Support Torah
Recordings

לקוטי שיחות חלק כ״ב - מצורע

Likkutei Sichos Vol. 22 – Metzora

Prev Search
0:00 0:00
Next
Watch on YouTube Part 1 Part 2

Parshas Metzora

1. After the sections concerning the laws of a zav1, "a man from whom there goes out a seminal emission"2, a niddah3, and a zavah4 — the Torah concludes (at the end of the Sidrah): "זאת תורת הזב ואשר תצא ממנו שכבת זרע גו׳ והדוה בנדתה והזב את זובו לזכר ולנקבה גו׳" ("This is the law of the zav, and of him from whom there goes out a seminal emission… and of her who is unwell in her niddah, and of the zav with his discharge, for male and for female…").

On this Rashi explains: "זאת תורת הזב, בעל ראי׳ אחת ומהו תורתו. ואשר תצא ממנו שכבת זרע, הרי הוא כבעל קרי טמא טומאת ערב. והזב את זובו, בעל שתי ראיות ובעל שלש ראיות שתורתן מפורשת למעלה" ("'This is the law of the zav' — one who has had one sighting; and what is his law? 'And of him from whom there goes out a seminal emission' — he is like one who has had a seminal emission, impure with the impurity of the evening. 'And of the zav with his discharge' — one who has had two sightings and one who has had three sightings, whose law is stated above").

The commentators5 explain that what compels Rashi to interpret "This is the law of the zav" as meaning (not the "law of the zav" spoken of earlier in the parsha, but) "one who has had one sighting," whose "law" is stated only here in the verse ("and what is his law? 'And of him from whom there goes out a seminal emission'"), is the fact that the Torah repeats once again (in the following verse6): "and of the zav with his discharge (for male)."

Therefore Rashi explains that the two verses6 — "This is the law of the zav" and "and of the zav with his discharge" — speak of two categories: a) "This is the law of the zav" speaks of "one who has had one sighting," and the reason the verse singles him out from zav in general is that one who has had one sighting has a different law — "and what is his law" (of the "one who has had one sighting")? — "he is like one who has had a seminal emission."

b) "And of the zav with his discharge" means "one who has had two sightings and one who has had three sightings, whose law is stated above"7.

2. However, this needs to be understood. This interpretation — that the two categories (in the two verses here) are "one who has had one sighting" and "one who has had two sightings and one who has had three sightings" — involves several difficulties according to the plain meaning8, because:

a) Why is the "law" of one who has had one sighting stated only at the conclusion of the Sidrah, after all the other categories (and after the verse "והזרתם את בני ישראל מטומאתם גו׳" ("And you shall separate the children of Israel from their impurity…")), and not earlier, together with the laws of the zav or of one who has had a seminal emission9? (This is especially so since he too is, after all, one who has had one sighting — and there cannot be "two sightings" unless there was first "one sighting.")10

b) Accordingly, it emerges that one must split the words "This is the law" in two directions: in relation to "(the law of) the zav" it means that what follows, which comes later, is "the law of the zav"; while in relation to "and of her who is unwell in her niddah, and of the zav with his discharge…," "This is the law" means what was said earlier ("which is stated above")!

c) Accordingly, the conclusion — the summary of the preceding sections — is not at all in the order in which they appear: the section of the zav came before "a man from whom there goes out a seminal emission" and niddah, yet here "and of the zav with his discharge" (which according to Rashi means the zav whose law is "stated above") appears after "and of her who is unwell in her niddah"11 —

It is therefore not understood: why does Rashi (whose commentary is the plain meaning of Scripture12) explain that the two categories are "one who has had one sighting" and "one who has had two sightings and one who has had three sightings"? He should have explained that ("This is the law…" is merely a summary of what came before, and) "This is the law of the zav" means "one who has had two sightings," and "and of the zav with his discharge" means "one who has had three sightings"13 — just as Rashi already stated earlier (at the beginning of the section of the zav14) that they are distinguished from each other: "שתים לטומאה והשלישית מזקיקתו לקרבן" ("two for impurity, and the third obligates him in an offering").

[As for the fact that the Torah places the detail of the zav with three sightings (not in its place — before "and of him from whom there goes out…" — but) together with the zavah, one can answer that this is because only these two have a special law (which distinguishes them from all the other categories here)15: they must bring an offering16 (to atone for the impurity of the discharge).]

