Yud Kislev and the Chassidic Holidays of Kislev
This week, as we approach the 9th and 10th of Kislev, we reflect on the significance of these dates in Chabad history. Yud Kislev marks the release of the Mitteler Rebbe, Dov Ber, the son of the Alter Rebbe, from prison. These days are among several Chassidic holidays in Kislev, alongside Chanukah. The titles "Alter Rebbe" and "Mitteler Rebbe" originated when three generations of Rebbeim were alive: the Alter Rebbe (Shneur Zalman), the Mitteler Rebbe (Dov Ber), and the Tzemach Tzedek, who was then the current Rebbe. These names became permanent identifiers for each.
The Imprisonment and Release of the Rebbeim
Both the Alter Rebbe and the Mitteler Rebbe were imprisoned due to slander from opponents who objected to the spread of Chassidus. The intention was to halt the Chassidic movement, but as with the Jews in Egypt—"But the more they afflicted them, the more they multiplied and the more they spread" (Shemos 1:12)—the movement only grew stronger. Upon his release, the Alter Rebbe recited the verse, "He has redeemed my soul in peace" (Tehillim 55:19), which became associated with Yud-Tes Kislev. Remarkably, the Mitteler Rebbe also recited this verse upon his own release, highlighting a divinely orchestrated parallel.
The Meaning of "Pada v'shalom nafshi"—Redemption in Peace
The Rebbe explains that redemption can come through struggle or through peace. Often, overcoming the yetzer hara or personal challenges requires a battle. Resisting laziness, depression, or negative speech demands effort and restraint. However, "redeemed with peace" means achieving freedom without conflict. Both the Alter Rebbe and the Mitteler Rebbe were released peacefully, without the need for a fight. This theme is echoed in Parshas Vayeitzei: Yaakov, though forced to flee and endure hardship with Lavan, ultimately returned home in peace, just as he had prayed.
Why Did Hashem Allow the Imprisonment?
The imprisonment of the Rebbeim was not merely a personal trial, but a heavenly challenge regarding the revelation of Chassidus. The Alter Rebbe began teaching the mystical secrets of Torah in a logical, accessible way, prompting a spiritual criticism that the world was not ready for such revelations. The imprisonment was thus a result of this challenge from Above, not simply the actions of their human adversaries.
The Difference Between Revealed and Mystical Torah
In the revealed Torah, conclusions are reached through debate and challenge—questions and answers refine the halacha. In contrast, mystical teachings, such as those in the Zohar, are presented as statements without debate or challenge. The innovation of the Alter Rebbe and the Mitteler Rebbe was to make these mystical teachings understandable and accessible, bringing the hidden into the open. This shift was at the heart of the spiritual opposition they faced.
The Peaceful Victory of Chassidus
Chassidus is described as a peaceful victory. On Yud-Tes Kislev and Yud Kislev, the triumph of Chassidus was achieved without conflict, allowing the inner Torah to become the inheritance of all. Where once only a select few studied these teachings, now they are available to everyone. Even the strongholds of the Misnagdim eventually produced devoted Chassidim, and this transformation occurred peacefully. The Alter Rebbe insisted that his followers not retaliate against their former opponents, emphasizing that all must be done b'shalom—peacefully.
The Rebbe taught that when faced with opposition, we must respond with peace and not engage in debate or retaliation. Sometimes, those who oppose us do so out of their own inner conflict. The way of Chassidus is to act peacefully, focusing on the truth of Torah without contention.
Yaakov's Inheritance and the Boundless Blessing
In our parsha, Hashem promises Yaakov, "Ufaratzta yamah vakeidmah v'tzafonah v'negba"—"You shall burst forth to the west, to the east, to the north, and to the south" (Bereishis 28:14), signifying a blessing without boundaries. The Rambam (end of Hilchos Shabbos) teaches that one who keeps Shabbos receives the inheritance of Yaakov—an unlimited blessing. The Rebbe explains that, according to the Rambam, most rewards mentioned in the Torah are not true payment, but rather means to enable Torah study and mitzvah observance. The true reward is reserved for the World to Come.
