The Significance of Esav’s Lineage in Parshas Vayishlach
Chapter 36 of Bereishis is devoted to the lineage of Esav, describing his family, the Seir HaChori family, and the land of Edom in great detail. Many tend to skim this section, thinking the names and relationships are not relevant. But a closer look reveals important lessons about family dynamics, relationships, and the moral environment in Esav’s world. The Torah’s detailed account highlights the depth of immorality and complex relationships—incest and other forms of promiscuity—within Esav’s family.
There is a well-known expression: we wish each other "Yiddishe nachas"—true Jewish pride and joy. Among Chassidim, it is called "Chassidishe nachas." This is contrasted with the name Nachas, which appears among Esav’s descendants in the parsha, emphasizing that the nachas we seek is of a different, holier kind.
The Changing Names of Esav’s Wives
If the Torah were simply a history book, the frequent changes in names would be confusing. In Parshas Toldos, Esav’s wives are listed with certain names, but in Parshas Vayishlach, the names and even the names of their parents are different. Without Rashi’s commentary, one might think these are different wives or that Esav remarried. Rashi clarifies that they are the same women, and the names were changed for specific reasons. For example, Esav gave his wives righteous-sounding names to deceive his father Yitzchok into thinking they were pious. The details of these name changes are complex, but the main point is that the Torah is teaching us something deeper through these changes.
The Puzzle of Oholivamah’s Parentage
The Torah describes one of Esav’s wives as Oholivamah bas Anah bas Tzivon haChivi. This raises a question: was Oholivamah the daughter of Anah or of Tzivon? The Torah refers to her as the daughter of both, which is unusual. Rashi explains that Oholivamah’s biological father was Tzivon, but people believed she was the daughter of Anah because she was born to Anah’s wife. Tzivon had a relationship with Anah’s wife, resulting in Oholivamah’s birth. Thus, the Torah calls her both bas Anah and bas Tzivon, reflecting both the reality and the public perception.
This complexity is just one example of the tangled and often immoral relationships in Esav’s family. The Torah’s account is not just a historical record but a lesson in the consequences of such behavior and the contrast with the families of Avraham, Yitzchok, and Yaakov.
Lineage, Morality, and Our Heritage
Rashi points out that many of the births in Esav’s family were illegitimate, involving incest and other forbidden relationships. In just a few verses, the Torah reveals much about the lifestyle and values of Esav’s descendants. In contrast, Yaakov’s family is described as mitaso shleima—his bed was complete—meaning all his children were righteous and connected to Hashem. This stark difference highlights the holiness and purity of the Jewish lineage compared to Esav’s.
The Torah gives us these details to send a powerful message: we must recognize the beauty and sanctity of our heritage. Our lineage is holier and purer, and with that comes a responsibility to appreciate who we are and where we come from. The Torah’s detailed account is meant to inspire us to value our identity and live up to the standards set by our forefathers.
The Lineage of Esav in Parshas Vayishlach
The entire chapter 36 in Bereishis is devoted to the discussion and the lineage of Esav's family in great detail. Esav's family, the Seir HaChori family, and the place of Edom where Esav settled are all described. Usually, we just run through this section quickly. It doesn't seem to have that much significance or importance to us—the various different names, the various different relationships that took place over there—we tend to skim through it. But when you pay a little bit closer attention, it's really fascinating to see what the parsha tells us about different things we can learn about their families, about their relationships, and about the different things that were going on over there. As a matter of fact, the depth of immorality, the relationships—incest and all kinds of promiscuous relationships—over there is just mind-boggling. I'll try to share with you just a few things from there.
It's also interesting—I once heard an expression. When there is a blessing, we wish each other, "You should have Yiddishe nachas." That expression, "You should have Yiddishe nachas." By Chassidim, they say "Chassidishe nachas." But at least, you know, Yiddishe nachas. So why Yiddishe nachas? Because we see that one of the descendants of Esav was also called Nachas. So we make a distinction—we say you should have nachas, not like the Nachas over here in the parsha, but it should be Yiddishe nachas, the real pride, Yiddishe nachas.
If the Torah was just a history book, just telling you the story, we wouldn't really understand why the Torah chooses to change around names all the time. It's just so confusing when you read, two parshas back, in Parshas Toldos, the Torah relates to you the women that Esav married. First he married two women, then he married somebody else, a third woman—three wives he had. The Torah stops and tells you a little bit about it. In this week's parsha, at the end of Vayishlach, the Torah talks about those three women, but guess what? Not even one of these wives of Esav has the same name. They're all different names. It talks about Esav being married to three wives and the children that they had, but all the names here are altered. Not only the names—their names and the parents' names too. Because it says "the daughter of," and that changes too. In one case it's the same, but in the two other cases it changes. There are different names.
