybe no. If Rashi would have said that she could have swayed him, we would understand, but Rashi says "perhaps"—maybe yes, maybe no. Yaakov couldn't take a chance with that.

Someone pointed out that this was one of two deceptions that Yaakov did to his twin—the second one being that he put Dina into the box. The first was earlier. But I wouldn't call this a deception. It's not showing; it's concealing. My mother used to tell me, "You're not allowed to lie, but you don't have to tell them all the truth either." You can't lie, but you don't have to show everything you have. I wouldn't call that deception.

Yaakov does lie to Esav when he tells him that he will meet him in Seir. But there, too, he says, "I'll meet you at some point," and Rashi says he will meet him in the future, when Moshiach will come. He'll meet him over there. The posuk says, "I will make my way slowly, according to the pace of the work that is before me and the pace of the children, until I come to my master, to Seir" (Bereishis 33:14). Rashi explains that this will be fulfilled in the days of Moshiach.

But let's leave that for later, because that's going ahead. For now, we see that all these events are unfolding, and the Torah is very precise in what it tells us and what it leaves out.

Rashi’s Sensitivity to Truth in Yaakov’s Actions

We see that even when there were deceptions, Rashi always makes a point to clarify the nature of Yaakov’s words. For example, when Yaakov comes to Yitzchak and Yitzchak asks, “Who are you, my son?” Yaakov answers, “I am Esav your firstborn.” Rashi points out that Yaakov did not say, “I am Esav your firstborn” as a single statement, but rather, “I am — Esav is your firstborn.” There is a difference between outright lying and saying something that can be interpreted in more than one way. Rashi is careful to show that Yaakov did not tell a direct lie, but used words that could be understood differently. This is a subtlety, but it is important. Let’s leave that point for now, because we have a lot to discuss here, and I want to see how it all works out.

Was Yaakov’s Concealment Justified?

The question is: was Yaakov putting Dina in the box really such a strong argument against him? Maybe it was justified, maybe not. And then, we see that Yaakov was punished for it. But why was he punished? He was trying to protect her. Maybe he did the right thing. Even if he did the right thing, why should he be punished for it? This is the second time there has been a concealment. The first was with Rachel, when Yaakov did not know that Rachel had taken her father’s idols and hidden them, and there was a consequence for that. Here again, it seems he hasn’t learned; he is concealing again. According to some commentaries, Avraham also concealed his wife Sarah in a box when he came to Egypt, and when they opened the box, she was discovered. So, putting women in boxes is not new in the Torah. But the point here is that it does not seem that Yaakov was punished for deception. The punishment, as Rashi says, was because he denied Esav the opportunity to turn his heart around. My question is: first of all, Yaakov was not sure what would happen, so it doesn’t seem like such a terrible thing. Even if it was, he meant well. Why would he be punished?

I have an idea I want to share with you that I think will answer a lot of these questions, but before we get to that, let’s continue exploring the issue.

Why Was Dina’s Suffering a Punishment for Yaakov?

Another question: why is Dina’s suffering considered a punishment for Yaakov? She was taken by Shechem, forced into his house, violated, and then her brothers took revenge and freed her. You don’t have to read any novel — just read the Torah stories. It seems more like a punishment for Dina than for Yaakov. Why should Yaakov be punished in this way? Why should Dina suffer for his mistake?

And then, all the men of Shechem, who had been circumcised under false pretenses, were killed by Shimon and Levi. That’s another deception, and they were punished for it. What did they do wrong? They didn’t judge properly? All these things are discussed by the commentaries. I have an idea that I think will address these difficulties, but before I share it, I want to point out something else.

Rashi’s Commentary: Why Go Beyond the Simple Answer?

