Support Torah
Recordings

כד תשרי תקס"א - המאסר השני של אדמו"ר הזקן

24 Tishrei 5561 (October 13, 1800) – The Alter Rebbe Was Arrested for the Second Time

This shiur discusses the historical significance of the second arrest of the Alter Rebbe on the 24th of Tishrei, 5561 (1800). It explores the context, details, and impact of this event on Chassidus and its legacy within the community.

1. Introduction to Yemei Chabad

Today marks Yemei Chabad, the 24th day of Tishrei, which is also known as Isru Chag—the day after Sukkos. We will discuss significant events that occurred in the year 5561 (1800), which was 203 years ago. This date is particularly notable as it commemorates the second arrest of the Alter Rebbe.

2. The First Arrest of the Alter Rebbe

The first arrest of the Alter Rebbe occurred two years prior during Sukkos. Authorities came to arrest him but delayed until after the holiday, on Isru Chag. The primary complaint against him at that time was related to his financial support for Israel, which was under Turkish rule and seen as a rival to the Russian government. The slander claimed he was sending money to a foreign government, leading to his imprisonment. Fortunately, he was released on Yud-Tes Kislev, a date celebrated by Chabad.

3. The Second Arrest and Its Context

The second arrest took place two years later in 5561 (1800), instigated by the Misnagdim—opponents of Chassidus—who sought to undermine the Alter Rebbe and his followers. Unable to halt the growing influence of Chassidus through direct opposition, they resorted to slandering him to the government. This time, rather than accusing him personally of being a counter-revolutionary, they claimed that Chassidic philosophy opposed governmental authority.

4. Details of the Arrest

On the 18th day of Tishrei, an order was issued for the Alter Rebbe's transfer to Petersburg on the 24th day of Tishrei. Unlike his first arrest, where he was treated harshly and taken in a black carriage with armed guards, this time he was allowed to travel in a comfortable wagon with escorts. His imprisonment took place in a less severe location known as the Taini Soviet (the Secret Chancellery) rather than the Petropavlovsk Fortress.

5. Imprisonment and Investigation

The Alter Rebbe remained imprisoned from the 28th day of Tishrei until the 27th day of Kislev—over two months—during which various intellectuals investigated his teachings. He engaged with them through lectures and discussions in both Russian and Hebrew, with his son Reb Moishe translating when necessary. Ultimately, these investigations led many officials to recognize that Chassidus posed no threat to the Russian government.

6. Impact on Chassidus

The Alter Rebbe's influence grew significantly during this period; even non-Jews began to respect him as a holy figure. Upon his release on the 27th day of Kislev—coinciding with Hanukkah—he emphasized that even those in power acknowledged his teachings were not contrary to state interests.

7. Stories from Imprisonment

Numerous stories emerged from this time that illustrated his holiness and wisdom. One notable interaction involved an investigator who questioned why God asked Cain about Abel’s whereabouts if He already knew everything. The Alter Rebbe explained that God’s inquiry served as an opportunity for reflection on one’s actions rather than a literal question.

8. Historical Significance and Legacy

On this same date in 5688 (1927), another significant event occurred: the previous Lubavitcher Rebbe left Russia for Riga amidst increasing persecution from communist authorities. His departure marked a pivotal moment for Chabad leadership during tumultuous times.

9. Remembering Rebbetzin Rachel Yanovsky

Additionally, we remember Rebbetzin Rachel Yanovsky, who is believed to have been killed al Kiddush Hashem during the Holocaust around this date. She was a key figure in our lineage as she was both a mother and grandmother within our tradition.

10. Conclusion

In conclusion, we reflect on these historical events commemorated on Yemei Chabad—the second arrest of the Alter Rebbe—and their lasting impact on Chabad philosophy and community resilience amidst adversity.

Notes

The Alter Rebbe's two arrests – the first ended with his release on 19 Kislev 5559; this second one ended on 27 Kislev 5561.

The Previous Rebbe's departure from Russia – followed his arrest and release in 5687. See 15 Sivan – his arrest and 12 Tamuz – his release.

Leave Feedback