So, one reading the parsha—if you don't read the Rashi, you don't read the commentaries—maybe you think, maybe he had three wives, maybe these are different wives, maybe he divorced those wives, maybe he married somebody else. The names don't match. Rashi tells you no, these are exactly the same. He gives you a reason why the names were changed, and that there is a reason. Part of it is Esav scheming to deceive his father and show himself as righteous—he named them with righteous names, like the name Yehudis, to show that she's very religious. The name Bosmas—there are various explanations. It's too long to go through this whole detail; it's very interesting, but it's a long discussion. I want to just stop on one aspect over here.
The Puzzle of Olivamah's Parentage
The Torah calls the names over here, who Esav married. One was Oholivamah bas Anah bas Tzivon haChivi. By the way, it's interesting to read here because you see where Amolek comes from. You see all the trouble that the Jewish people had throughout the generations and history. When you read the section of Bereishis in general, and you see the children, and then you meet them once again later on in the story—some of it in Parshas Devarim, in the rest of Tanach—it's very interesting to be able to connect the puzzle and the pieces over here, to see who comes from where and how it all developed.
We know we have Amolek, dealing in Chumash Shemos, thirteen parshas after the Jews left Mitzrayim. That war with Amolek didn't begin over there. Why did Amolek all of a sudden come after the Jews left Egypt? All of a sudden Amolek pipes up. It wasn't like that. There was a cheshbon over here, a reckoning. It all stemmed from this battle between Esav and Yaakov. And of course, in Kabbalah, Esav and Yaakov—as we talked about yesterday—they represent the more general battle that goes on between good and evil, between ourselves, the yetzer tov and the yetzer hara, between the bad in the world and the good in the world. So this is an ongoing battle. With Yaakov taking the blessings from Yitzchok, and Esav here, the sar of Esav battling Yaakov, and then eventually it went on to the children. It went on to Elifaz. Elifaz was sort of chetzi-chetzi, as Rashi brings down. He was still raised by Yitzchok, so he didn't want to really kill Yaakov. But eventually Amolek comes from there, and Amolek has been on the Jewish case since then, fighting the Jewish people. But in any event, that's a different discussion.
I wanted to just stop at the name of the wife over here. The Torah calls her Oholivamah bas Anah bas Tzivon haChivi. Her name was Oholivamah. She was the daughter of whom? It says bas Anah, and then it says she was the daughter of Tzivon. But wait a minute. Whose daughter was she? Was she Anah's daughter, or was she Tzivon's daughter? The Torah says both. The Torah says she was bas Anah, and it says bas Tzivon. That's unusual. The Torah usually says bas one name; it doesn't say two bas. Well, one can say maybe it's a granddaughter. But Anah is the name of a male—it's a man. Bas Anah. So we can't say bas Tzivon, we can't say Anah is the daughter of Tzivon, because Anah wasn't a daughter; Anah was a man. So it's still going back to Oholivamah—that Oholivamah was the daughter of Anah, Oholivamah was the daughter of Tzivon. How could Oholivamah be the daughter of Anah and be the daughter of Tzivon at the same time? Who was her father? Was the father Anah or the father Tzivon?
Rashi goes and explains that over here, actually her real father was Tzivon. That was her real father. But people thought that she was the daughter of Anah, because there was a relationship that took place between Tzivon and Anah's wife. So the Torah calls her bas Anah, the daughter of Anah, because people thought that this Oholivamah—she was born by Anah's wife. So people assumed that if Anah's wife gave birth to this Oholivamah, who married Esav, that probably the father must be Anah, because that's the husband of Oholivamah's mother. That was his wife, and if she gave birth, it must be him. The Torah is telling us that she was bas Tzivon, because Tzivon actually had a relationship with Anah's wife and gave birth to Oholivamah, who later on married Esav.
Are you still with me? Because it gets more complicated than that. But I don't know if at five o'clock in the evening, after a day, when you go through—I’m going to leave it at that because of the time constraint.
The Torah’s Emphasis on Lineage and Morality
When you go through these verses, as Rashi points out, you see that many of these births in the family of Esav were illegitimate. There were incestuous relationships—mamzeirus after mamzeirus, generation after generation. In these three or four verses, we learn so much about their lifestyle, about who they really were. When you contrast that with Avraham, Yitzchak, Yaakov, and especially Yaakov and his children—mitaso shleima, his bed was complete—you can see the difference between the descendants and the children of Yaakov and those of Esav. How much holier, how much more connected the descendants of Yaakov were to Hashem, to morality, and to the way of life that is expected from us, as opposed to all these people coming from Esav and all these families.
Just to go through some of the details here, it’s really fascinating. The Torah tells us all these things to send us a very strong message: we need to realize where we are standing, where we come from, our heritage and our lineage—how much more beautiful, how much holier, how much purer it is than the other side. That’s why the Torah troubles itself to give us so many details, so many names, and so much about what took place there, even though it doesn’t seem like it has a very direct and immediate connection to us. The Torah is teaching us to appreciate who we are, where we come from, and the responsibility that comes with that.