Yaakov’s Encounter with Esav: Messengers or Angels?
At the beginning of Parshas Vayishlach, Yaakov prepares to meet his brother Esav after decades apart. Fearing Esav’s anger over the blessings he received from Yitzchak, Yaakov sends messengers ahead. The Torah says, "Vayishlach Yaakov malachim"—Yaakov sent malachim (Bereishis 32:4). The word malachim can mean either messengers or angels. Rashi explains that Yaakov sent "malochim mamash"—actual angels. This is remarkable, as usually only Hashem sends angels, but here Yaakov himself sends them. The commentaries discuss why Rashi insists they were angels and not just human messengers, but Rashi’s words are clear: Yaakov sent angels.
The Significance of Yud-Tes Kislev
This Shabbos is Yud-Tes Kislev, a day with deep significance in Chassidic history. On this date, the Maggid of Mezrich, Rabbi Dovber—the successor to the Baal Shem Tov and leader of the Chassidic movement—passed away in 1772. The Maggid was chosen to lead after the Baal Shem Tov’s son stepped aside, recognizing the Maggid’s strength to withstand opposition to Chassidus. The Maggid’s passing is not seen as a sad day, but as a Yom Hilulah, a time when the tzaddik’s influence is elevated and continues to benefit his followers, as explained in Tanya.
The following year, the Alter Rebbe, Rabbi Schneur Zalman, had a son, Dovber, named after the Maggid, fulfilling a blessing the Maggid gave him before his passing. Decades later, on Yud-Tes Kislev 1798, the Alter Rebbe was released from prison. This release is seen as a sign from above that the teachings of Chassidus should continue and spread. The Alter Rebbe explained that his imprisonment was a result of spiritual criticism for revealing deep mystical teachings, but after his release, he was told to continue spreading Chassidus even more widely. This is connected to the Baal Shem Tov’s vision, in which Mashiach told him, "When your wellsprings will be spread forth," then redemption will come. The Alter Rebbe’s release marked the beginning of the true spreading of Chassidus, especially after he moved to Lyadi, where his influence grew greatly.
Thus, Yud-Tes Kislev is celebrated as the "Rosh Hashanah" of Chassidus, marking both the Maggid’s passing and the Alter Rebbe’s liberation, and is considered the greatest Chassidic holiday, especially in Lubavitch.
Connecting Yud-Tes Kislev to Parshas Vayishlach
The Maggid of Mezrich, on his deathbed on Yud-Tes Kislev, also Parshas Vayishlach, offered a unique interpretation of Rashi’s words "malochim mamash". He explained that Yaakov sent only the "mamash"—the tangible, external aspect—of the angels, while their spiritual essence remained with him. The Rebbe teaches that this is a lesson for us: when we engage with the world, we should only send our "mamash," our external self, while our spiritual core remains connected to holiness. This parallels the mission of Chassidim and shluchim, who must interact with the world but keep their inner selves attached to their source. Our "malach"—our spiritual side—should remain with Yaakov, with our source, while only our external self engages with the challenges of the world.
Two Levels of Serving Hashem in Daily Life
The Rebbe, quoting the Rambam, explains two levels of serving Hashem in everyday life. The first, from Pirkei Avos, is "All your deeds should be for the sake of Heaven" (v'chol ma'asecha yehiyu l'shem shamayim): whatever we do—business, eating, walking—should be done with the intention of serving Hashem. The second, higher level, from Mishlei, is "In all your ways, know Him" (b'chol drachecha da'ehu, Mishlei 3:6): not only are our actions for a higher purpose, but we actually perceive Hashem in everything we do. The act itself becomes a way of connecting to Hashem, not just a means to an end.
The Alter Rebbe illustrated this with a story: when a guest found the soup oversalted, the Alter Rebbe explained that when he was in Mezritch, he was so removed from physicality that he didn’t even taste the food—his eating was purely for the service of Hashem. This represents the highest level, where one’s entire being is devoted to Hashem, and all physicality is secondary.
Yud-Tes Kislev, with its focus on the teachings of Chassidus, is a time to strive for this deeper connection: to reveal our inner selves and serve Hashem not only externally, but with our whole being, seeing Hashem in everything.