3. Seemingly one could answer that what concerns Rashi here is the doubled expression "and of the zav with his discharge" (unlike the previous verse, "This is the law of the zav," where the word zav appears only once). From this Rashi derives that the verse here alludes to two categories within "zav" — just as Rashi earlier derived the distinction (mentioned above) between "one who has had two sightings" and "one who has had three sightings" from the doubled expression in the two verses there: "מנה הכתוב הראשון ראיות שתים . . זב מבשרו זובו . . ומנה הכתוב השני ראיות שלש . . בזובו רר בשרו את זובו או החתים בשרו מזובו" ("The first verse counted two sightings… 'a discharge from his flesh, his discharge'… and the second verse counted three sightings… 'in his discharge, his flesh runs with his discharge, or his flesh is stopped from his discharge'") —

And since in the two verses (together) zav is mentioned three times, Rashi therefore explains that "This is the law of the zav" means "one who has had one sighting," and "and of the zav with his discharge" means "one who has had two sightings and one who has had three sightings."

But it is difficult to explain it this way, because the doubled expression "and of the zav with his discharge" here is not such a strong point of precision (according to the plain meaning). It is similar to (and moreover, it comes in continuation of) the doubled expression "and of her who is unwell in her niddah"18. Consequently there is no basis to say that because of this Rashi would adopt so far-fetched an interpretation (and call it the plain meaning) of "This is the law of the zav and of him from whom…."

In addition: even if one were to accept that the doubled expression ("and of the zav with his discharge") is indeed a point of precision according to the plain meaning, the manner of the derivation (that the doubled expression alludes to two categories) is only a matter of Midrash

— as Rashi says earlier17 regarding the distinction between "two sightings" and "three sightings" (which is derived from "The verse counted… two sightings… three sightings"), that this is (not "its plain meaning" but) "its Midrash." So here too Rashi should have emphasized that his interpretation is "its Midrash."

4. The explanation of this may be said as follows: The expression "This is the law of the zav" is similar to "זאת תורת העולה גו׳" … "זאת תורת המנחה גו׳" ("This is the law of the burnt-offering…," "This is the law of the meal-offering…"), which means all burnt-offerings, all meal-offerings, etc. — all categories19. So Rashi explains that here the Torah is stating a general principle and wishes to detail all the categories of zav, and in order: from the lighter to the more stringent20.

Accordingly it is answered why the Torah places "and of the zav with his discharge, for male" not where the zav is spoken of earlier in the parsha, but together with "and for female" — the zav together with the zavah — because both have the same stringency.

Accordingly, however, there is a difficulty: here, after all, "(the law of) the zav" is stated first, before "and of him from whom there goes out…" — and "ואשר" ("and of him") has an added vav, which shows that "the zav" here is (also) a detail within the general category of "zav." It should therefore follow that there is a zav who is lighter in his law than "and of him from whom there goes out…"!

And since one cannot say that a zav with two sightings would be equal to, and all the more so lighter than, "and of him from whom there goes out…"21, one must say that "This is the law of the zav" means "one who has had one sighting."

5. However, we need to understand what Rashi says: "and of the zav with his discharge — one who has had two sightings and one who has had three sightings, whose law is stated above."

From the precise wording of Rashi, "one who has had two sightings and one who has had three sightings22 whose law23 is stated above," it is evident that according to Rashi the verse "and of the zav with his discharge" speaks of two categories of zav24. This is not understood: the above explanation (section 4) only compels us to say that "This is the law of the zav" speaks of "one who has had one sighting," and "and of the zav with his discharge" of a zav who is more stringent than "and of him from whom there goes out…" (and "her who is unwell in her niddah"25). But from where is the compulsion (from the plain sense of the verses here) that "and of the zav with his discharge" includes two categories — "one who has had two sightings and one who has had three sightings"26?

Seemingly one could answer that since Rashi already stated earlier (at least as "its Midrash") that there are two categories of zav (two sightings and three sightings), he details here (once again) the two categories.

But Rashi's wording "whose law is stated above" is not smooth — [saying] that their laws, which by extension also means the distinctions between them24, are "stated above." He should have said "whose law is derived above," as Rashi himself says "above" that the distinction between two sightings and three sightings is (not [OCR unclear]

6. The explanation of this is: That which Rashi brings earlier as "and its Midrash" is not as in other places, where according to "its Midrash" the meaning of the verse differs from its meaning according to "its plain meaning." Rather, in our case, also according to "its Midrash" the meaning of the verse is the same as according to "its plain meaning"27 (— "its Midrash" pertains (mainly) to (and only adds) a matter that is alluded to in the verse).

