10968 —על ביקורת פרסומים של תלמידים ושיפור התוכן

On Critiquing Student Publications and Improving Content

[ה'תשל"ג]
The Rebbe writes that critiquing student publications is generally not the proper educational approach, but since it has already begun, it should continue with efforts to improve content and style as much as possible. He also instructs to note this on the title page.
Audio for this shiur is coming soon

[ה'תשל"ג]

שלום וברכה!

[1]

נת'

ות"ח.

[2]

בכלל

אינו מדרכי

חינוך

לתלמידים להו"ל הערות עוה"פ ועוה"פ במהד"ב – כ"א

"לאפשא לה"

– אבל כיון שכבר התחילו – ימשיכו ועכ"פ [לתקן

התוכן

והסגנון ככל האפשרי].

[3]

ולציין

זה בהשער.

[4] ממזכ' –

חומש

.

[5733]

Shalom u'Vrachah!

It is generally not the method of education for students to raise critiques and comments in student publications—unless it is absolutely necessary. However, since this has already begun, they should continue, but with the effort to improve the content and style as much as possible.

This should be noted on the title page.

From the secretary—Chumash.


Summary

The Rebbe teaches that while critiquing student work is not ideal educationally, if already started, it should be continued with a focus on constructive improvement and clarity for all involved.

Leave Feedback