Yaakov's Struggle with the Ish
This week's parsha describes Yaakov left alone after transferring his family across the Nahal Yabok. He returns for some forgotten jugs and encounters an Ish—a man—with whom he wrestles. The Torah relates that the Ish could not overpower Yaakov, though Yaakov's hip was dislocated, leading to the prohibition of eating the Gid Hanasheh. Yaakov then asks the Ish for a blessing.
The question arises: who was this Ish that Yaakov struggled with?
Who Was the Ish? Rashi and Kabbalah
Rashi explains that the Ish was the guardian angel of Esav, making this a spiritual struggle between Yaakov and Esav. Years earlier, Yaakov had taken the blessings from Esav, who never forgave him. Now, as Yaakov returns from Lavan's house, Esav is coming to confront him, and before the physical encounter, his angel battles Yaakov. Rashi calls this angel the Sar shel Esav.
Kabbalah teaches that the Ish represents the evil side, the Samech Mem—the Satan—who battles against Yaakov. This symbolizes the evil forces that oppose the good within every Jew, represented by Yaakov. Whenever a Jew tries to do mitzvos and connect to Hashem, the Samech Mem tries to interfere and distract him from his service.
The Struggle in Daily Life
This struggle is not just historical; it happens daily. For example, when a person davens, he is fully focused and connected to Hashem. But after davening, as he enters his daily activities, the Ish—the Satan—returns to challenge him. Wrestling represents a close, personal struggle, not a distant attack. The Yetzer Hara tries to entice a person with temptations, pulling his mind away from Hashem.
This is the ongoing battle: the Samech Mem tries to divert a Jew from his connection to Hashem with challenges and temptations.
Maintaining the Inspiration of Davening
To overcome this, a Jew must strive to keep the inspiration and connection from davening throughout the day. Davening at the start, middle, and end of the day gives strength and energy. If one holds on to that closeness to Hashem, the Ish cannot defeat him.
The Meaning of Yaakov's Name
Yaakov's name is made of Yud and Ekev. Yud, the smallest letter and the first of Hashem's name, represents the highest spirituality. Ekev means heel, the lowest part. Yaakov brings the Yud—the spiritual inspiration—down into the Ekev, into everyday actions. This means conducting all activities, including work, with honesty and according to halacha, carrying the inspiration of davening into daily life.
When we do this, "lo yuchal lo"—the Yetzer Hara and all negative forces cannot overpower us. Like Yaakov, we can continue forward, returning to Eretz Yisroel, with Hashem's help.
Yaakov's Struggle with the Ish
In this week's parsha, we find that Yaakov had a struggle with a man. The Torah says, "Vayevaser Yaakov levado"—Yaakov was left alone. He had transferred his whole family to the other side of the brook, the Nahal Yabok, and then went back over to fetch a few leftover jugs he had left there. At that point, he meets up with this Ish—a man—and they have a struggle.
The Torah relates that eventually there was a discussion between Yaakov and this Ish. The Ish could not overpower Yaakov, and Yaakov was only hurt—his hip was dislocated. This is the Gid Hanasheh, and from here we learn the prohibition regarding the Gid Hanasheh. Then Yaakov asks the Ish to bless him, and the story continues as we read in the Chumash.
But just on this verse: who was this Ish that Yaakov encountered, the one wrestling and battling with him?
Who Was the Ish? Rashi and Kabbalah
Rashi, on the simple literal level of the explanation of the Chumash, says this was the guardian angel of Esav. So, basically, this was a struggle between Yaakov and Esav. Yaakov had taken the blessings many years before from Esav. Esav never forgot or forgave him. Now, when Yaakov is leaving the home of Lavan after twenty years, he meets Esav again—Esav is coming to fight, to even out the scores with Yaakov. Before Esav himself comes, Esav's angel is battling Yaakov. That is how Rashi explains the whole event with the officer, the angel, Sar shel Esav.
In Kabbalah, it is also brought down that this Ish represents, in general, the evil side, or the Samech Mem as it is known—the Satan, the other side—which is battling against Yaakov. These are the evil forces that stand in the way and wrestle with the positive and the good that is within every Jew, which is represented by Yaakov.
Many times, when a Yid—a Jew—is standing and trying to do mitzvos, trying to connect to Hashem, this Ish, the Samech Mem, the Satan, comes and tries to interfere, to get the person away from his service to Hashem.
The Struggle in Daily Life
There is a certain level of excitement, for example, when a person davens. In the morning, he puts his tallis over his head and concentrates on the words he is saying. During Shemonah Esrei, he closes his eyes so that the whole world doesn't exist at that time—he is connected and bound to Hashem. But what happens when he opens his eyes after finishing Shemonah Esrei? He finishes davening and goes out into his daily activities. Once again, he has to encounter the Ish—the Satan comes again and tries to struggle with him.
When you wrestle, it is a battle that takes place when one is trying to embrace and hug the other person, to throw them over and push them to the ground. Not by shooting from afar, but actually through the embrace. What this represents is that the Satan, the Yetzer Hara, tries to get the person to fall by enticing him with all the goodies, with all the different desires, trying to get his mind away from his connection to Hashem.
This is the battle of the Ish against Yaakov—the battle of the Samech Mem, who struggles and tries to get a Yid away from his service and connection to Hashem, putting all kinds of things in his way: challenges, struggles, and temptations to try to divert his attention from Hashem and to follow after him.
Maintaining the Inspiration of Davening
For this, we say that at the end of the day, if a Yid makes a determination and wants to stay strong, to keep that fire, that experience, that connection to Hashem that he had during davening—that is actually the reason why we start the day with davening, in the middle of the day with davening, and at the end of the day as well. Davening inspires the person and gives him the energy he needs.
We say that notwithstanding the struggle, even though the Samech Mem tries to trip you, if a person stays strong and keeps that experience he had during davening—the closeness he felt with Hashem—and holds on to it, then the Ish cannot win. He is not able to put Yaakov to the ground.
The Meaning of Yaakov's Name
The word Yaakov is made up of two parts: Yud and Ekev. Yaakov is Yud, Ekev. Ekev means the heel. Yud is the smallest of the letters, and it is the first letter of the Shem Havayah, Hashem's name—Yud, Kei, Vav, Kei. The letter Yud represents the highest level of spirituality. Yaakov brings down and experiences the Yud, the highest level, all the way into the Ekev, the heel. This means he takes that experience and closeness to Hashem—the letter Yud—and brings it down into all the activities that he does. So when he goes out to work, he knows that work needs to be done as a Jewish person should, according to halacha: no cheating, no tricking, no dishonesty. He takes along that inspiration, that Yud, down to the Ekev.
Then, "lo yuchal lo"—the Yetzer Hara, the Samech Mem, and all the forces that try to hug us and entice us are not able to overpower us. We continue as Yaakov, successfully marching on as Yaakov did, back to Be'er Sheva, back to Eretz Yisroel. Bimheira v'yameinu, amen.