On the other hand, the Midrash (does not merely "settle" the plain meaning, but) is "compelled" by "its plain meaning"28 — because only according to the Midrash (in Rashi's words29, "an Aggadah that settles the plain meaning of Scripture") is the lengthy wording of the verse explained (which is difficult according to "its plain meaning"):

Earlier30 there are two verses: "איש כי יהי׳ זב מבשרו זובו טמא הוא. וזאת תהי׳ טומאתו בזובו רר בשרו את זובו או החתים בשרו מזובו טומאתו היא" ("Any man who has a discharge from his flesh, his discharge is impure. And this shall be his impurity in his discharge: whether his flesh runs with his discharge or his flesh is stopped from his discharge, it is his impurity"); and afterwards (in the following verse) the detailed laws of the impurity of the zav begin — "כל המשכב וגו׳" ("Every bed…").

This is not understood: why does the Torah interrupt between "And this shall be his impurity in his discharge" and the laws of the impurity ("Every bed…") with the words "whether his flesh runs… or his flesh is stopped…," which are (not laws of the impurity of the zav, but) two modes of discharge ["his flesh runs" — "ריר שיוצא צלול" ("a mucus that comes out clear")31; "his flesh is stopped" — "שיוצא עב וסותם את פי האמה" ("that comes out thick and blocks the orifice of the organ")31]?

The words "whether his flesh runs with his discharge or his flesh is stopped from his discharge" should seemingly have appeared in the previous verse: "Any man who has a discharge from his flesh, whether his flesh runs with his discharge or his flesh is stopped from his discharge, his discharge is impure" (and afterwards: "And this shall be his impurity: every bed…").

To this "its Midrash" comes and answers: "The first verse counted… and called him impure… the second verse… and called him impure." The Torah thereby alludes to two categories within zav, whose impurity is not the same; and therefore they appear in two separate verses ("the first verse… the second verse"32), and of each of them separately it says "called him impure" (since their impurity is not the same).

What are the two categories of zav (and where is the distinction between them alluded to in the verse)? Rashi says that every "discharge" mentioned in the verse alludes to an additional sighting. Consequently, the "first verse" speaks of one who saw two sightings, and the "second verse" of one who saw three sightings.

It emerges that the plain meaning of Scripture there compels us to say (that the extra wording must be expounded, and consequently) that there are two categories of zav — one who has had two sightings and one who has had three sightings.

7. Since "its Midrash" in our case is one that is compelled by "its plain meaning" (as above), it is understandable that the distinction in law between them as well (which Rashi brings) — "two for impurity, and the third obligates him in an offering" — is (not merely a citation of the words of Chazal33, which do not contradict the plain meaning, but is) compelled by the plain meaning of Scripture.

The explanation: Since "And this shall be his impurity" plainly relates to the "he is impure" stated in the previous verse (regarding one who has had two sightings), one must say that the laws of impurity stated in the continuation of the section apply also to one who has had two sightings34.

One must therefore say that what one who has had three sightings adds over one who has had two sightings is not in the essential matter (and manner) of the impurity — "he is impure" — but in that "(two for impurity,) and the third mazkikaso (obligates him) in an offering"35. [Rashi says mazkikaso,] not "mechayavto" ("makes him liable to") an offering, for "zikah" means a need for a new (additional) matter.

Accordingly it is understood why Rashi says at the conclusion of the Sidrah "one who has had two sightings and one who has had three sightings, whose law is stated above": because the above distinction between two sightings and three sightings is compelled also by "its plain meaning" (as explained above at length). Consequently, when Rashi wishes to explain which "zav" has his law "stated above"36 — unlike one who has had one sighting, whose law appears only at the conclusion of the Sidrah — he brings both categories of zav.

8. Among the wondrous matters, according to halachah, in this commentary of Rashi:

The content of Rashi's commentary at the conclusion of the Sidrah appears in Toras Kohanim on the verse, but with several changes, which the commentators on Rashi37 discuss. There is, however, one change of wording which, as far as I have found so far, no one discusses. It may be said that in this change lies an entire matter, reflecting the respective approach of Toras Kohanim (halachah) or of Rashi's commentary (the plain meaning of Scripture):

In Toras Kohanim the wording is: "… זה שראה ראי׳ אחת . . זה שראה38 שתי ראיות . . זה שראה שלש ראיות" ("… this one who saw one sighting… this one who saw two sightings… this one who saw three sightings"); and Rashi changes this39 and says: "one who has had (baal) one sighting… one who has had two sightings and one who has had three sightings."

