The Unique Service of Each Tribe
Each of the twelve tribes of Yisroel had a unique way of serving Hashem. The Kohanim and Levim come from Levi, while the Yisraelim each stem from their own tribe, reflecting different approaches and specialties in avodas Hashem.
Seeing and Hearing: Two Ways of Perception
We perceive and internalize information through two main senses: seeing and hearing. When we see something, our conviction is absolute; no argument can shake what we have witnessed ourselves. In contrast, when we hear something, even from a trustworthy source, our belief is more vulnerable to doubt or challenge, since we have not experienced it firsthand.
Riya and Shmiya in Avodas Hashem
These two modes exist in our service of Hashem as well. There is a level of riya—seeing godliness—where one is so convinced of Hashem's presence that nothing can shake that certainty. This is not physical sight, but a clarity and conviction so strong that it is as if one sees it with the mind and heart. Then there is shmiya—hearing and believing, but not yet internalizing to the point of unshakeable conviction. This is a lower level, where knowledge and belief have not yet fully penetrated one’s being.
Ruvein and Shimon: Names Reflecting Avoda
This distinction is reflected in the names of the first two tribes. Ruvein’s name comes from "Ki ra'ah Hashem b'onyi" (Bereishis 29:32), emphasizing riya, seeing. Shimon’s name comes from "ki shama Hashem" (Bereishis 29:33), emphasizing shmiya, hearing. Thus, Ruvein represents the avoda of seeing, while Shimon represents the avoda of hearing.
Bar Mitzvah: Learning from Shimon
Rashi, in Gemara Nazir 43b, discusses the source for bar mitzvah at thirteen. He explains that the Torah refers to Shimon and Levi as "ish"—a man—in "Vayikchu ish charbo" (Bereishis 34:25), and tradition teaches that Levi was thirteen at the time. This is how we know a thirteen-year-old is considered an adult for mitzvos. But why is this learned from Shimon and Levi, not Ruvein?
Because at bar mitzvah, a child is not yet on the level of riya, of seeing. It takes years of growth, learning, and avoda to reach that level. At the beginning, the avoda is like Shimon—shmiya, hearing and believing, but not yet fully internalized.
Knowing vs. Internalizing: The Thief's Prayer
The Gemara gives the example of a thief praying to Hashem for success while breaking the law. If he truly believed in Hashem, he would not steal. This shows that knowing and believing is not always enough to affect our actions. We may know something is wrong or unhealthy, but that knowledge alone does not always motivate us to act accordingly.
The Chocham Who Sees the Future
That is why it says, "Eizehu chocham? Ha'roeh es hanolad"—Who is wise? One who sees what is born (Avos 2:9). True wisdom is not just knowing, but seeing—the consequences are so real that they affect our choices. If consequences were immediate, our awareness would be like sight; when they are distant, it is more like hearing.
A bar mitzvah boy begins with shmiya, but through years of effort, he can climb the ladder—"sulam mutzav artza v'rosho magia hashamayma" (Bereishis 28:12)—and reach the level of riya, where his connection to Hashem is clear and unshakeable.
The Unique Service of Each Tribe
We know that each one of the twelve tribes of Yisroel had their own specialty, their unique way of serving Hashem. That is why we have twelve tribes, all branches from Yaakov Avinu, each one a different passageway. There are the Kohanim and Levim from the tribe of Levi, and then we have the Yisraelim, each from their own tribe.
Seeing and Hearing: Two Ways of Perception
Generally, the way we get information from the outside world, so that we can understand and use it, is through two main senses. Sometimes we see things. When you see something, that's how you connect to something outside of yourself. Other times, you hear about things. So sometimes it's the power of sight, and sometimes it's the power of hearing.
There's a big difference between the two. When you see something, the evidence and conviction are like 100%. If you see something and then someone asks you, "How is that possible?"—for example, you tell him you saw a plane fly, and he says, "A piece of metal can't fly, it's not possible"—he can ask as many questions as he wants, but he can't change the fact that you've seen it. If you've seen it with your own eyes, nothing will shake that conviction. It's something you've experienced yourself.
On the other hand, when you hear about something—someone tells you about it—you may believe him, you have no reason to doubt that he's telling the truth. But because you haven't seen it, if someone comes and asks you a strong question, and says, "Look, it doesn't really fit," then you're not as convinced anymore. Someone can come and challenge what you've heard.
Riya and Shmiya in Avodas Hashem
In the service of Hashem, there are also basically these two ways. There is a level of riya—seeing godliness—which means that it's so fixed in your mind and heart that nothing in the world can shake you, because you're actually seeing it. Of course, you can't see it with your physical eye, but sometimes you are so sure of it, so convinced, that it's as if you see it. Sometimes there's an expression: you "see it with your intellect." Your intellect sees it, and you're 100% convinced.