Esav Leaves Canaan: The End of the Parsha
At the end of the parsha, after Yaakov returns to Canaan, the Torah describes how Esav takes his family and possessions and leaves the land "because of his brother Yaakov." The Torah says it was because the land could not support both of their cattle. Rashi comments that there was not enough feed for all the animals, similar to the earlier story of Lot and Avraham. But Rashi also brings a Midrash Aggadah: Esav left because he did not want to pay the "debt"—the suffering foretold to Avraham in Bereishis 15:13, that his descendants would be strangers and afflicted in a foreign land. Esav chose to leave Canaan and not share in this destiny. Another reason Rashi gives is that Esav was ashamed for having sold his birthright to Yaakov.
The Rebbe asks: if the Torah gives a reason—lack of feed—why does Rashi add other explanations? The answer is that Esav’s departure was not just about the immediate situation; he had deeper motives. The lack of feed was the trigger, but Esav already wanted to avoid the responsibilities and consequences of remaining in Canaan.
Living in Exile and the Sense of Belonging
The Rebbe draws a lesson from Esav’s choice. Esav settled in a strange land and made it his home. In contrast, Jews in exile must never feel truly at home outside Eretz Yisroel. Even when living comfortably, we must remember that our true place is in the Holy Land, and our real connection is to Hashem and spirituality. The sense of exile should remain with us, reminding us that we belong elsewhere, and that our ultimate goal is redemption and return to Eretz Yisroel.
The Lesson: Connecting to Hashem and Our True Place
In summary, Parshas Vayishlach and Yud-Tes Kislev together teach us to engage with the world without losing our spiritual core, to serve Hashem in all aspects of life, and to remember our true home and purpose. May the merit of the Maggid of Mezrich and the Alter Rebbe inspire us to connect to Hashem in an inner way, revealing the hidden parts of Torah and of ourselves.
Yaakov's Encounter with Esav
This week’s parsha is Vayishlach, and this coming Shabbos is the 19th of Kislev. I want to talk about two aspects: the beginning of the parsha, and the significance of Yud-Tes Kislev.
At the start of the parsha, we read that Yaakov sent messengers to his brother Esav. As you know, after Yaakov spent 20 years with Lavan—his uncle, his mother’s brother—who deceived him and made his life very difficult, Yaakov was still able to come out with a beautiful family. Eventually, he escaped from Lavan, as we read at the end of last week’s parsha. But as soon as he got past that challenge, he now had to face his brother Esav.
Yaakov’s Encounter with Esav: Messengers or Angels?
As you remember, originally Yaakov ran away from his brother Esav because he took the blessings from his father Yitzchak. He basically plotted together with his mother Rivka, and he got his brother so angry that Esav wanted to kill him because he snatched away the blessings that Esav was going to get. They advised Yaakov to leave, and now, more than 20 years later—according to the commentaries, actually, there were another 14 years in which Yaakov was in yeshiva—so we're talking about 34 years later, and his brother is still full of rage.
As Yaakov leaves Lavan, the place where he spent all that time, Esav hears about it. Maybe while Yaakov was by Lavan, Esav was afraid to start up with him because Lavan and the whole family were there. I'm not sure exactly what motivated Esav to wait all this time, but finally, when Yaakov is leaving Lavan and heading home, he encounters Esav. Originally, Esav came with 400 men and was going to wage war on Yaakov. We see that Yaakov prepared himself in various ways: he prepared a gift, he prayed, and he was ready for war—he was ready for all possibilities if necessary. But in the end, at the last minute, Esav sort of broke down, hugged his brother, kissed him, and they made up. But at first, our parsha begins with the words "Vayishlach Yaakov malachim"—Yaakov sent malachim. The word malachim means messengers, but malachim can also mean angels.
Why are angels called malachim, messengers? Because the purpose of these angels is that they are messengers of Hashem; they go ahead on the mission that Hashem sends them. That's what they do, so that's why they're called malachim. The word malachim really contains both interpretations: it could mean an angel, and it can also mean a messenger. It's not very clear in the posuk itself—were these messengers, or were they angels? In the context of the story, we know that Yaakov was trying to send to his brother that he is giving him the gift and trying to make up with him. So really, both interpretations would be acceptable: whether he sent angels as his messengers or he sent others as his messengers, that would be okay in the text. We'll see in a minute what Rashi says, but that's why I said these messengers that Yaakov sent—that's one thing we're going to discuss at the beginning of the parsha.
The Significance of Yud-Tes Kislev
The other thing we'll discuss in the parsha is that this Shabbos is going to be the 19th day of Kislev—Yud-Tes Kislev. We're going to try to find and see a connection that is made between the parsha of Vayishlach and Yud-Tes Kislev. First, let's talk about what happened on Yud-Tes Kislev.