This will be understood by first noting that we find in the Gemara40 two derivations for the distinction between two sightings and three sightings:

a) The exposition of R. Simai41 (which Rashi brings here42): "מנה הכתוב שתים וקראו טמא שלש וקראו טמא הא כיצד שתים לטומאה ושלש לקרבן" ("The verse counted two and called him impure, three and called him impure; how so? Two for impurity and three for an offering").

b) The exposition of the Sages: "זובו חדא רר בשרו תרי את זובו תלת לימד על זב בעל שלש ראיות שחייב בקרבן. או החתים בשרו מזובו טמא מקצת זובו טמא לימד על זב בעל שתי ראיות שמטמא משכב ומושב" ("'His discharge' — one; 'his flesh runs' — two; 'with his discharge' — three: this teaches that a zav with three sightings is obligated in an offering. 'Or his flesh is stopped from his discharge' — part of his discharge is impure: this teaches that a zav with two sightings renders a bed and a seat impure").

It may be said that there is a practical difference between the two derivations in the definition of a zav who has had two sightings, which can be understood in two ways43:

a) A zav with two sightings and a zav with three sightings are two entirely separate realities. The impurity of one who has had two sightings is not the same impurity as (that of the two sightings of) one who has had three sightings; it is a matter in its own right — the two sightings in and of themselves obligate the impurity of a zav and the counting of seven clean days.

b) The impurity of one who has had two sightings is a part of the impurity of a zav with three sightings. And since he is a part of three sightings, he also receives only a part of the laws of the impurity of one who has had three sightings.

[Accordingly one can explain what is stated in Targum Yonasan ben Uziel on the verse44 "Any man who has a discharge…": "חמא תלת זימני" ("sees three times") — and he does not mention the law of one who has had two sightings at all. For the impurity of one who has had two sightings is a part of that of one who has had three sightings.]

9. One of the practical differences that may possibly be said with regard to actual halachah45: if there was an interruption (of a day) between the third sighting and the first two sightings, do they all combine so that he receives the status of one who has had three sightings, or not? (This is a dispute, according to the opinion of R. Eliezer ben Yehudah46, between Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel.)

If one were to accept that the impurity of one who has had two sightings is a matter in its own right, this means that after the two sightings there immediately arises an obligation (in its own right) to count seven clean days (unless he immediately sees a third sighting, in which case it is revealed that he is one who has had three sightings).

Accordingly it should follow that if (after the two sightings) there was an interruption (of a day), so that it has become clear that he is not one who has had (three) sightings, it is revealed retroactively that he had (immediately after the second sighting) the status of one who has had two sightings. And if he sees a sighting on the day after the interruption, this is a new matter; it does not combine with the previous two sightings47.

If, however, the impurity of one who has had two sightings is a part within the definition of the impurity of one who has had three sightings, it must follow that even after one day of the seven clean days has passed (after the two sightings), the later third sighting combines with the previous two. For the counting of seven clean days after two sightings is (not because the two sightings in and of themselves obligate it, but) because they are a part — "a portion" — of three sightings48.

10. And this is also the difference between the two derivations mentioned above:

According to the exposition that a zav with two sightings is derived from the verse "מזובו" — "מקצת זובו טמא" ("from his discharge — part of his discharge is impure"), a zav with two sightings is a "part" of a (complete) zav, one with three sightings.

Whereas according to the exposition of R. Simai, "The verse counted two, etc.," the Torah counts "two" separately and "three" separately, and in two separate verses — so these are two separate categories of zav49.

Accordingly one can also explain the difference between the wording of Toras Kohanim and the wording of Rashi at the conclusion of the Sidrah:

Toras Kohanim brings earlier50 the derivation "from his discharge — part of his discharge"; and therefore it uses here the wording "this one who saw51 two sightings… three sightings." This wording emphasizes the actual sightings: they are within the same definition, and there is only a difference in quantity — how many sightings there have (already) been.

Rashi, who brings the exposition of R. Simai (as above), holds that these are separate persons — each a separate "baal" ("possessor") of what he saw. Therefore he is precise and specifies in his wording52 "one who has had (baal) one sighting… one who has had two sightings and one who has had three sightings"53 — each of them is a separate "baal" in his own right.

