Yaakov Sends Malachim: Messengers or Angels?
At the start of Parshas Vayishlach, the Torah says, "Vayishlach Yaakov malachim"—Yaakov sent malachim. The word malachim can mean either messengers or angels. Rashi explains that Yaakov sent actual angels—"malachim mamesh"—to Esav to find out his intentions.
Yaakov had just escaped Lavan after 20 difficult years, only to face a new threat: Esav, who still harbored anger from decades earlier. Although Yaakov originally fled to Lavan to escape Esav’s wrath, even after 36 years, Esav’s anger had not subsided, as Rashi brings from the Midrash. Now, Yaakov is confronted with Esav coming toward him with 400 men.
Yaakov's Fear Despite Hashem's Promise
Despite Hashem’s recent promise to protect him, Yaakov was afraid. The Gemara and Rashi discuss why: even the righteous, the tzaddikim, do not rely on their merits. Yaakov considered that perhaps Hashem’s promise had already been fulfilled—Hashem had protected him from Lavan—or perhaps, as Rashi later says, he had sinned and was no longer worthy. Yaakov did not doubt Hashem’s promise; rather, he was unsure if it still applied to him.
This humility is seen in Yaakov’s words: "Katonti mikol hachassadim"—"I have been diminished by all the kindness and truth You have done with Your servant." He recalls how he crossed the Jordan with nothing, and now, with Hashem’s help, he has become wealthy. Yet, he asks Hashem, "Hatzileini na miyad achi, miyad Esav"—"Save me from my brother, from Esav." Yaakov’s fear was not only for himself; he also did not want to harm Esav or anyone else. He prepared for three possibilities: sending a gift, praying to Hashem, and preparing for war if necessary.
Lessons from Yaakov’s Approach to Esav
Yaakov’s approach teaches us that when seeking Hashem’s help, we should not feel entitled, but instead humble ourselves and ask for His mercy. We should also prepare by giving tzedakah and acting through derech ha’teva—the natural order. This means making efforts to resolve problems peacefully, but also being ready to defend ourselves if needed. At the same time, as seen from Yud-Tes Kislev, sometimes just standing strong with confidence in Hashem brings success without even needing to fight.
The Value of Every Human Life
Yaakov’s reluctance to harm Esav, even when threatened, highlights the Torah’s value for every human life. The Lubavitcher Rebbe emphasized that even in war, efforts should be made to minimize casualties on all sides. The goal is not only victory, but to avoid unnecessary loss of life. When tragedy strikes, even among enemies, we should feel sadness and compassion, recognizing the pain of every human being.
May Hashem help bring peace, goodness, and the coming of Moshiach Tzidkeinu speedily in our days. Amen.
Yaakov Sends Malachim: Messengers or Angels?
Today we started reading the portion of Vayishlach. The opening verse is very interesting: "Vayishlach Yaakov malachim"—Yaakov sent malachim. The word malachim in Hebrew can have two meanings. Malachim can mean messengers, or it can mean angels. A malach is an angel, but a malach can also mean a messenger.
Yaakov was constantly in trouble. He had just finished his sojourn with Lavan, where he lived for 20 years. He finally got out, but Lavan was chasing him, and Lavan did everything bad to him. As Yaakov is leaving Lavan, he hears that now Esav is coming. Originally, why did Yaakov go to Lavan? Because he was afraid of Esav. After taking the firstborn blessings from Yitzchak, Esav wanted to kill him. His mother advised him to go away until the anger of his brother would subside, until Esav would forget what Yaakov had done to him and would no longer bother him.
But Esav the wicked was so angry that his anger did not subside. The anger didn't stop all these years, even 20 years later. As a matter of fact, it was actually 36 years later. Rashi brings down, according to the Midrash, that there were an additional 14 years that are not mentioned in the posuk. So 36 years later, Esav is still angry and still ready to go and kill his brother. Now, Yaakov is finally done with Lavan, and now he is faced with the danger of Esav.
It says, "Vayishlach Yaakov malachim"—Yaakov sent malachim. What does this mean? Rashi translates right away: "malachim mamesh"—he actually sent actual angels. Imagine, Yaakov had at his disposal actual angels. It wasn't just messengers; Rashi says it was really angels. He sent these angels to his brother to find out what was going on, what was happening, how things stood with Esav.
The angels came back and told him about his brother. They said, "We came to your brother, to Esav, and he is coming to meet you with 400 men."
Yaakov's Fear Despite Hashem's Promise
What does Yaakov do? It says that Yaakov was afraid. Why was Yaakov afraid? Hashem had just appeared to Yaakov in the previous parsha, in his dream, and told him, "Don't be afraid, I will be with you, I will protect you." So why is Yaakov suddenly afraid?
The Gemara brings this down, and Rashi brings it a little bit later as well. Even the righteous people, the tzaddikim, who serve Hashem with all their heart and mind and try their best, never rely or count on their merits. Especially in this case, Yaakov thought to himself: even though Hashem promised him, even though Hashem told him He would protect him, maybe Yaakov had already received all the payment for the good deeds he had done. Maybe now it is a new era, and maybe the promise would not continue to protect him. He didn't rely on his privileges.
Although, it's a little bit schwer in the pshat, and I'm just throwing this out, because Hashem's promise to him wasn't that long ago—it was right in the parsha. When you read at the end of Parshas Vayetze, Hashem promises him. It seems like these stories, there wasn't really much time in between. This was a promise that Hashem gave him right at the end of the last parsha, when Hashem says He will protect him. So it seems that even from a promise which comes fairly recently, even on that they don't rely.