Rashi says that Yaakov hid Dina in the box. That seems to answer Rashi’s question: where was Dina? Rashi says he hid her in the box because he didn’t want Esav to see her. That part of Rashi makes sense. But why does Rashi continue and say that Yaakov was punished? How does that help us understand the story? Why does Rashi need to go further than simply explaining where Dina was? The question was: where was Dina? The answer: he hid her so Esav wouldn’t see her. Whether it was right or wrong does not seem to be Rashi’s concern at this point. Why is it important for Rashi to explain whether it was good or bad? It seems to go beyond Rashi’s purpose of explaining the simple meaning of the text. He could have just said, “He hid her,” and left it at that. Why does Rashi bring in the idea of punishment? Is Rashi trying to explain what happened later? Why did those later events happen? As we’ll see, based on what I’m going to explain, all of this will make perfect sense. There is a key to understanding this that will clarify everything.

Hiding from Esav: A Positive Example?

Before we get to the answer, let’s examine something else. Just a few verses later, it seems that hiding someone from Esav’s view is actually a positive thing — not a punishment, but a blessing. Let’s read the next verses. In Bereishis chapter 33, verse 1, it says: “He divided the children unto Leah, and unto Rachel, and unto the two maidservants.” In the next verse: “He placed the maidservants and their children first, and Leah and her children after, and Rachel and Yosef last.”

If you look at the order, the mothers always come first: the maidservants and their children, then Leah and her children, then Rachel and her children. First the mother, then the children. Now, contrast that with what happens a few verses later, when Yaakov actually meets Esav. Let’s look at how the verse states it in chapter 33, verse 6: “And the maidservants drew near, they and their children, and they bowed down.” Then verse 7…

Yosef Protects Rachel from Esav

And Leah and her children drew near and prostrated themselves. And after them, Yosef and Rachel drew near and prostrated themselves. But notice something here: the verse changes the order. It says, "Yosef and Rachel drew near." Previously, it was always the mother and then the child—Rachel and Yosef. In all the earlier cases, the mother comes first, then the son. But here, when it comes to Rachel and Yosef, Yosef comes before Rachel. What's going on?

Let's look at Rashi. Rashi comments that in all cases, the mothers drew near before the sons, but in Rachel's case, Yosef preceded her. Why? Because Yosef said, "My mother has a pretty figure. Perhaps that scoundrel [Esav] will set his eyes on her. I will stand in front of her and prevent him from gazing upon her." Because of this deed, Yosef merited the blessing over the eye—meaning that he stood up in front of Esav's eyes and protected his mother.

But wait a minute. Yosef did exactly the same thing as his father Yaakov did—he protected his mother from Esav. Rashi actually points to the difference. Rashi says that Dina could have married Esav and changed him, and Leah, of course, was already a married woman, so that couldn't happen. Rachel was also a married woman, so that couldn't happen. But the act itself—preventing Esav from looking at his mother—got Yosef a blessing. That means this was something very positive. Perhaps that's why, if Rashi says that Yaakov was punished, he must explain why, because logically, and from here, we see that protecting the women from Esav was something necessary and even meritorious—it got Yosef a blessing. So why would Yaakov be punished? This brings us back to our earlier question.

Rashi says Dina could have married Esav and changed him, but that's a question mark. It's not certain. The Rebbe, in one of his sichos, learns that it was more than just a possibility—Dina truly had the power to change Esav. But if you read the simple text in Rashi, it almost seems like it wasn't a given; it was questionable whether she could change him or not. And yet, Yaakov was punished. So all the questions remain: why was he punished? How was he punished? Was the punishment for Dina or for him? Why does Rashi have to get involved in this whole thing? Rashi could have simply said that he hid her, or that he got a blessing for protecting his mother. He didn't have to get involved in the question of punishment. What's going on? There must be something deeper here.

Incestuous Relationships in the Torah

Now, regarding incestuous relationships—are nieces allowed to marry uncles? In those days, that was very common. It hasn't come up yet in the story, but we see that in those days, not only did it happen, but for example, Moshe Rabbeinu's parents were an uncle and niece. Yocheved was the daughter of Levi, which made her Amram's father's sister. So Moshe Rabbeinu's father married his aunt. And then we have the brothers marrying each other's daughters and other close relatives marrying. But that's explained: such close relationships are prohibited today because we can't handle it, but in those days, when they could handle it, it actually had additional benefits. You can see that also for medical reasons—when there is a mixture of the same blood, it can cause terrible, devastating effects, deformities, and so on. But that's only because of our limitations. On the other hand, sometimes they say great geniuses come from such unions. But that's another subject.