What happened on Yud-Tes Kislev? Again, it's coming up this Shabbos when we will be reading this portion of Vayishlach in the Torah, so there should be a connection between the parsha and the date. So, what happened on Yud-Tes Kislev?
Number one: the Maggid of Mezrich—his name was Rabbi Dovber—was the Maggid of Mezrich. The Maggid of Mezrich was the replacement for the Baal Shem Tov. We all know that the Chassidic movement was introduced by the Baal Shem Tov. After the passing of the Baal Shem Tov, Rabbi Dovber, the Maggid of Mezrich, became the head of the Chassidic movement.
Now, the Baal Shem Tov had a son, and for one year the son became the leader. But after one year, the son said that his father came to him in a dream and told him—with everybody's agreement—that the most fitting person to take over for the Baal Shem Tov would be Rabbi Dovber, the Maggid of Mezrich. You see, these people were very great scholars and great tzaddikim. They didn't show themselves as being boastful or trying to build themselves up. Look, he called himself the Maggid. A Maggid means a preacher—the preacher of Mezrich. A preacher is, you know, anybody can be. He didn't say, "I am the Rebbe," he called himself the Maggid of Mezrich. He was the one who took over after the Baal Shem Tov.
There was a lot of opposition at the time. With the introduction of the Chassidic movement and some of the Chassidic ideas, there was a lot of objection to it. They needed a strong leader. The son of the Baal Shem Tov didn't feel that he could stand up to all the challenges that were in the street, by the rabbis, by the other groups. It was Rabbi Dovber who was chosen to lead the Jewish community. He passed away on the 19th day of Kislev in 1772. That's when he passed away.
By the way, his great disciple, the Alter Rebbe—even though the Alter Rebbe was one of the youngest disciples—he ended up being a favorite of Rabbi Dovber. Some of the students said that while everybody drank from the same well, so to speak, the same plate—they all had Rabbi Dovber as their teacher—but they said that Rabbi Schneur Zalman, the Alter Rebbe, he had the knedlach, he had the matzo balls. In other words, he sort of got the best of the soup; he didn't just get the regular soup. Even though he was very young and he came later, he was very respected, and the Maggid of Mezrich loved him.
The Alter Rebbe, for many years, only had daughters; he didn't have any sons, and he wanted a son very, very badly. So he went to his Rebbe, Rabbi Dovber, the Maggid of Mezrich, and he asked him for a blessing for a son. Rabbi Dovber quoted him a verse, and it's very interesting—a play on words. How do you merit getting a son? By inviting guests. If you invite guests to your home, then you get a blessing from Hashem to have a son.
It happened that Rabbi Dovber passed away in 1772. The next year, in 1773, the blessing that he gave before his passing to the Alter Rebbe came true, and the Alter Rebbe had a son in 1773 that he named Dovber. The second Lubavitcher Rebbe is named Dovber—he's named after the Maggid of Mezrich. That was the son who was blessed by Rabbi Dovber.
So, Yud-Tes Kislev is the day of passing. We know the day of passing of a tzaddik is not a sad day in essence. Of course, a tzaddik's passing—we love the tzaddik, we want the tzaddik to be with us—but we know that when a tzaddik passes, especially a Jewish leader, he doesn't just leave us behind. In a way, when he's alive, he's restricted by his physical abilities, but when he passes away, he can actually reach even further and deeper because he doesn't have any restrictions anymore, doesn't have any limitations. While you're in your physical body, you still have restrictions and limitations. Therefore, it's known that when a tzaddik passes away, he doesn't leave his flock just like that, but he actually ends up taking care of them. The passing of a tzaddik is called the Yom Hilulah—it's a very special day in which his good deeds and everything that the tzaddik did, as the Alter Rebbe explains in Tanya, are elevated and have a special impact.
Therefore, on this day, the 19th of Kislev, when it was the passing of Rabbi Dovber, even though it's a passing, it's still considered a day to remember, a day to connect, a day to reflect. That was the teacher of the Alter Rebbe.
In 1798, the Alter Rebbe, Rabbi Schneur Zalman, was released from prison. Now, as I said before, you see that there were some years that passed between the passing—there were about 36 years between them, between the Maggid of Mezrich and the Alter Rebbe. The Maggid of Mezrich once said to the Alter Rebbe that this day is our holiday—in other words, he shares the holiday with his teacher. The Maggid passed away in 1772, and the Alter Rebbe, Rabbi Schneur Zalman, was released from prison in 1798 on the same Hebrew date of Kislev 19.