(From the sichos of Shabbos Parshas Metzora 5725)


Notes

1) Our parsha, 15:2 ff.

2) Ibid., 16 ff.

3) Ibid., 19 ff.

4) Ibid., 25 ff.

5) See Re'em, Sefer Zikaron and Be'er Yitzchak here. See also Korban Aharon on Toras Kohanim here.

6) Rashi's comments on the two verses are one continuous comment.

7) As Rashi explains above (15:3) from "its Midrash" [OCR unclear]. See at length further in the text.

8) Although, on the other hand, according to Rashi's commentary the fact that the verse (32) concludes "לטמאה בה" ("becoming impure through it") — words that seem superfluous — is well understood: the intent of the verse is to explain the law of the zav, that he is impure ("becoming impure through it") like "and of him from whom there goes out…." (However, Rashi did not quote these words in his commentary (even though he concludes his commentary "impure with the impurity of the evening"), which implies that this is not Rashi's proof for his interpretation.)

9) 15:31.

10) Also: from the unqualified wording of Rashi, "and what is his law? 'And of him from whom there goes out…'," it is implied that Rashi's intent is (not to compare the zav to "and of him from whom there goes out…," as the commentators on Rashi and on Toras Kohanim here write, but) that the vav of "ואשר תצא ממנו גו׳" is like an "explanatory vav" (see Rashi, Shemini 10:9, and Re'em there; Sicha of Shabbos Parshas Shemini 5741) — which is not so smooth in the plain meaning of Scripture. This is especially so in our case, since in the following verse further categories are enumerated (in continuation of this verse), and the vav in them is a conjunctive vav.

11) See Sefer Zikaron here.

12) From which it is understood that one cannot say that Rashi writes this because it is so in Toras Kohanim here — for the derivation in Toras Kohanim [that in the verse the zav is compared both to one who has had a seminal emission and to her who is unwell in her niddah, etc. — see Rabbeinu Hillel and Korban Aharon there; the commentators on Rashi here] is by way of derush (especially since Rashi changes from the wording of Toras Kohanim here — see Re'em and Gur Aryeh here; and see further, section 8 ff.).

In Rashi on Pesachim (67b, beginning) [it is stated] that the verse "This is the law of the zav" deals with one who has had one sighting, "since in this verse it counted only one discharge, for we follow the count of the verse, as we say in Megillah (8a): the verse counted two and called him impure, etc." — and Rashi brought this exposition above (15:3) (as below, section 3).

However, it is difficult to say that this is also Rashi's compulsion here in his commentary on the Torah (relying on his commentary above). For (besides the fact that if so, he should have said "and its Midrash" here, as he writes above, there, regarding the exposition (of Megillah) that he brought) according to the plain meaning one cannot compare our verse(s) to the verses (and the exposition) above, as below, note 26.

13) It should be noted that according to the version of the Re'em and Gur Aryeh in Toras Kohanim here, the verse "This is the law of the zav" refers (also) to one who has had two sightings, and "and of the zav with his discharge" (only) to one who has had three sightings. [As for what Gur Aryeh writes, that Rashi did not write so because "he explained the plain meaning" — he concludes that this is because "according to its plain meaning, 'This is the law of the zav' deals with one who has had one sighting."]

14) 15:3.

15) Similar to the fact that the law of "ולאיש אשר ישכב עם טמאה" ("and of a man who lies with an impure woman") is specified here on its own, and not in its place. See further, note 20.

16) 15:14-15; ibid., 29-30.

17) [OCR unclear] But not exactly, since there it counts the sightings, whereas here it is categories of zav. See further, note 26.

18) And Rashi did not explain the reason for this doubled expression — even though there are explanations by way of derush (see Toras Kohanim on the verse; Shabbos 64b; Niddah 54b).

19) Rashi, Vayikra 6:2; ibid., 7.

20) And although it concludes with "and of a man who lies with an impure woman" — even though his impurity is not as stringent as that of a zav and zavah (for he does not need an offering to atone for his impurity) — that is because this also involves a prohibition (of kares). Note Bachaye here (on the reason the verse concludes with "who lies with an impure woman").

21) For a zav is more stringent than one who has had a seminal emission, as stated explicitly in the section of the zav. And one cannot say that a zav with two sightings would be lighter than one who has had a seminal emission (who is impure even with one sighting).