Other times, there's another avoda, which is a person who's not yet at that level, and has a level of shmiya—he knows, he understands, and he believes, but to say that it touched him so deeply, that he's so convinced, he's not yet at that madreiga.
Ruvein and Shimon: Names Reflecting Avoda
We see this in the names of the shvatim, the tribes. Let's talk about the first two tribes: Ruvein and Shimon. Ruvein has the word riya—as it says, "Ki ra'ah Hashem b'onyi" (Bereishis 29:32), Hashem has seen my pain. Leah said this because Yaakov loved Rachel more than her. Ruvein's name contains the idea of riya, seeing.
Shimon, on the other hand, has the letters of shmiya—"ki shama Hashem" (Bereishis 29:33), Hashem has listened. So the avoda of Ruvein is more an avoda of riya, of seeing, and the avoda of Shimon is an avoda of shmiya, of hearing.
Bar Mitzvah: Learning from Shimon
This can help us understand something fascinating. Rashi, in the Gemara Nazir, daf mem gimel (43b), discusses: where do we know that there is such a thing as bar mitzvah at thirteen years old? It doesn't say anywhere in the Torah. Some poskim hold it's halacha l'Moshe miSinai. Rashi brings down that we find the word ish—a man, which represents manhood. In the Torah, we find various places where someone is called an ish. Rashi says that by Shimon and Levi, in this week's parsha, it says, "Vayikchu ish charbo"—each man took his sword (Bereishis 34:25). The Torah refers to Shimon and Levi as ish, which represents adulthood, that they were adults at the time. Rashi says, "g'miri"—we have by tradition—that they were thirteen years old at the time. Levi, who was the younger one, was thirteen years old. So the ish actually goes on Levi, that Levi was the ish who was thirteen years old at the time. Because we find the Torah referring to Levi as ish, that's how we know that a thirteen-year-old is considered an adult for mitzvos.
Now, one could wonder: why do we learn out bar mitzvah from Shimon, the second one? Why not from Ruvein, the first one? It happened to be the case, but it was made in such a way that Shimon is the one who was thirteen years old at the time. Why is that?
Based on this approach, when a child becomes bar mitzvah, at the beginning, he's not yet at the level of riya, the level of Ruvein, which is the level of seeing. It takes time, years, a lot of study, reflection, avoda of Hashem, a lot of davening, a lot of working with yourself, a lot of refinement, to be able to reach the level of riya, to be able to come to something as seeing Hashem. Up to that point, we're mostly—like a lot of times—we know, we believe, but it doesn't affect what we do.
Knowing vs. Internalizing: The Thief's Prayer
The Gemara gives a classical example. The Gemara says that sometimes a thief is trying to break into someone's home, and he's asking Hashem, "Please help me that they don't catch me." You have to ask: if you believe in the Eibershter that He can help you, why are you breaking into someone's house? That's going against what Hashem wants. If you believe in Hashem, Hashem will feed you in an honest, kosher way. You don't need to break into someone's house for that. If not, why are you davening to the Eibershter that He should help you? You don't believe in the Eibershter, so why are you asking Him for help?
It sounds funny, but the truth is, if you look at it, that's the way we are. We believe in the Eibershter, we say Modeh Ani every morning, we say brochos, but not always does what we know and believe impact what we do. We know one thing, we know it's not good, we know we're not supposed to eat certain foods, we know they're not healthy for us, but just knowing about it is not enough to motivate us, to prevent us from doing it.
The Chocham Who Sees the Future
That's why it says, "Eizehu chocham? Ha'roeh es hanolad"—Who is wise? One who sees what is born (Avos 2:9). A chocham sees; it's not just an idea. It doesn't say a chocham should know what's coming. No, it's not just knowing. You have to be able to have the level of riya to actually see it in front of you. If the consequence—if we had reward and punishment instantaneously, like as soon as you ate something you weren't supposed to, you would get sick immediately—then maybe the consequence would be right there. But if it's removed, it becomes like a level of makif, it becomes like shmiya, like hearing.
A bar mitzvah boy is not yet at that level, so you have to start with Shimon, you have to start with shmiya. Hopefully, eventually, through many years of working hard with yourself and growing up that ladder—"sulam mutzav artza v'rosho magia hashamayma" (Bereishis 28:12)—you climb the ladder, you become a more perfect person, a perfect Yid, more connected to the Eibershter. When "v'rosho magia hashamayma," then you actually see the heavens, and you're actually connected with it. Then you have that extra koyach that it takes to stay connected, not make mistakes, and do what you're supposed to.