The Unique Reward of Shabbos
However, Shabbos is unique. The tranquility, peace, and joy of Shabbos are themselves the reward, experienced in this world. When one truly unites with Shabbos—not merely refraining from work, but becoming one with its spirit—this unity is the blessing and payment itself. The Rebbe emphasizes that this is a unique aspect of Shabbos, as derived from the Rambam.
Unity and the Greeting of Shabbos
The Rebbe notes that when greeting someone with "Shalom Aleichem" and receiving the response "Aleichem Shalom," the exchange creates unity and peace between people. Experiencing Shabbos in unity brings tranquility and joy, serving as both a personal reward and a means of bringing the world closer to Hashem. This prepares us for the ultimate revelation with the coming of Moshiach, bimheirah v'yameinu.
Yud Kislev and the Chassidic Holidays of Kislev
This week, we are learning Torah and Tea for Parshas Vayeitzei. As you know, tonight is already the 8th of Kislev, and we are coming up to the 9th and 10th. The 8th will be on Wednesday, Thursday is the 9th, and Friday is the 10th. What is so special about the 9th and 10th of Kislev?
We are going to talk today about Parshas Vayeitzei, of course, which is the parsha of the week. Our discussion is based on Likkutei Sichos, Volume 25, Yud Kislev, and also Volume 30, Vayeitzei 1. We will talk about two sichos. Just so you know, the month of Kislev has a lot of holidays, a lot of Chassidic holidays. Of course, it has Chanukah, but it also has many Chassidic holidays. One of them is called Yud Kislev. What is Yud Kislev? Yud Kislev is the day that the Mitteler Rebbe—Mitteler Rebbe means the Mitteler Rebbe—was released from prison. The Mitteler Rebbe's name was Dov Ber. He was the son of the Alter Rebbe. What does Alter Rebbe mean? Alter Rebbe means the Old Rebbe.
Why do we call him the Old Rebbe and the Mitteler Rebbe? These were names used when Chabad had three Rebbeim at that time. The third Rebbe, who was then called the current Rebbe, and then the Rebbe before him, called the Mitteler Rebbe, meaning the Mitteler Rebbe, and then the Alter Rebbe, the Old Rebbe. So, Schneur Zalman was the Old Rebbe, the Mitteler Rebbe was Dov Ber, and the Tzemach Tzedek was the current Rebbe at that time. These names stuck to them. So, whenever we say the Mitteler Rebbe, we are talking about the second Lubavitcher Rebbe, Dov Ber. Whenever we talk about the Alter Rebbe, the Old Rebbe, that is Shneur Zalman, the founder, the very first Rebbe. And at that time, the present Rebbe was the Tzemach Tzedek.
The Imprisonment and Release of the Alter Rebbe and Mitteler Rebbe
Now, I want to talk about something very interesting. It seems almost a coincidence, but of course, nothing is a coincidence. The Alter Rebbe was put into jail. Why was the Alter Rebbe put into jail? Because they slandered the Alter Rebbe. There were some Jewish people, so-called religious people, who did not like what the Alter Rebbe was doing. They did not think that the Alter Rebbe should be teaching Chassidus. They did not like it. This is nothing new. If you look around us today, no two Jews can agree on anything, so it is not surprising. Even people who call themselves religious sometimes do terrible things. Sometimes we wonder when we see people dressed in very Chassidic garb going together with the Palestinians to demonstrate. It is very chilling when you see those pictures. You ask, how could you join our greatest enemies and go together with them? But there are frum people, so-called frum people, who do things that blow our minds and we cannot understand.