22) In the first and second printings and in several manuscripts of Rashi, this word is absent.

23) In the second printing and in several manuscripts of Rashi: "שתורתו" ("whose law," singular). But in the editions of Rashi before us it is as in the text. And in one of the manuscripts of Rashi ([OCR unclear]): "שתורתם."

24) In Be'er Mayim Chaim (by the brother of the Maharal) here it is implied that he explains Rashi's intent as referring (not to two categories of zav, but) to one who has had "multiple discharges" (in contrast to "one who has had one sighting"); and "whose law is stated above" means the common denominator between one who has had two sightings and one who has had three (that they require seven clean days). However, from the lengthy wording of Rashi, "one who has had two sightings and one who has had three sightings whose law, etc.," it is implied that his intent is to the two categories he mentioned above in his commentary. Perhaps he had before him the version found in the second printing of Rashi (mentioned in the previous note).

25) Or at least equal to a niddah. See Ramban at the end of our parsha ("by way of the plain meaning").

26) The commentators (Rabbeinu Hillel and Korban Aharon on Toras Kohanim here; Re'em, Gur Aryeh and Sifsei Chachamim here) [explain] that the three discharges mentioned here (in the two verses) indicate one who has had three discharges. This is similar to Rashi's commentary above, 15:3 (and see above, note 12). But according to the plain meaning, Rashi's commentary above is not comparable to our case, for in our verse ("and of the zav with his discharge") only two discharges are mentioned (although one could say that it combines with "This is the law of the zav"); whereas in Rashi's commentary above, in the verse that deals with one who has had two sightings, two discharges are mentioned on their own, and in the verse that deals with one who has had three sightings, three sightings on their own.

27) See similarly Be'er Yitzchak above, there.

28) Note what is explained (Likkutei Sichos vol. 21, p. 33 ff.) on Rashi's words (Va'era 6:9, at the end) "יתיישב המקרא על פשוטו . . והדרשה תדרש" ("the verse will be settled according to its plain meaning… and the exposition will be expounded"): that Rashi's intent is that the plain meaning compels the exposition. See there.

29) Bereishis 3:8.

30) 15:2-3.

31) Rashi, there.

32) Based on what is explained in the text, the reason for this addition by Rashi ("the first… the second") to the wording of the Talmud (Megillah 8a; Niddah 43b) is well understood.

33) Megillah and Niddah, there (with a slight change of wording).

34) Unlike according to derush and halachah, where there is a special derivation that one who has had two sightings requires seven clean days (Toras Kohanim, our parsha, 15:13; Megillah, there, a-b).

35) Although the offering also pertains to the impurity of the zav, for it comes to atone "for his discharge" (our parsha, 15:15), nevertheless it is not a law within the impurity (like the preceding laws).

36) And this itself is Rashi's intent in writing "whose law is stated above": that the compulsion to explain that "and of the zav with his discharge" refers to "one who has had two sightings and one who has had three sightings" comes (not from the wording of the verse here, as the commentators cited in note 26 explain, but) from the fact that "their law is stated above," and here is the summary of the sections above.

37) Re'em and Gur Aryeh here.

38) In several printings: "זו שראתה" ("she who saw"). But seemingly it should read as in the version cited in the text (since it refers to a zav).

39) In Yalkut Shimoni here the version (of Toras Kohanim) reads: "בעל שתי ראיות" ("one who has had two sightings").

40) Niddah, there.

41) His exposition is also cited in Megillah, there; and likewise, without attribution, in the Rambam's Commentary on the Mishnah, beginning of Zavim.

42) See at length Nachalas Yaakov here.

43) See similarly* this inquiry regarding a shomeres yom keneged yom — whether she is a detail of a zavah gedolah or a category in her own right — Likkutei Sichos vol. 7, p. 106 ff. (see there at length).

*) But not exactly, for there the question is whether the matter of shomeres yom is because the sighting can combine and lead to a major zivah; whereas in our case, the law of the impurity of a zav with two sightings applies even when the sighting is of another kind that cannot combine into three sightings. For the impurity of two sightings applies even if the first sighting was through an external cause (b'ones), whereas the impurity of three sightings, requiring an offering, applies only if the first sighting was not through an external cause (Niddah 35a; Rambam, Hilchos Mechusrei Kaparah 2:5).

44) 15:2.