Yud-Tes Kislev: The Chassidic "Rosh Hashanah"
Kislev 19 therefore became a major holiday celebration in the Chassidic communities, especially in the Lubavitch community. Kislev 19 is considered the greatest holiday. The Alter Rebbe, Rabbi Shneur Zalman, who was the founder of Chabad, was released from prison on this day. This release was taken as an approval from above that the Rebbe's teachings, his ideas, and his philosophy are important and will endure.
The Alter Rebbe was imprisoned because there was slander against him. Various accusations were brought against him. Sometimes, unfortunately, the infighting within the Jewish community gets out of hand, and people turn to the authorities, to the non-Jewish officials who have no real understanding of what is going on in the Jewish community, just to settle their own differences. The Misnagdim, the opposition to the Alter Rebbe, came and slandered him, and they succeeded in having him arrested. He was in real danger of losing this battle with the Misnagdim.
But in the inner dimension of things, this was never seen as just something that happens. Nothing happens in the world just like that. There is always a deeper, spiritual reason. The Alter Rebbe himself spoke about this. He related that, on a spiritual level, after the Maggid of Mezritch had already passed away, the Maggid came to visit him in prison together with the Baal Shem Tov. The Alter Rebbe asked them, "Why do I deserve this? Why am I in prison?" They answered that there was a criticism in the spiritual worlds because he was revealing and spreading such lofty, spiritual, hidden ideas that were not really meant for ordinary people to study and learn. There was a big criticism, and that is why he was imprisoned—to stop him.
The Alter Rebbe then asked them, "Does that mean that if I get out, I should stop?" They told him, "No. Now that you have started, do not stop. You should continue—not only continue, but with even more force than before." This is a very well-known story.
There are many fantastic stories about the Baal Shem Tov, including the story where the Baal Shem Tov himself writes that he had an aliyas neshama—his soul ascended to the spiritual worlds—and he came to the chamber where Mashiach was. He asked Mashiach the question that we all have: "Amasai ka'asi mar—Master, when will you come?" The Baal Shem Tov, in his spiritual elevation, came to the room of Mashiach and asked him, "Amasai ka'asi mar—when will you come?" Mashiach answered him, "When your wellsprings will be spread forth." The word yafutzu means that they will be spread out in a large way. "Your wellsprings" refers to the teachings of Chassidus. That is when Mashiach will come.
The Alter Rebbe said that after his release from prison in 1798, that is when the real spreading of Chassidus began in earnest. The Alter Rebbe used to live in a town called Liozhna before he was arrested. There, his influence was limited. But after he was released from prison, he moved to a new city called Lyadi. The governor of Lyadi was very impressed with and friendly to the Alter Rebbe. They built a shul and houses, and all the Chassidim came there. This continued until the war with Napoleon, when the Alter Rebbe had to flee, and unfortunately, he passed away on Chof-Daled Teves after that. But those years in Lyadi were years when the Alter Rebbe was able to teach, to bring his energy, learning, and holiness to the masses in an unprecedented way. That was the real yafutzu mayonosecha chutzah—the spreading of the wellsprings outward.
So for Chassidim, Kislev 19—Yud-Tes Kislev, which falls this Shabbos—is considered a major, major Chassidic holiday, the one holiday, because it was taken as the day when the Rebbe was approved from above to continue in his ways, and this is what will lead to the coming of Mashiach. The 19th day of Kislev is two things, as we mentioned: the passing of the Maggid, Dovber, and the release of the Alter Rebbe.
Connecting Yud-Tes Kislev to Parshas Vayishlach
Now, let's connect this to the parsha. In Parshas Vayishlach, chapter 32, verse 4, at the beginning of the portion, it says, "Vayishlach Yaakov malochim lefonov"—"Yaakov sent messengers ahead of him to his brother Esav, to the land of Seir, the field of Edom." That is where Esav lived. He sent them toward him.
As we mentioned earlier, it says that Yaakov sent messengers. Rashi explains and interprets: Who were these malochim? Who did he send? Rashi says immediately, "malochim mamash"—they were actually angels. It was not just messengers, not just human beings. It is amazing—these were actual angels, not regular messengers. It is actually amazing that Yaakov had at his disposal these angels. We read before that he saw the angels going up and down. Not only did he see them in his dream, but he could actually send them. Most of the time, we know that Hashem sends angels; we do not usually hear of people sending angels. Yes, there are stories in Tanach, but generally speaking, angels are reserved for missions that Hashem sends them on. In this case, Rashi says that Yaakov sent them—malochim mamash.
