Support Torah
Recordings

לקוטי שיחות חלק כ״ב - אמור ב

Likkutei Sichos Vol. 22 – Emor 2

זמן החג ומצוותיו – בחגה"ס ובחגה"פ. נטילת המינים בסוכה דוקא – בהלכה ובעבודת האדם

Prev Search
0:00 0:00
Next

Parshas Emor

1. On the verse1 (near the end of the section of the festivals) "דבר אל בני ישראל לאמר בחמשה עשר יום לחודש השביעי הזה חג הסוכות שבעת ימים לה'" ("Speak to the Children of Israel, saying: On the fifteenth day of this seventh month is the festival of Sukkos, seven days for G‑d"), it is stated in Toras Kohanim: "מה ת"ל" ("Why does the verse say this?")2 Since it says,3 'בסוכות תשבו שבעת ימים' ('You shall dwell in sukkos seven days'), and I would not know whether this means the first seven days or the last seven days. When it says, 'And on the fifteenth4 day of this seventh month is the festival of Sukkos, seven days for G‑d,' this means the first seven days and not the last seven days."

[The commentators5 explain the plain meaning: the question of Toras Kohanim, "Why does the verse say this, etc.," is: why does this verse use the expression "חג הסוכות" ("the festival of Sukkos"),6 seeing that these verses contain only the command of "מקרא קודש כל מלאכת עבודה לא תעשו" ("a holy convocation; you shall do no work of labor") and the offerings of the festival, while the command to dwell in the sukkah appears only later, at the end of the section? It should have said here "a festival of seven days, etc." (without the word "Sukkos").7

To this Toras Kohanim explains, "Since it says, etc.": since the verse "You shall dwell in sukkos seven days" appears at the end of the section, after the verse earlier stated "בחמשה עשר יום לחודש השביעי גו' תחוגו את חג ה' שבעת ימים" ("On the fifteenth day of the seventh month… you shall celebrate the festival of G‑d seven days"),8 one would not know whether the verse "You shall dwell in sukkos seven days" refers to the very same seven days of the festival ("the first seven," beginning from the fifteenth of the month) of which the verse spoke earlier, or whether the seven days of dwelling in the sukkah must come separately, after the "festival of G‑d, seven days" ("the last seven," beginning from the day after those seven days).

Therefore it states right at the beginning of the section, "On the fifteenth day of this seventh month is the festival of Sukkos, seven days," which reveals that "You shall dwell in sukkos seven days" is in the time of the seven days of the festival, which begins "on the fifteenth day of the month."]

2. From the simple meaning of the exposition in Toras Kohanim it seemingly follows that the mitzvah "You shall dwell in sukkos seven days" is not connected with the festival itself9 and with the other matters of the festival (which are stated immediately afterwards, in the first verses: "ביום הראשון מקרא קודש כל מלאכת עבודה לא תעשו שבעת ימים תקריבו אשה לה'" ("On the first day is a holy convocation; you shall do no work of labor. Seven days you shall bring a fire-offering to G‑d"))10 nor with the mitzvah of taking the Four Species (which the Torah connects with the festival11) — which is why one might have supposed that "You shall dwell in sukkos seven days" is not in the same time as the festival and its above-mentioned mitzvos —

The Torah merely lets us know, by adding the word "Sukkos," that in practice the "festival of Sukkos" is in the time of the "seven days for G‑d" that begin "on the fifteenth day of the seventh month."

However, one cannot learn it this way. For from the very fact that the Torah informs us of the time of "You shall dwell in sukkos" (not in some other manner, but) by calling the "seven days for G‑d" the "festival of Sukkos," it is understood that the mitzvah of dwelling in the sukkah does not merely apply in the time of the festival, but that it has a relation to, and is connected with, the festival itself12 and its matters.13 Moreover: since this is the name of the festival, it is understood that this is (as with every name, which expresses the thing named) the content and essence of the festival.14

According to this, however, we must understand:

a) Why, in the command "You shall dwell in sukkos seven days," is there no emphasis in the verse — not even by merely saying "בסוכות תשבו בשבעת הימים" ("You shall dwell in sukkos in the seven days") — so that we would know that these are the seven days of the festival mentioned before?

b) Why does it not say right at the beginning of the section — following "On the fifteenth day of this seventh month is the festival of Sukkos" — "שבעת ימים תשבו בסוכות" ("Seven days you shall dwell in sukkos"); especially since this is how the verse speaks earlier regarding the first festival: "בחמשה עשר יום לחודש הזה חג המצות לה' שבעת ימים מצות תאכלו" ("On the fifteenth15 day of this month is the festival of Matzos for G‑d; seven days you shall eat matzos"),16 and only afterwards comes the matter of "holy convocation," the prohibition of work, and the bringing of the offerings for seven days?