Dina's Punishment and Her Identity

Let's look further. I want to show that the reason Dina was punished, as the verse says, was because of who she was. It had nothing to do with Yaakov. Let's look at the next verse—chapter 34, verse 1: "Dina, the daughter of Leah, whom she had born to Yaakov, went out to look about among the daughters of the land."

This is surprising. How is Dina referred to here? As "the daughter of Leah." Why not "the daughter of Yaakov," as she was called before? Let's look at Rashi. Rashi says: Not the daughter of Yaakov. However, because of her going out, she was called the daughter of Leah, since Leah too was in the habit of going out, as it is said, "And Leah came forth toward him." And concerning her, they devised the proverb, "Like mother, like daughter."

This seems to suggest that Dina inherited this trait from her mother. The Rebbe actually learns that this wasn't a negative thing about Leah. The Rebbe puts a positive spin on it, because we see that Leah was blessed with a child from that going out—it wasn't something negative. But in the simple, first approach of Rashi, it seems that Rashi is saying that Dina was hanging out with the wrong people, going outside, and basically putting herself in a vulnerable position. Today, people would call that blaming the victim, but the text seems to say that she put herself in a vulnerable position by going out among the daughters of the land.

Someone asked: Was Dina looking for trouble? Apparently, this going out—perhaps at the wrong time of day or in the wrong place—put her in a vulnerable situation. Another question: How old was Dina at the time? She must have been fairly young. She was born right before Yosef, so she must have been around six to eight years old at the time. It couldn't be much more, because shortly after Yosef was born, this happened. But the ages were different then; even at a young age, they matured much earlier than today.

The Danger of Certainty and Self-Reliance

The world then was not the same as it is today. But again, I want to point out that the verse seems to place the blame on Dina, not on Yaakov. It wasn't Yaakov; it seems that Dina brought it upon herself. I want to share a story that I once read, which I think is key to understanding what happened here.

The story goes like this: There was a Chassidic master who would invite his Chassidim to his court. They would discuss Torah together, share some food, and enjoy each other's company. The Rebbe would lead these gatherings.

Now, some people are very particular when it comes to Pesach. They won't eat in anyone else's home; they only eat in their own home to ensure everything is up to their standards. They simply don't eat out on Pesach. There was one particular Chossid who was so stringent and so religious that he wouldn't even eat in his own Rebbe's home. When they served food there, he wouldn't eat. But he had a problem: if he went to his Rebbe's table on Pesach and didn't eat, it would be offensive to his teacher. But he didn't want to eat there either. So what did he do? He avoided going to the Rebbe on Pesach. Pesach was the one holiday he stayed away.

This Chossid was significant and important. One time, when the Rebbe was running a gathering—a farbrengen, a get-together of all the Chassidim—this great Chossid was not there. The Rebbe asked, "Where is so-and-so?" The other Chassidim didn't know, but finally they had to say that he doesn't eat out anywhere on Pesach. The Rebbe sent one of those in attendance to go tell him something. In those days, they were so religious that they wouldn't draw any water on Pesach; they would prepare all the water in jugs before Pesach and only use that water. They wouldn't collect water during Pesach itself. The Rebbe said, "Go tell the Chossid that under the lid of one of these jugs, there's a little bit of chametz there."

The messenger went to the Chossid and told him. The Chossid checked and saw it was true. The whole world became black for him. He was so upset and so sad. He ran quickly to his Rebbe and said, "Rebbe, Rebbe, I have three questions. Number one: if you knew that I had chametz in my house, why didn't you tell me before Pesach? I violated such an important mitzvah of not having chametz on Pesach—why didn't you tell me before? Number two: why do I deserve this? I try so hard, with all my heart and soul, to serve Hashem and do the mitzvos in the most perfect way. Why do I deserve to fail so miserably after trying so hard? And third: what do I do to make up for this transgression?"