Even if people have disagreements and differences of opinion, and that is okay, but when it deteriorates to the point where people start slandering to the government and really hurting other people, it is no joke. In some of these cases, there was even death involved from the suffering caused by the opponents. So, they slandered the Alter Rebbe because they hoped that by doing so, they could curb and stop the Chassidic movement from spreading. But as you know, as it says in the verses, when the Egyptians tried to stop the Jews, "But the more they afflicted them, the more they multiplied and the more they spread" (Shemos 1:12). The same thing happened with the Chassidim. The more the opponents, the Misnagdim, tried to stop them, the more they grew in numbers.
In any event, they did put the Alter Rebbe into prison. The Alter Rebbe said that when he was reading in Tehillim, he came to the verse in which it states, "He has redeemed my soul in peace" (Tehillim 55:19). We have a song that we sing on Yud-Tes Kislev, which is the song, "Pada v'shalom nafshi"—He has redeemed my soul in peace. What does it mean? The Alter Rebbe was basically saying that he was released in a peaceful way from prison. After all that he suffered there, there were no fights; he was freed. Even the nations of the world recognized that the Alter Rebbe was a holy man and that all this was slander. He ended up going out with honor. Not only did they not punish him, but on the contrary, they gained a lot of respect for the Alter Rebbe. At the moment that they freed him, he said that verse.
Very interestingly, his son, the Mitteler Rebbe, Dov Ber, was also put in jail. There were a little different circumstances, but the main reason people slandered the Mitteler Rebbe was also the same—they hated the Chassidim and tried to stop the Alter Rebbe, and then they tried to stop the Mitteler Rebbe. They succeeded a little bit. But it is also said that when the Mitteler Rebbe was released, he said the verse, "Pada v'shalom nafshi"—He has redeemed my soul in peace. That is the verse in Tehillim, chapter 55, verse 19. So, look at this coincidence—it seems like a coincidence, but everything is divinely orchestrated. Both the Alter Rebbe and the Mitteler Rebbe said that verse, "Pada v'shalom nafshi."
The Meaning of "Pada v'shalom nafshi"—Redemption in Peace
The Rebbe goes through and explains a lot about this verse. First, the Rebbe says that sometimes you have to fight for your freedom. Sometimes it takes a battle. If you have an enemy, sometimes you cannot get rid of him unless you go out to war with him. Let's take it in our own selves. We have certain tendencies or learned behaviors that become very difficult for us, and we have to battle the yetzer hara—the evil inclination. The yetzer hara makes us lazy, it depresses us, it tries to bring us down. You know how many people today are fighting depression, fighting anxiety, fighting all kinds of things? They have to battle it. If they do not battle, if they do not fight it, they fail, they fall. And once they fall, they fall deeper and deeper. They stop functioning and they are in big trouble.
Sometimes you have to battle to get your freedom. If you want to free yourself from your yetzer hara, from the evil inclination, you have to battle. Sometimes it is a struggle. You do not want to get out of bed, you do not want to go to class, you are lazy, you are tired—all kinds of different things. But we have to fight. We have to restrain ourselves. Even holding back from a good piece of lashon hara—gossip—or a good piece of negative information about someone, to hold back and not do it, takes restraint. Sometimes you have to battle. It is hard. It is hard work.
Redemption Through Peace Versus War
When we say someone was redeemed with peace, it means there was no need for a battle. In the case of the Alter Rebbe, they did not have to fight; he was let out in a peaceful way. The same was true for the Mitteler Rebbe. We also see this idea in our parsha. Look at what happened with Yaakov. The Mitteler Rebbe’s freedom on Yud Kislev, the tenth of Kislev, is always associated with the portion of Vayishlach. But even in Vayeitzei, this theme appears. The theme of Vayeitzei is similar to being imprisoned and then going free. Originally, Esav was trying to kill Yaakov, so Yaakov had to run away. He had to escape to a strange country, a strange land, and deal with his uncle Lavan, who was a thief, a cheater, and a deceiver. Yaakov had to deal with him. That is like going into jail—Yaakov, who was simple and innocent, who followed Hashem’s ways and the ways his parents, Avraham and Yitzchak, taught him, had to run away. He had to go away. That’s like going to jail, going to another place.