I am not going to go into the Meforshim, the commentaries on the Torah, who wonder why Rashi has to say this—that these were actually angels. Why can't we say they were just messengers? If he was just trying to convey a message to his brother, why would he have to use angels? Why was it necessary? But the bottom line is, Rashi says, "malochim mamash"—he actually sent angels.
There is an interesting teaching from the Maggid of Mezritch. As he was lying on his deathbed, before he passed away—it was on Kislev 19, and it was also Parshas Vayishlach—he made an interesting play on the words. Literally, malochim mamash means "actual angels." But he interpreted it differently: malochim mamash—he only sent the mamash (the physical aspect) of the angels. Basically, an angel has a spiritual part, but also a sort of physical part, relative to its spiritual essence. The Maggid said that the mamash—the tangible aspect—of the angels was sent, but the actual spiritual angels remained back home with Yaakov. He did not fully send them; he sent only a part of them, almost like a partial presence.
Engaging with the World Without Losing Ourselves
The Rebbe explains at length that Yaakov's confrontation with Esav is not just a story of two brothers, but a lesson for our own lives. Each of us has to deal with our own "Esavs"—sometimes these are external forces that try to harm us, and sometimes they are internal, like our own insecurities, worries, or personal struggles. Just as Yaakov had to confront Esav, we too must face and sometimes even engage with these challenges. The Rebbe draws a parallel to the way the previous Rebbe and the Rebbe would send Chassidim, shluchim, out into communities. These shluchim have to confront all sorts of challenges on their journeys and must engage with the world around them.
The Rebbe teaches that when we send ourselves out to deal with the world, we should only send a part of ourselves—our "mamash," our external, tangible side. We must keep our true selves, our spiritual core, on a higher level and not allow ourselves to descend completely into the worldliness of Esav. While we have to navigate and negotiate with the world, and deal with the "other side," this engagement should be only external. Internally, we must always remain connected to holiness. The "malach"—the angel—within us represents our spirituality, while our "mamash" is our physicality, our needs. We should never send away our malach; our higher levels should remain with Yaakov, with our source. In simple terms, even as we engage in the world—eating, drinking, working, doing business—only our external part should be involved. Our neshamah, our soul, should always remain above, never truly descending to the level of Esav. Only our "mamash," our tangible self, is sent out; our essence stays above.
Two Levels of Serving Hashem in Daily Life
The Rebbe brings from the Rambam that there are two ways to serve Hashem, even outside of the obvious mitzvos like lighting Shabbos candles, making a bracha, helping others, or giving tzedakah. These are the clear ways of serving Hashem. But even when we are not actively doing a mitzvah—when we are just going about our daily business, not in shul, not learning Torah, not visibly doing something holy—we can still serve Hashem.
The Rambam writes about two levels. The first is based on the verse in Mishlei: "In all your ways, know Him" (Mishlei 3:6). The key words are b'chol drachecha da'ehu—"in all your ways, know Hashem." This means that even as you go about your own ways—walking in the street, going for a walk, doing business—you can come to know Hashem. For example, you might notice Hashem's greatness and divine protection in the singing of a bird, the beauty of flowers, or in a chance encounter with someone. Even in your regular, mundane activities, you can come to know Hashem. This is called drachecha—your ways. You're not doing anything explicitly for Hashem, but you see Him in your daily life.
But there is another level, which is actually the first step, brought in Pirkei Avos: "All your deeds should be for the sake of Heaven" (v'chol ma'asecha yehiyu l'shem shamayim). This means that whatever you do—business, walking, eating, drinking—should be done with a purpose: for the sake of Heaven. For example, you might go for a walk to be healthy, so that your mind will be strong, and with a strong mind you can love Hashem, have awe of Hashem, and study Torah. So even in your regular activities, your intention is that they should serve a higher purpose. This is the first level: doing your own things, but with the intention that they are for Hashem.
The second, higher level is b'chol drachecha da'ehu: not only are your actions for a purpose, but you actually see Hashem in the action itself. It's not just a means to an end; the act itself becomes a way of connecting to Hashem. For example, enjoying a good meal on Shabbos—the meal itself is a mitzvah, not just a physical act for some other goal. You come to appreciate everything Hashem has created in your life itself.
