Support Torah
Recordings

Vayishlach – After Rachel passed, Reuven moved his father’s bed into his mother Leah’s tent

Classes, Vayishlach – After Rachel passed, Reuven moved his father’s bed into his mother Leah’s tent

ראובן מזיז את מיטת יעקב וכוח התשובה

Reuven Moves Yaakov's Bed and the Power of Teshuvah

This shiur explores Reuven's act of moving Yaakov's bed after Rachel's passing, the Torah's strong language about his action, and how Reuven became the first true baal teshuvah. It discusses the difference between teshuvah from fear and teshuvah from recognition, and the lesson for our own lives.
Prev Search
0:00 0:00
Next

Reuven Moves Yaakov's Bed After Rachel Passes

After Rachel passes away in Parshas Vayishlach, Reuven sees that Yaakov moves his bed—not into the tent of Leah, Reuven's mother, as Reuven expected, but into the tent of Bilhah, Rachel's maidservant. Disturbed by this, Reuven moves Yaakov's bed into Leah's tent. The Torah describes this act with strong language: "Reuven lay with Bilhah his father's concubine" (Bereishis 35:22). Rashi explains that because Reuven interfered in his father's intimate life, the Torah considers it as if he committed a grave sin.

Reuven Opens the Gates of Teshuvah

The Midrash teaches that Reuven was the one who opened the gates of teshuvah—repentance—for everyone else. Even after making a mistake, a person can repent. The Torah immediately follows this episode by stating, "And the sons of Yaakov were twelve" (Bereishis 35:22), showing that Reuven, despite his error, was still considered whole and his repentance was accepted. Thus, among Yaakov's children were not only tzaddikim, but also a baal teshuvah—one who returns in repentance. The Gemara (Berachos 34b) notes that a baal teshuvah can be even greater than a tzaddik.

Why Is Reuven Called the First Baal Teshuvah?

The Rebbe asks: Why does the Midrash say Reuven was the first baal teshuvah when Adam and Kayin also did teshuvah? The answer is that Adam and Kayin repented out of fear of punishment, while Reuven's teshuvah came from recognizing his own wrongdoing. His return was motivated by an internal realization, not by fear of retribution.

The Power of Teshuvah from Recognition

This highlights a deeper strength in Reuven's teshuvah. Often, people change their behavior out of fear of punishment, but true change comes from recognizing what is right. Reuven thought he was defending his mother's honor and believed he was doing a mitzvah. It is especially difficult to admit a mistake when one believes they are acting for a noble cause. Many troubles and disagreements among Jews come from people convinced they are doing what Hashem wants. Yet, sometimes, even when we think we are standing up for justice, it is not our place to get involved. Yaakov's private life was not Reuven's issue, and intervening was a violation, no matter how justified it seemed.

The Uniqueness of Reuven's Teshuvah

Reuven's greatness was his ability to recognize his mistake despite his good intentions. Admitting error when one feels justified requires tremendous strength. This is why Reuven is seen as the true baal teshuvah. Yaakov's children were all whole, including a son who could reach this level of self-awareness. "And the sons of Yaakov were twelve"—all together, forming a united Klal Yisroel, worthy of Hashem's blessing.

Reuven Moves Yaakov's Bed After Rachel Passes

In Parshas Vayishlach, we read about the incident that took place after Rachel passes away. After Rachel's passing, her eldest son, Reuven, sees that his father, Yaakov, moved his bed—which was normally in the tent of Rachel. Now that Rachel had passed away, Reuven expected that Yaakov would move his bed into the tent of his mother, Leah, who was Rachel's sister and Reuven's mother. But instead, Yaakov put his bed in the tent of Bilhah, the maidservant of Rachel. Reuven was very disturbed and upset about what his father did. So he went and moved the bed into his mother's tent, into the tent of Leah.

The Torah uses very strong words to describe this. The verse says that Reuven "lay with Bilhah his father's concubine" (Bereishis 35:22). Rashi explains that because Reuven mixed up the bedding of his father—he interfered in his father's intimate life, which was not his place—the Torah considers it as if he had committed a grave sin. That is why the Torah refers to it as if Reuven had lain with Bilhah.

Reuven Opens the Gates of Teshuvah

Yet, we know that the Midrash says Reuven was the one who opened up the level of teshuvah—repentance—for everyone else. As we read later on in the parsha, Reuven was the first one and he opened the gates of teshuvah. This means that even after someone makes a mistake and violates one of the laws or rules of the Torah, he can repent. Reuven repented to such an extent that the Torah says, right in the verse following this, "And the sons of Yaakov were twelve" (Bereishis 35:22). This means that even Reuven, who made this mistake, was really wholesome and complete, and his repentance was complete.