But in the end, he actually goes home. The beginning is incarceration, but then he goes home. Before he left, Yaakov prayed to Hashem. He asked, "I want to return in a peaceful way." What does it mean, in a peaceful way? While he suffered over there, he didn’t have to fight with Lavan. Even with Esav, later on, he didn’t have to fight him. He thought he might have to fight, but in the end, he didn’t have to. So when he prayed to Hashem, "let me return in peace," he did return in peace.
The same thing happened with the Mitteler Rebbe. When he was freed, it was in a peaceful way. He suffered, but it was still done peacefully. This demonstrates that there are two ways to win: through war or through peace. You can win both ways. If you have to fight, it’s more difficult—there’s energy, you lose people, you wage war, there is damage and pain. But when you redeem in a peaceful way, it means you don’t lose anybody, you don’t have to fight, you win the battle without actually battling.
Why Did Hashem Allow the Imprisonment?
What’s the connection between the Alter Rebbe and the Mitteler Rebbe being freed with peace and this idea of going out of prison peacefully? We have to understand that what happened to the Alter Rebbe and the Mitteler Rebbe—the fact that they were taken into jail—could not have happened without Hashem wanting it to happen. Nothing happens without Hashem. Why were their enemies able to succeed with their slander? Nothing can happen if Hashem doesn’t agree. So why did Hashem actually agree that the Alter Rebbe should go to prison? Why did Hashem agree that the Mitteler Rebbe should go to prison?
The answer is that there was a criticism against the Alter Rebbe. There was a challenge. The Alter Rebbe started explaining very deep secrets of the Torah in a very logical way. Therefore, there was a decree. The Satan and the criticism was that the world isn’t ready for the mystical teachings to become revealed. The Alter Rebbe was teaching mystical teachings, revealing them. But why is it called mystical? Why is it called mysticism? Because it’s hidden, it’s not open. The Alter Rebbe was taking mysticism and making it open. There was a criticism that the world was not ready for that. Therefore, from above, they agreed to arrest the Alter Rebbe—maybe to stop him, maybe he should not be teaching and revealing so many hidden secrets. So this was from Hashem.
However, this was not a challenge to the personal lives of the Alter Rebbe and the Mitteler Rebbe. This was a challenge to their teachings, to the revealing of secrets of the Torah. That’s what it was—it wasn’t just a personal matter.
The Difference Between Revealed and Mystical Torah
What is it about the teaching of the mystical part of Torah? How is the mystical part of Torah different from the regular part of Torah? In the regular, revealed Torah, how do you come to conclusions? Someone sets forth an idea, and then you ask, “What do you think the ruling should be in this case?” One rabbi says, “I think this is the ruling.” Another rabbi challenges, “How could you possibly say that? In another place, it says differently.” So the first rabbi says, “We have to make a distinction. These two cases are a little different.” Then the rabbi shows how it’s different. But the challenge comes back: “Still, it doesn’t fit. How come?” You go back and forth. Finally, after going back and forth, you come to a conclusion and say, “Now we know what the halacha is. This is the halacha.”
How did you get to the halacha? You came to the ruling by having to negate and make your way through all the obstacles, the challenges, the questions. Every question is a challenge, meaning that’s the enemy of the idea. You have an idea, and then you have the enemy putting down a challenge and saying, “Maybe not.” Then you try to put the enemy out of the way—metaphorically, of course. We’re not talking about real enemies, but about ideas. The way we learn regular Torah is that you come to conclusions by dealing with questions, answers, and challenges, and eventually you figure out the right answer. That’s the way we learn the revealed part of Torah.