The Alter Rebbe and the Oversalted Soup
There is a story told about the Alter Rebbe. Once, an important guest was coming to visit him. Because of the guest's importance, the whole community got involved in preparing the meal. All the women in the kitchen wanted to participate, so they divided up the tasks among themselves. But they forgot to assign who would salt the soup. Each woman, thinking perhaps the others had forgotten, quietly added salt to the soup when no one was looking. By the end, five or seven women had each put in salt.
When the food was brought before the Alter Rebbe and the guest, the Alter Rebbe ate it as he always did. But the guest tasted it and put it aside. The Alter Rebbe asked him why he wasn't eating. The guest replied, "It's oversalted; I can't eat it." The Alter Rebbe explained that when he was still by his teacher in Mezritch, he was so removed from physicality that he didn't even taste the food. He simply ate without noticing the taste.
Levels of Serving Hashem: From L'Shem Sh'mayim to Complete Bitul
He ate, but his eating was on such a level that it was all for the service of Hashem. It wasn't about the physical pleasure; even the taste of the food didn't impact him. Now, this is not a level that anybody can easily reach, but the idea is to consider how much our physicality really takes up space within us. At first, a person can serve Hashem with their soul, doing things for the sake of Hashem, in the way of l'shem Shomayim—for the sake of Heaven. But when you reach a higher level, you come to a place where all you see is Hashem in whatever you do. Your whole life, everything you see in the world, is Hashem. People who can really see things this way don't see physical, material things; they see Hashem everywhere. In everything that happens in their lives, in everything that goes on in the world, they only see Hashem. That is a very high level, and it's not easy to live that way.
When it comes to Yud-Tes Kislev, it's a special time to reflect on this teaching of Chassidus, which was meant to bring out the deeper part of ourselves. We have who we think we are on the external level, but then we have a deeper layer, a much more intense inside. When it comes the time of Yud-Tes Kislev, with Chassidus revealing the inner dimension, we can reveal within ourselves this extra, deeper level. So, on the first level, we have to reveal in ourselves that what we do should be for Hashem's purposes. But then we move up to a higher level, where our whole being, whatever we do, is just for Hashem—there's nothing else. There's no world, there's no separation. Everything in our lives becomes just Hashem. "In all your ways, know Him"—we see Hashem in everything that we do.
Esav Leaves Canaan: The End of the Parsha
I want to go over another part of the parsha. This is not directly related to Yud-Tes Kislev, but just to cover another section of the portion. It so turns out that most of the time, when I give over something, it's from the beginning of the parsha and something from the end of the parsha. That means we have to cover everything in between, and there's so much to cover. We read something very interesting at the end.
Yaakov sends the gift, then we have the whole story with Dina being captured by Shechem, and a lot of stories happen in the parsha. But when we come to the end, we read something amazing. It says that at the end of the day, when Yaakov moved back to his father, he's back in Canaan, the land of Canaan. The Torah says that Esav took his wives, his sons, and his daughters, all of his family, all that he acquired, all of his animals, and all that he had acquired in the land of Canaan, and he left to a land because of his brother Yaakov.
What does it mean he left because of his brother Yaakov? The verse tells you they had too much fortune; it was too much for them to be able to live together, because the land where they were living could not carry them because of all the cattle that they had. So they couldn't be there together—Esav leaves, and Yaakov stays. That's towards the end of the parsha.
Rashi comments here: what does it mean that the land could not sustain them, couldn't hold them, couldn't carry them? Rashi says it was because there was not enough feed for all the animals. There wasn't enough to feed all the animals, so Esav picked up and left. We had a similar story before with Lot and Avraham; they were fighting over there, and Lot left because of it. So again, there wasn't enough.
But here, Rashi brings down a very interesting Midrash Aggadah, an aggadic Midrash. It says that the reason Esav left was because of his brother Yaakov. What does it mean "because of his brother Yaakov"? Because there was a debt that was due to be paid. What was the debt? Way back earlier, in Parshas Lech Lecha, chapter 15, verse 13, Avraham has a dream—the dream in which Hashem makes a covenant with him. Hashem says, "Your seed will be a stranger in a land that is not theirs, and they will serve them, and they will afflict them" (Bereishis 15:13). Basically, Hashem tells Avraham that his descendants are going to have a hard time; the seed of Avraham, or the seed of Yitzchak, has to pay the price.