There's a big difference here. It's not, God forbid, that Yaakov doubted Hashem's promise. He thought that Hashem's promise—Hashem kept. There is no question that Hashem always keeps His promise. Yaakov wasn't doubting or afraid because of Hashem's promise. Rather, he thought that Hashem's promise may have already been fulfilled, and therefore it would not apply anymore—not because Hashem would not keep His promise, but because maybe things had happened since then.
I think Rashi brings this down as well. There are two things. In the Gemara, I believe the language is that Yaakov thought maybe he had already gotten paid for it, maybe he had already received all the rewards, so that's it—for the promise of Hashem's protection, he already got it. Hashem protected him from Lavan, so Hashem already fulfilled the promise. That's the language in the Gemara. But in Rashi, later on, the language is that Yaakov thought, "Maybe I've done something wrong, maybe I've made a mistake."
I think that Rashi in the Chumash, who teaches according to the simple meaning, doesn't think that Hashem's promise, which came so close beforehand, could have already been fulfilled, because the promise just happened now. How could it already be fulfilled? It just took place right then and there. Therefore, Rashi says that Yaakov thought, "Maybe I've done something wrong."
This shows us the level of a tzaddik. Even though they have a right and privileges, and technically they could demand from Hashem and say, "You owe it to me," nevertheless, they never use that kind of attitude toward Hashem, that He owes it to them. They always beseech Hashem, asking for His favor and kindness.
In his expression to Hashem, Yaakov says, "Katonti mikol hachassadim"—"I have been diminished by all the kindness and all the truth that You have done with Your servant." "Ki v'makli avarti es hayardein hazeh"—"For with my staff I crossed this Jordan." He had nothing, as Rashi explains. Elifaz, Esav's son, chased after him and took away everything that he owned. He came with zero, and now he has two camps—God has helped him. So he asks Hashem, "Hatzileini na miyad achi, miyad Esav"—"Protect me from my brother Esav," who doesn't want to treat him like a brother, but wants to treat him like an Esav.
There was something else, as Rashi says—not only was Yaakov afraid for himself, but Yaakov also didn't want to hurt anybody else. He wasn't only afraid that he would get hurt; he didn't want to hurt anybody, and he didn't want to kill Esav either. Yaakov wasn't someone who wanted to show Esav who was stronger; he wanted to actually avoid and get away. As we say, he prepared himself for a gift—he brought Esav a nice gift, maybe he would accept it. He prepared himself with prayer—he davened to Hashem to help him. But he also prepared himself for war. He got ready, in case he needed to, to fight Esav and be victorious.
Lessons from Yaakov’s Approach to Esav
There is a powerful lesson for us in how Yaakov prepared himself to meet Esav. Whenever we need Hashem’s help, for anything in life, the first thing is to remember that we should never approach Hashem with the attitude that He owes us something. We must always humble ourselves before Hashem and ask for His mercy, recognizing that even if we are not deserving, we still turn to Hashem and ask for His kindness.
At the same time, we should always be ready with a gift—meaning, we should always give tzedakah, charity. This is part of our preparation when we seek Hashem’s help. And most importantly, we must recognize that the Eibershter wants us to act through derech ha’teva—the natural order. If we have to stand up and fight our enemies, especially in Eretz Yisroel or in places where people want to do harm, of course Hashem protects us, but Hashem also wants us to do what is necessary in the natural way. We prepare ourselves, we try to work things out, we try to make peace, and we try to do things in a nice way. But at the end of the day, if we need to go to war, we must be ready for that as well.
However, as we learned from Yud-Tes Kislev, sometimes you don’t even need to come to war. The fact that you are strong and confident, and you know that with Hashem’s help you will be successful no matter what, that itself brings success. When you stand strong, you are victorious, and you don’t even need to fight the war.
The Value of Every Human Life
I want to mention something important. We recently heard about a terrible human tragedy. Whatever the circumstances, every human being is Hashem’s creation. Any loss of life is a terrible tragedy for so many people. When we look at Yaakov, even when he was facing Esav—his enemy, who was coming to kill him—Yaakov still did not want to kill Esav. This shows us the value of life: every person’s life is so precious, that even when it comes to an enemy, we do not want to take a life unnecessarily.
I have heard the Lubavitcher Rebbe say, on several occasions, even during wars in Israel, that it is important to act quickly and decisively, but also to minimize casualties on the other side. The Rebbe strongly encouraged that the war should be won quickly, without attrition, and without causing many casualties to the other side. The goal is not just to win, but to do so in a way that avoids unnecessary loss of life. This is a very important value in Torah, and we see it even with Yaakov and Esav—Yaakov did not want to harm Esav, even though Esav was coming to harm him.
Sometimes, unfortunately, we see that when Israel lets out prisoners, those people may return to their previous ways and even do worse things. But when we hear about such a terrible tragedy and such a loss of life, we must feel sadness. It is not something to be happy about, even if it does not affect us or our immediate families directly. The suffering and pain of any human being is something we should care about.
May Hashem help that the world should become a stable place, a world of peace, a world filled with goodness and kindness, and that the world should be prepared for the coming of Moshiach Tzidkeinu, speedily and in our days. Amen.