But with mysticism, we don’t have that whole series of questions and answers. In the mystical, in the Zohar and other places, they just tell you the statements as they are. There are no questions, no challenges, no debate—it’s just facts, giving you the situation the way it is. The challenge to the Alter Rebbe and the Mitteler Rebbe was that they were trying to get this mystical teaching understood in the same way as the revealed part of Torah. They tried to bring it down, because initially, most people would just read it, accept it, and go by it; it wasn’t challenged or questioned. The fact that the Alter Rebbe and the Mitteler Rebbe brought it down into understanding meant that something was going to change now—the secret was coming into the open.
The Peaceful Victory of Chassidus
This is why Chassidus is called a peaceful victory. On Yud-Tes Kislev and Yud Kislev, the victory was achieved in a way of peace. The inner part of Torah was allowed to continue and became the inheritance of everyone—now, everyone can learn it. In the olden days, only a select few would study these teachings, but today, Chassidus is accessible to all. What does it mean to win the war here? It means that we all have Chassidus today—all the teaching, all the learning, and all the revelation that we have from the Rebbe and from all the previous Rebbeim. This is the victory we celebrate on Yud Kislev and Tes Kislev.
But it was accomplished in a peaceful way. Just as Chassidus is the peaceful part of Torah, it was brought down into the world in a peaceful manner. This is a very important lesson: to do things in a peaceful way. Sometimes, when you have to deal with opponents—when people reject you or your ideas—the natural response is to want to give back, not to stay silent. For example, after what the opponents did to the Alter Rebbe, putting him into jail, there was a temptation to retaliate once they were victorious. But the Alter Rebbe warned his followers: we are not going to give back. The idea was that it should be b'shalom—in a peaceful way.
Even the fortresses of the Misnagdim, places where Chassidim were never allowed and never thought they would be accepted, eventually turned around. Some of the strongest followers of the Alter Rebbe and the Mitteler Rebbe came from these strongholds of the Misnagdim, the opponents. Yet, it was all done in a peaceful way. What does it mean in a peaceful way? Yes, there were some difficulties, but generally speaking, it was b'shalom nafshi—in a peaceful way, both for the Alter Rebbe and for the Mitteler Rebbe.
I think this is one of the messages for us. We have a lot of work to do, but the Rebbe always emphasizes that everything has to be done pleasantly and peacefully. Even when we think we have a reason to respond, we must act peacefully. I read a letter this morning: imagine someone who discovers that his lineage comes from real Misnagdim—opponents who did terrible things to the Rebbe. Here is a person who is now a Chossid of the Rebbe, and suddenly he finds out that his ancestors, way back, were terrible Misnagdim who did terrible things to the Alter Rebbe. He writes to the Rebbe, heartbroken, trying to explain his feelings.
The Rebbe answered him: besides the fact that, over many generations, everyone has already done teshuvah—they have repented and there is nothing left—but besides that, the Rebbe said, you have to fix something in the place where it was broken. If you want to do something, since your ancestors interfered with Chassidus, your job is to spread Chassidus even more, above and beyond, and do a lot. Many people who became close to the Rebbe or to Chassidus experienced trouble from their families or friends. Suddenly, people ask, "What happened to you? Why are you joining those Lubavs? Why are you going with those Chabadniks?" For those joining, it can be difficult. They wrote to the Rebbe about these problems. It's not always b'shalom as we're talking about; sometimes there are real difficulties.
The Rebbe always said very clearly and strongly: never give back, don't get into debates. The Rebbe made an interesting comment—many times, the people who oppose you and say things against you do so because they have a guilty conscience. They feel that they themselves should be more involved, but instead, they criticize you. It's their way of expressing frustration with themselves for not doing what they should. But the Rebbe never allowed giving back; he always said to do everything in a peaceful way. That is the way of Chassidus—peace. There are no questions, no answers, just the Torah of Hashem, which is the real thing we strive for.