It turns out that Yaakov not only had children at the level of tzaddikim, but he even had a child at the level of a baal teshuvah—one who returns in repentance. In the Gemara, we find two opinions, but it seems that a baal teshuvah is even greater than a tzaddik (see Berachos 34b). So among Yaakov's children were many tzaddikim, but there was also a baal teshuvah, which is Reuven. He opened up the way of teshuvah.

Why Is Reuven Called the First Baal Teshuvah?

But the Rebbe asks: teshuvah is not something that started with Reuven. We find by Adam, we find by Kayin, that they also did teshuvah. Why does the Midrash say that Reuven opened up the door of teshuvah, that he was the first baal teshuvah? There were people before him who did teshuvah.

The Rebbe explains that while Adam and Cain did teshuvah, they did it out of fear of retribution. Their teshuvah, while it was teshuvah, came as a result of fear of punishment. Whereas Reuven's teshuvah came because of his realization that he made a mistake and that he had done a violation. His reason for returning was much stronger, because he realized that what he did was wrong.

The Power of Teshuvah from Recognition

Perhaps we can even add to this. In our lives, when we try to discipline children, sometimes they don't want to listen. What do we do? Sometimes they're afraid of punishment. A student in class might lose recess, or have to go to the principal, or lose some computer time—whatever the case is. Sometimes there is a way to enforce discipline through threatening punishment or through actual punishment. But, of course, that's not the same as when the realization comes from inside—that you don't do what's wrong or you change your ways not because of a threat, but out of recognition that it's the right thing to do.

Here is the additional strength of what Reuven did. This was a very difficult thing for Reuven to realize, because at first glance, when a person doesn't realize that they're making a mistake, they actually think they're doing a mitzvah. What did Reuven do here? Reuven thought he was standing up for his mother's honor. By all measures and standards, it would seem that Yaakov should have gone to his mother. Reuven was offended and took on his mother's case, her pain. His mother had suffered enough during Rachel's lifetime, since Yaakov liked Rachel more than Leah. Reuven was full of pain, and after Rachel's death, he stuck up for his mother.

It's so hard to realize sometimes that you've made a mistake when, on the surface, you actually think you're doing a big mitzvah. Most of the tzaros—troubles—that the Jewish people have come from those who think they're doing mitzvos. There's a lot of discontent, a lot of machlokes—disagreements—and a lot of hard feelings. If you ask people why they're behaving like this, they'll say, "What do you mean? I'm fighting for Hashem, I'm fighting for what's right, I'm doing the right thing." They're always thinking that what they're doing is what Hashem wants them to do.

It's a very fine line to reach the realization that, while you may think what you're doing is justice, that you're standing up for what's right and doing what's good, if it's not your place—if you see other rabbis having a disagreement, or other Yidden—it's not your place to get involved. It's not your issue. Yaakov's private life was not Reuven's issue. Reuven should not have gotten involved, no matter how bad it felt for his mother, no matter how much he wanted to stand up for her pain. It was not his responsibility, and for him it was a violation.

The Uniqueness of Reuven's Teshuvah

Herein lies the strength of Reuven's teshuvah. Sometimes you talk to people on this side of the fence or that side, and you try to tell them, "Why are you doing this?" Sometimes, in cases of shalom bayis—peace in the home—you try to say, "Do you know who she is?" It's so hard to step back and realize, "You know what? I'm actually wrong." Even though I think I'm so right, and even though I have all the excuses and all the reasons, at the end of the day, I'm actually wrong. That takes tremendous power. That was the power of Reuven's teshuvah—more than anything else—that he could realize that, notwithstanding all his good intentions, he had made a mistake.

That's why we can say that Reuven was the real level of a baal teshuvah, on the highest level. That's why Yaakov's children were all wholesome, that he could have a son who, even at that level, could recognize that he made a mistake. Then we know that Yaakov is perfect. "And the sons of Yaakov were twelve"—all the children were twelve, and all of Klal Yisroel, all of us together, are one unit, we're all together, and we receive Hashem's blessing.

Leave Feedback

{# Keyboard shortcuts: Alt+Left = previous shiur, Alt+Right = next shiur. Ignored while typing in a box or editor so Alt+arrow word-jumping still works there. #}