So Esav says, I'm leaving, I'm out of here. I don't need the gift, I don't want this land, and neither do I want to pay the debt. I don't want to be in a strange land. So the reason why he left, in one interpretation from the Midrash, is because there was a debt to pay for the one who gets the land of Canaan. Esav said, I don't want the land of Canaan, and I don't want to pay the debt, so I'm out of here.
Then Rashi brings another reason: because he was ashamed. Esav was ashamed that he sold his firstborn rights to his brother Yaakov, to his younger brother. So that's why he left.
The Rebbe's Question on Rashi's Explanation
The Rebbe has a whole long explanation, but he asks a very simple question. In the posuk, it gives you a reason directly: why did they not stay together? Why could they not stay together? Because there wasn't enough feed. That's what it says in the posuk. Why does Rashi come up with other reasonings that seem to go against what the posuk says? The posuk gives the reason that the land could not provide enough feed for both of their cattle. Yet Rashi says, no, Esav left for another reason—either because he didn't want the land and didn't want to pay the price that comes with the land, or because he was ashamed. But that doesn't say in the posuk. Why does Rashi say something different?
The Rebbe brings a beautiful insight here. It's a little bit surprising: Yaakov was away all this time, and now Yaakov comes back. Who was there? Esav was there. That's a whole other question, because it seems like Esav still lived there, even though he had already gone to Edom before. It says, "Vayishlach Yaakov"—he sends to Seir, to Edom. But apparently, Esav was all over the place, but he still was living together with his parents in Eretz Canaan, in the land of Canaan.
Now, a newcomer comes—Yaakov. Yaakov moves in after being with Lavan for 20 years, and as we said before, 34 years and two years on the road, so it's 36 years. Now, all of a sudden, Yaakov comes, and Esav picks up and leaves. The question is: why was Esav such a gentleman? As soon as Yaakov comes, he decides to leave because there's not enough? Let him tell Yaakov, there's not enough feed here—you go.
Esav's Departure and Our Sense of Exile
What Rashi is trying to explain, and as the Rebbe explains, is that there were other reasons for Esav’s departure. Why did Esav wait until now to leave? Esav had reasons that he really didn’t want to be there, but this situation was just the impetus. He left now because there was a lot of cattle, and he felt that with Yaakov there, let him take it. It wasn’t because Esav was such a gentleman. He had shame for Yaakov, and he didn’t want to pay the debt, so he decided to leave. Basically, why did he leave right now? Because Yaakov suddenly came, and now it became a choice—who gets to stay, who goes? Esav said, “I really don’t want to have anything to do with this, and I’m ready to leave.”
It turns out there are two reasons for Esav leaving. The main reason was that, right now, when they both arrived, there wasn’t enough to support them both. But Esav had other reasons in mind from before. He didn’t leave earlier because it wasn’t so bad, but now that he found a reason, he goes ahead and leaves.
The question is, really, Esav was also in a strange land, because the fact that he went to the land of Seir—that was a strange land. But the Rebbe says that even if you go to a strange land, you can live there and become settled, or you can live there always feeling, “This is not where I belong.”
We Jews live, Baruch Hashem, in the United States. Whether you like the president or not, the new one or the old one, still, in our day-to-day life, we live, thank God, a very good life, Baruch Hashem. Physically, most of us—of course, there are a lot of tourists now with the pandemic—but most of us, reasonably, if you consider what people had to go through, we have it good. But we have to remember: we shouldn’t feel like we truly belong here. That’s not good. We need to know that we belong in Eretz Yisroel. We belong in the Holy Land. We belong with Moshiach coming and redeeming us. We have something more than just this material, physical life. We have a powerful connection to Hashem, to Eretz Yisroel. That’s who we really are.
So while Esav in Har Seir settled there and was happy, we have to feel that we are still strangers. If we’re not in Eretz Yisroel, we are not truly at home. Unfortunately, it’s very real that some of the antisemitism that is dormant, that you don’t feel or hear, can pop up so easily. You can really understand that this is not ultimately where we belong. Baruch Hashem, as I said before, considering everything, we live relatively peacefully. But that’s why it’s important for us to always keep in mind that we’re still not home. This is not where we want to be. Yes, we’re here for various reasons—I’m not saying whether we’re right or wrong—but that’s the fact. The bottom line is, we still want to be in Eretz Yisroel.
So while Esav lived in a strange land but settled there, and that became his land, we, as long as we are in Galus, don’t feel ourselves truly at home. Our home is Eretz Yisroel. That’s where we belong. That’s where we really are.