The Rebbe told him, "Number one, let me tell you something. If I had known that you had chametz under the lid, of course I would have told you. I wouldn't have hidden it from you. Actually, I didn't know. But when I saw all the Chassidim at the table, and everyone was together except for you, I knew there had to be something wrong. There can't be a positive reason for you not to participate in a place where you should be with everyone at your Rebbe's table on Pesach, when it's such a beautiful thing. I got a sort of vision from above that there's something wrong under the water, and that's what happened.

"Now, you ask me: why did you fail when you tried so hard? That's precisely the point. What Hashem is trying to tell you—and all of us—is that we're all human beings, and we're subject to failure. We can't be confident and sure, without a doubt, that we're going to succeed. That's being arrogant, that's being haughty, that's believing in yourself and your powers and thinking that you're not going to make a mistake. That's wrong. What Hashem is telling you is that you must have faith in Hashem. You do the best you can, but you can't absolutely guarantee yourself, because if you think you can do it alone, that you don't need Hashem, that you'll figure out how to do it and you'll succeed—Hashem says, no. You're just a human being. You can't succeed without Hashem. You need Hashem's input, you need Hashem's blessing, and you need to rely on Hashem and trust in Hashem."

Then the Rebbe told him what to do to make up for the transgression.

Yaakov's Certainty and Its Consequence

Now, look closely at the words of Rashi. Rashi doesn't just say that Yaakov put Dina in a chest. What does Rashi add? Two more words: he put her into a chest and locked her in. The key word is "he locked her in." Why did he lock her in? He wanted to absolutely guarantee himself that there was no way she would be able to fall into Esav's hands. He thought he had the power and ability to make sure, without Hashem's help, that he would see to it she would not fall into Esav's hands. His punishment came for his certainty, for believing that he could do it—that he could lock it up. That was his punishment. Of course, Dina was punished for what she did. But his punishment—what did Hashem show him? "You think you can protect yourself?" She fell into the hands of Shechem. Look at that. You think you have the ability to control everything. That's why Rashi brings down this whole other piece, because it goes along with explaining what was going on here.

When Rashi says he locked her in, Rashi is implying that Yaakov left no avenue for mistake. Now, for sure, Esav isn't going to get to her. Hashem says, "No, you're going to get punished." Not just punished—you'll get punished because you can't be certain. Why can't you be certain? Because we don't know if she could have changed Esav's heart or not. You're not supposed to rely 100% on your own ability to protect yourself, because there may be other plans. Maybe Hashem would orchestrate it that she should fall into Esav's hands. Don't lock her in there. Maybe she could have changed him. It's enough that there's a maybe. The maybe itself goes counter to the certainty that Yaakov had. You're saying for sure, "I know what's good."

Many times, we have to make decisions in our own lives. For example, when choosing a school for our children, sometimes we look and see that there are schools that we think would provide a better education for our children. But being Chabad, we know in our hearts that we need to send to a school which has the Rebbe's stamp on it, that has the Rebbe's name on it. That's what we know.

Balancing Effort and Trust in Hashem

Many times in life, we find ourselves compromising on what we thought we knew for certain. We might be sure which is the better choice, but deep down, we know that to be successful with our children, we need Hashem's help. It doesn't matter which school you send your child to—there can be bad influences anywhere, and things can go wrong in any environment. Ultimately, you have to rely on the Eibershter a little bit. Of course, there has to be a balance; you can't just throw up your hands and say, "It's all in Hashem's hands," and do nothing. But at what point do you say, "Put her in that black room"—meaning, at what point do you try to control every outcome?

