Text for this content is coming soon
1. The Significance of Precision in Mitzvos
Many people wonder why such seemingly minor details matter in mitzvah observance, such as whether one should verbally announce the tekiyos—shofar blasts—or simply point. Does it really make a difference to Hashem? The answer is that in Torah observance, every detail is significant. Just as with dialing a phone number or entering a password, one wrong digit or letter means you don’t reach your destination. Similarly, with mitzvos, precision is essential; if you want your prayers or mitzvos to be accepted, they must be done exactly as Hashem prescribes. This is the “password” for spiritual connection, and while the reasoning behind each detail may be known only to Hashem, our role is to follow the halacha as precisely as possible.2. Chabad’s Custom: Pointing Instead of Speaking
In Chabad tradition, during the shofar blowing on Rosh Hashanah, instead of calling out the names of each blast (tekiyah, shevarim, teruah), the makri—the prompter—points rather than speaks. This differs from what is written in Shulchan Aruch, which instructs to call out the blasts verbally. While this is not a violation of halacha, it does require explanation: why does Chabad diverge from the standard practice? It’s important to note that changes in minhag are not made for convenience but are rooted in holy reasons and tradition.3. Possible Reason: Respect in Presence of Greatness
One suggestion offered was that perhaps this custom arose out of respect for the Rebbe’s presence. There is a concept that one should not speak or rule halacha in front of their teacher or someone greater than themselves. The story of Chana and her son Shmuel illustrates this: when Shmuel ruled halacha before Eli HaKohen, Eli was offended because it was considered disrespectful for a student to speak up before his teacher. Applying this idea, perhaps pointing instead of speaking was adopted when the Rebbe was present so as not to speak in his presence.4. The Rebbe’s Response: A Consistent Minhag
However, the Rebbe clarified that this is not the reason for Chabad’s custom. He pointed out that there were years when the Rebbe Rashab (the father of the previous Rebbe) did not blow shofar himself but acted as makri, and he too only pointed without verbalizing, even though he was the leader and could have spoken if that were customary. The same occurred with the previous Lubavitcher Rebbe in his later years. Thus, pointing rather than speaking is not limited to times when one is in front of a Rebbe but is consistently practiced regardless of who is present.5. The Value and Simplicity of Minhag Chabad
While we may not always know or understand every reason behind a minhag, belonging to Chabad provides clarity and consistency: we do things according to our tradition without needing to constantly re-examine each practice against Shulchan Aruch or debate every detail anew. If you want to know whether to say it aloud or point during tekiyos, you simply follow what Chabad does—you point.6. Possible Halachic Considerations: Hefsek (Interruption)
Another possible explanation relates to avoiding interruption (hefsek) between making a blessing and performing a mitzvah. Speaking unnecessarily after making a bracha can be an interruption; for example, after washing hands for bread (netilas yadayim) one should not talk before eating because it interrupts between washing and eating bread. Similarly, after making the bracha on shofar blowing, speaking could be considered an interruption unless it directly pertains to fulfilling the mitzvah—such as prompting which blast comes next. Some argue that even announcing page numbers during davening constitutes an interruption unless absolutely necessary for prayer continuity.7. Practical Differences Between Customs and Their Origins
If pointing avoids unnecessary speech and thus minimizes interruption, why doesn’t Shulchan Aruch mention this option? In earlier times there may have been practical reasons: fewer siddurim available meant people needed verbal prompts; some might have had poor eyesight and couldn’t see where someone was pointing; also, once people started saying words aloud they might add unnecessary words beyond what’s required for the mitzvah.8. Questions About Other Tekiyos Practices
Questions were raised about why we don’t point during shofar blowing on regular mornings before Rosh Hashanah or how other communities handle these customs. The answer given is that daily shofar blowing during Elul is merely a tradition without all formal requirements—no bracha is recited, no minyan required—so there’s less need for precision or prompting by pointing or calling out. Additionally, regarding why we blow three different sets (tashrat: tekiyah-shevarim-teruah-tekiyah, tashat: tekiyah-shevarim-tekiyah, tarat: tekiyah-teruah-tekiyah): this fulfills all opinions about what constitutes a teruah. Each set covers different interpretations from Torah and Talmud regarding what sounds are required.9. Continuity of Minhag Through Generations
As for whether earlier generations practiced this custom of pointing rather than speaking during tekiyos, we lack direct documentation from before the Rebbe Rashab’s time due to limited historical records and changes introduced by early Chassidic leaders like the Alter Rebbe (Siddur Admur Hazaken). However, it can be presumed that later generations followed their predecessors’ customs closely.10. Final Reflections on Tradition and Change
The evolution of minhagim within Chabad reflects both fidelity to tradition and adaptation over time under guidance from its leaders. While some practices changed dramatically with early chassidic innovation (such as changes in nusach tefillah), others have been preserved through careful transmission from one generation to another—a process sometimes documented more thoroughly once photography became common in later years. Ultimately, even if we do not always know every reason behind each detail—such as why we point instead of speak—the strength of minhag lies in its consistency and its roots in generations past dedicated to serving Hashem with precision and devotion.