A Family Story of Survival and Connection
Let me share a story. My sister called me up just two weeks ago. I want you to understand—my sister has an extended family: children, grandchildren, great-grandchildren, marriages. Baruch Hashem, she has a large family of her own. What happens is, as families grow, you become a little bit further apart. We each have our own families, and we’re not as close as you might think siblings would be. As a matter of fact, I never really grew up together with my sister. By the time I was four, she got married and moved out. But of course, she was my older sister, and I always looked up to her. They lived in Pittsburgh all these years. It’s not that far, and they would come to us, we would go there. But then, when her kids got married and had their own large families, everyone became a little more distant.
Her husband, my brother-in-law, passed away. I called a few times, but all of a sudden, she calls me last Saturday night—two weeks ago, actually more than two weeks ago—and she starts talking. I thought maybe she was losing it a little bit, because some of the things she was saying made me wonder if she was fully cognitive. But then she tells me this story. Now, I knew this story for many years, but I didn’t know the end of it. She told me that a woman, Dassa Levine—who I knew, because I knew the person; she passed away a long time ago—told her that my sister saved her life.
So what’s the story? My parents got married right at the beginning of World War II. When the war broke out, many Jewish people ran further away into Uzbekistan, to a place called Samarkand. They lived there, and it was still a very difficult time for the Jewish people. My sister was born there. Even then, the KGB, the Secret Service, the police, were after people. It was difficult for everyone because of the war, but for Jews, and especially for religious Jews like the Chassidim who were there, it was immensely hard. My father was always worried. In their house, they had a cupboard with a hidden back. The plan was that if an agent ever came looking for my father, he would hide behind the cupboard.
My sister was a little girl. She went through a lot before coming to the United States. First, they went to Austria and the DP camps, then to Paris, and from Paris to Besan, a suburb of Paris. Then they went to Dublin, Ireland. Finally, in 1953, they came to the United States. She grew up between Samarkand, the DP camps, Paris, France, and Ireland. By the time she came to the United States, she was maybe sixteen years old.
Her teacher in one of the places in Paris was this woman, Dassa Levine, who told her that she saved her life. So what happened?
Living in Exile and the Sense of Belonging
So these agents, the KGB, came knocking at the door of my parents in Samarkand. The signal was there. My father went and hid in the closet. They started asking my mother, "Where is the man of the house?" and so on. She said, "There is nobody here." But my sister started screaming in Russian, "My father is there!" She went to the closet—she had seen him go away—and she gave it away. My father came out, shivering, because there was nothing else he could do. He walked out, and they didn't do anything to him. They let him go. They warned him, but they didn't bother him further.
What really happened, at the end of the story, was that this Dassa Levine, who taught my sister, told her that she and her own sister—Dassa's sister—were about ten years old at the time. Whenever people needed to go to the black market or to collect something, to do something risky, they would send these girls. What were the authorities going to do? They weren't going to bother a ten-year-old girl. So they used to send them, and mysteriously, these girls were all over the place, doing all kinds of shtick, all kinds of tricks, and the authorities could never catch them. Finally, they cornered them when they came into my parents' house. That's where they came in to do something. And because of the whole commotion—my sister screaming, "tamoy papa, tamoy papa," that my father is there—they were able to escape and run away. The reason the authorities didn't do anything to my father was because they hadn't come for him; they came for these girls. They were going after them, and they finally figured out where they were. That escape, she said, saved their lives, because it was only because of this commotion that they were able to get away. So my father got away with just being scared.
I think about these things and I shudder. Look what they had to go through for nothing. They didn't do anything, they didn't bother anyone, and yet they were persecuted, they were chased, they were afraid all the time. Living over there, they knew that they didn't belong there. But sometimes, by accident, we start to feel that we do belong here. We think to ourselves, "Over here, this place is beautiful." But we have to remember that a yid, a Jew in exile, is never truly happy. It's never our place. Our place is Eretz Yisroel, and our place is spirituality.
The Lesson: Connecting to Hashem and Our True Place
So may Hashem help that, in the merit of these great tzaddikim—the Maggid of Mezritch, the Alter Rebbe—on their days of celebration, we should be inspired to follow their teachings, to try to do what's right, to connect to Hashem, and especially to connect to Hashem in an inner way. Not only externally, but to have our souls come out from within, as the Chassidic teaching is: to take the hidden parts of Torah and bring them out to revelation.