I've seen many people who tried to lock up their children, to control every aspect of their lives, and it didn't help—they failed miserably. And I've seen others who didn't lock up their children, but rather guided them, gave them boundaries, put them "in the box" but didn't lock it. Locking up is a step beyond—it means saying to yourself, "I'm going to make sure nothing can go wrong." But you can't do that. There is still a God in the world who controls things, and whose help you need. You have to daven to Hashem. So, although we said before that Yaakov did everything he could, in this particular case, he wasn't punished for putting Dina in the box, but for locking her in. If she wanted to get out, if there was a possibility, he should have allowed for that. Do what you can, but don't try to control everything.

Why Was Yaakov Punished?

The next question is: why would Yaakov be punished for this? Why is the punishment that Dina fell into the hands of Shechem? Why would Dina suffer for something her father did? The answer is that Dina falling into Shechem's hands was not a punishment for her, but rather a message to Yaakov. It showed him that there are no guarantees in this world. You can try your best, you can lock her up, but it's not going to help you if Hashem doesn't will it. His punishment was for his certainty—for thinking he could guarantee the outcome. Hashem showed him, through what happened to Dina, that you can't control everything.

Rashi is giving us this message: there has to be a balance. Dina suffered for her own reasons, but the event also served as a lesson to Yaakov. If you force your child to do something and, at the end of the day, you're proven wrong—the more you tried to control, the less it worked out. Because you thought you could control it, you didn't trust Hashem enough, and you went beyond what was reasonable. And then you saw it didn't work out. That's the lesson here.

Why did Dina take the step she did? Because she was Leah's daughter, and she had that nature of taking initiative. Rashi doesn't elaborate; he just says "Nafla"—she fell. That's all we know.

A Personal Lesson: Cleaning for Pesach

I want to share something personal. When I clean the house for Pesach, I have this thing that I'm going to go through every nook and cranny, turn over every bed, and make my whole family crazy—as my husband can attest—to make sure the house is 100% clean for Pesach. My kids say, "You make everybody crazy!" But I feel I need to make sure it's perfectly clean.

And yet, this has happened more than once: the whole house is clean, we sit down, and one of my grandchildren takes a Lego box, flips it over in the hallway, and out comes a nice slice of bread. When I hear that story, I feel like it speaks to me. You have to have some faith in Hashem to help you along. My attitude is, "Nobody cleans like I do! I get everything clean!" And then, there it is—in the Lego box. That's exactly the point of the story. That's the lesson: no matter what, we're limited in what we can do. We have to rely on Hashem and daven to Him to make our efforts successful and to do what's right.

Trusting in Hashem and Following the Rebbe's Guidance

That's why, when it came to our own children, Baruch Hashem, I always said that the guiding principle would be to try to do what's right, and what I think my Rav (Rebbe) wants me to do—even if sometimes I thought I understood better. Recently, I spoke to someone who told me a similar story. He said, "I thought I was going to be smarter, I was going to beat the system, I didn't like this or that, and I wanted to make it better." But he ended up losing out a lot. He said, "Now, after it's a little too late, I know better. For my younger children, I'm doing things differently." He basically gave me the same point: "I thought I could figure out better, but you can't always outsmart the system."

That doesn't exempt us from trying our best, but we have to recognize that we are vulnerable and imperfect. As the Rebbe says, we need to have a tremendous amount of faith. Hashem has promised us once and twice. When we think we can protect everything, that our strength, our power, and our brains will accomplish all we need to do in our mission, and we leave Hashem out of the picture—that's exactly the mistake. Because ultimately, everything is out of our control.

Yaakov was blessed by Hashem, and to me, the Rebbe blesses the places that carry his name and his blessing. So, he's telling us: don't be afraid. Do what you can, try to improve and work, and then that's it. You're going to get my blessing. Why do you have to be smarter and try to outsmart? Go with the system, follow it, and you will be successful. And have faith.

I hope we learned something.

Leave Feedback

{# Keyboard shortcuts: Alt+Left = previous shiur, Alt+Right = next shiur. Ignored while typing in a box or editor so Alt+arrow word-jumping still works there. #}