Yaakov's Inheritance and the Boundless Blessing
Let me share something quickly from the parsha. Yaakov is the third of the forefathers. Hashem promised the land to Avraham, Yitzchok, and Yaakov. Each one received the promise in a different wording. Avraham received it in a limited way—Hashem told him to go to the land, describing its width and boundaries. Yitzchok also received a promise. But to Yaakov, what did Hashem say in the parsha? He said, "Ufaratzta yamah vakeidmah v'tzafonah v'negba"—"You shall burst forth to the west, to the east, to the north, and to the south" (Bereishis 28:14). There are no boundaries.
The Rambam (end of Hilchos Shabbos) says that one who keeps Shabbos receives the inheritance of Yaakov—a boundary-less inheritance, with no limits. You get everything; there are no boundaries to the blessings. If you keep Shabbos, you receive an endless amount of blessing. The Rebbe explains that this is a reward that you get in this world.
The Rebbe makes a very strong point here. Normally, the Rambam writes (Hilchos Teshuvah, chapter 8) that there is no reward in this world; all the reward is in the World to Come. In this world, there is no true reward. So how do we find in the Torah so many rewards? The Torah says that if you are good, you will be rewarded. The Rambam explains that all the rewards in the Torah are not payment in the sense of true reward. When the Torah says that if you do mitzvos you will be rewarded, the good things the Torah promises are not the actual reward. Rather, they are so that you will have the opportunity to study Torah and do mitzvos. If you are healthy and can afford it, then you can learn Torah and do the right things. So if Hashem blesses you with health, with financial means, with good feelings—everything you ask for from Hashem—what do you use those good things for? They are not the reward; they are just the means. When we have them, we are able to serve Hashem because things are easier for us and we can serve Hashem properly.
The Unique Reward of Shabbos
Imagine if I am worried about how I am going to pay my rent, or I do not know where I am going to sleep tonight, or I am worried about how I am going to marry off my child, or whatever worries you may have. When your mind is not free, you cannot sit and study because your head is full of worries. The Rebbe explains that the promises the Torah gives us are not payments for what we did; rather, Hashem is giving us an opportunity by taking away the distractions so that we will be able to learn Torah. The true reward will come in the World to Come.
However, there is one exception according to the Rambam, as the Rebbe explains: the mitzvah of keeping Shabbos. The Rebbe says that from the Rambam it is clear that the reward of Shabbos—the tranquility of Shabbos, the peace of Shabbos, the joy of Shabbos—is a payment in this world. It is similar to the payment we receive in the World to Come; it is actually a reward. When a person keeps Shabbos, that is their payment. You do not have to get something else; the greatest payment, the greatest reward, and the greatest blessing is Shabbos itself. When you keep Shabbos, that is the blessing, and that is a blessing in this world. It is not only a means of not being distracted by the world, but it is actually a payment.
The Rebbe therefore learns from the Rambam, with a whole lengthy explanation, that this is unique to the mitzvah of Shabbos. If you experience Shabbos and you become one with Shabbos—not just doing work or not doing work, but truly uniting with Shabbos—you receive this unique reward. You have to become one with Shabbos.
Unity and the Greeting of Shabbos
The Rebbe brings an interesting point about how, when you greet someone, you say "Shalom Aleichem," and when the other person responds, he says "Aleichem Shalom." He does not say "Shalom Aleichem" back; he responds with the opposite. The Rebbe explains that we try to make from the many—from two people—we want to make Shalom, to bring them together. When the other person responds, there are already two, so he brings Shalom to them. The Rebbe goes into a long explanation, but the point here is that when you experience Shabbos in a way that you are not just doing or not doing, but you unite with it, you bring down the feeling, the tranquility, the joy, and the honor of Shabbos, and you really begin to experience it.
Guess what? That is your payment. That is a reward, because people who have never experienced Shabbos—the tranquility of Shabbos—do not realize the benefits, the joy, the reward, or the merit. But if you do it, and you do it with unity with Shabbos, that in itself is the Shalom. This is all about bringing the world together, bringing people together, bringing us together with HaKadosh Baruch Hu, and preparing the world for the ultimate revelation with the coming of Moshiach, bimheirah v'yameinu.