45) It may also be said that this is the dispute of R. Yosei and the Sages (Zavim 1:5) whether one who saw one [discharge] as large as two is considered as having had two sightings — just as one who saw one as large as three, which we derive from a verse is considered as three sightings. For according to R. Yosei, the law does not extend from one who has had three to one who has had two (Rambam's Commentary on the Mishnah, there) — even though seemingly it is all the more so that one as large as two should be divisible into two (as written in Mishnah Acharonah, there).

46) Zavim 1:1. And in the Tosefta there (1:2) [it is stated] that R. Akiva went back to teaching according to his words.

It should be noted regarding the Mishnah (Zavim, there; R. Akiva's earlier teaching, Tosefta there, 1), where the dispute of Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel concerns "he saw one, and on the second [day] there was an interruption, and on the third he saw two": it may be said that they hold that the dispute concerns the definition of one who has had one sighting — whether he is a detail of a (complete) zav or not. This depends on their preceding dispute (in the Mishnah and Tosefta there; and see Chasdei David on the Tosefta there) whether one who has had one sighting is like a shomeres yom or like one who has had a seminal emission (according to the opinion of the Maharsha (Niddah 72b) that according to Beis Shammai, "with the second sighting of a zav he becomes a complete zav retroactively"; but see Mishnah Acharonah, Zavim, there).

However, note that regarding shomeres yom keneged yom, Beis Shammai hold that even "she who sees on the eleventh day," who cannot combine into a zavah gedolah, is a shomeres yom by Torah law (Mishnah, end of Niddah); whereas in our case (a zav with one sighting) they hold that the sightings combine. But see Likkutei Sichos there (p. 114 ff.), where it is said that according to Beis Shammai, even in one who sees on the eleventh day there exists the matter of being fit to combine into a zavah gedolah, only that it is in potential. See there. This is not the place to elaborate.

47) Therefore Beis Hillel did not accept what Beis Shammai said to them (Tosefta there, 2), "Since he has become obligated to count seven, the sighting has nullified the clean day." For although "the sighting has nullified the clean day," it is impossible for the following sighting to combine with the sightings before it, since the definition of a zav with two sightings has already taken effect upon him.

48) Accordingly there is room to say that even if there was an interruption of more than one day, the third sighting combines with the first two sightings, since all the impurity (and the counting of seven clean days) of two sightings is because they are the beginning of three sightings. However, according to the opinion of R. Eliezer son of R. Yannai in the Tosefta there, even according to Beis Shammai the sightings combine only if they all occurred within three days. See Mishnah Acharonah, Zavim, there.

49) And although R. Simai too needs the exposition "מזובו, מקצת זבין מביאין קרבן כו׳" ("'from his discharge' — some zavim bring an offering, etc.") (Megillah, there; and see Rashi there, s.v. mizovo), and likewise derives that one who has had two sightings requires seven clean days from what is written, "מזובו וספר" — "מקצת זובו וספר" ("'from his discharge, and he shall count' — part of his discharge, and he shall count") (Megillah, there ff.) — nevertheless: a) it may be said that this is only in the derivation according to halachah; b) the basis for there being a distinction between two and three (according to R. Simai) is from "the verse counted two, etc.," while from "mizovo" we derive only in what respect they differ (two for impurity and three for an offering; and likewise that two also requires seven clean days).

50) On the verse 15:3. See also there, 13; there, 15.

51) It should be noted that also above, there, the wording in Toras Kohanim is: "מקצת זובו . . את שראה שתי ראיות" ("part of his discharge… one who saw two sightings") — unlike the wording in Niddah, there: "this teaches about one who has had three sightings… part of his discharge is impure — this teaches about one who has had two sightings, etc."

52) This wording ("one who has had two… one who has had three") is common in many places (and it is also the wording in the exposition "mizovo — part of his discharge," as in the previous note). The precision noted in the text derives from the fact that Rashi changes from the wording of Toras Kohanim on the spot.

53) And not "one who has had two sightings and three sightings."


Key Lesson

This Sicha shows that Rashi's Midrash on the zav is not a departure from the plain meaning but is compelled by it, so that even a single word in Rashi — "baal," one who "has" a given number of sightings — reflects a whole approach. Each zav, whether of two sightings or of three, is his own distinct category; so too, every detail in the Torah and in Rashi's words carries precise meaning and deserves careful study.

Leave Feedback

{# Keyboard shortcuts: Alt+Left = previous shiur, Alt+Right = next shiur. Ignored while typing in a box or editor so Alt+arrow word-jumping still works there. #}