3. This will be understood by first explaining the connection, according to Nigleh (the revealed dimension of Torah), between the mitzvah of sukkah and the mitzvah of taking the lulav (for although the taking of the lulav is also separated in this section from the festival of Sukkos, the Torah nonetheless connects it with the "festival of G‑d, seven days" — unlike sukkah, as mentioned above): The Alter Rebbe writes in his Siddur17 that "מצות נטילתו בסוכה היא מצוה מן המובחר" ("the mitzvah of taking it [the lulav] in the sukkah is the choicest manner of the mitzvah").18

Seemingly this is a matter according to Kabbalah, and its source is in the writings of the Arizal;19 however, it may be said that, like all matters of (Kabbalah and) the inner dimension of the Torah, this too has a source and explanation according to Nigleh20 [especially since the Alter Rebbe changes the wording found in the writings of the Arizal ("טוב לברך כו'" ("It is good to recite the blessing, etc.")) and the like, and writes "the choicest manner of the mitzvah"21].

4. Seemingly one could say that this (that taking the lulav in the sukkah is "the choicest manner of the mitzvah") stems from the mitzvah of sukkah: since the mitzvah of sukkah is22 "תשבו כעין תדורו" ("'You shall dwell' — in the manner that you live"), "שיהי' אוכל ושותה וישן וטייל ודר בסוכה כל ז' הימים בין ביום בין בלילה כדרך שהוא דר בביתו . . וכל דבר שלא הי' עושה חוץ לביתו לא יעשה חוץ לסוכתו" ("that he should eat, drink, sleep, stroll and live in the sukkah all seven days, both by day and by night, the way he lives in his house . . and anything he would not do outside his house he should not do outside his sukkah")23 (and a reason and permission is needed to be allowed to study, etc., outside the sukkah24), it is simply understood from this that the taking of the lulav too, which is among the things a person does during the days of Sukkos, must be done inside the sukkah [especially since "מצותי' אחשבי'" ("its mitzvah makes it significant"),25 and it therefore has a fixed status — and since [?] even strolling (and the like) must be in the sukkah, all the more so must the taking of the lulav be in the sukkah].

However, from the fact that the Alter Rebbe writes the above among the "Laws of Taking the Lulav," and also from his wording, "the mitzvah of taking it in the sukkah is the choicest manner of the mitzvah" (in which the matter of [taking the lulav] is emphasized), it is evident26 that he means (not a law in sukkah, but) a law and choicest manner in the mitzvah of taking the lulav.27

Between these two explanations there is also a practical difference: in a case where one is exempt from the sukkah, such as when rain is falling and the like (since "המצטער פטור מן הסוכה" ("one who is distressed is exempt from the sukkah")):28

If taking the lulav in the sukkah is (merely) a choicest manner in the mitzvah of sukkah — like all other matters, eating, drinking and the like, through which one fulfills the mitzvah of dwelling in the sukkah — then when he is exempt from the sukkah because of rain and the like, he need not wait with taking the lulav until the rain stops, since right now he has no obligation of dwelling in the sukkah (just as he need not wait with his eating, drinking and the like until the rain stops).29

But if this is (also) a choicest manner in the taking of the lulav, then (although right now (while it is raining) he has no obligation of the mitzvah of sukkah), since he is obligated in taking the lulav, whose completeness (— the choicest manner) is when it is done in the sukkah — it is reasonable that the choicest manner is to wait30 until the rain stops, in order to fulfill "the mitzvah of taking it in the sukkah," which is "the choicest manner of the mitzvah."

5. The explanation of all this may be said to be: In our parshah, in the section of the festivals, we find only two festivals for which the festival is designated by a special name — the festival of Matzos and the festival of Sukkos.31 And there are differences between them:

a) For the festival of Matzos it says "ובחמשה עשר יום לחודש הזה חג המצות לה'" ("And on the fifteenth day of this month is the festival of Matzos for G‑d"); the name "festival of Matzos" is not stated in relation to all seven days;32 while for the festival of Sukkos it says "the festival of Sukkos, seven days for G‑d."33

b) On the other hand, for the festival of Matzos the verse immediately continues and says "seven days you shall eat matzos"; while for the festival of Sukkos this ("You shall dwell in sukkos seven days") is stated not adjacent to the name, but only at the end of the section.

The explanation of these differences can be learned from another [?] distinction that we find between the two festivals:

The festival of Matzos is called34 (also) by another name (the festival of Pesach) in the language of our Sages — and also in the language customary among the Jewish people (in common parlance). Whereas regarding the festival of Sukkos, we do not find that it is called by another name;35 it is called by the same name by our Sages36 and in Jewish custom.

From the above it is understood that the content of the entire festival (of Pesach) does not consist entirely in its being the festival of Matzos; whereas with the festival of Sukkos, this (sukkos) is the main content of the festival.

Therefore, when the Torah says "On the fifteenth day of this month is the festival of Matzos for G‑d," the verse immediately explains "seven days you shall eat matzos" — that it is called "the festival of Matzos" only because of this (the detail of eating matzah), not because this is the content of the festival and of all its seven days.37

Whereas on the fifteenth day of the seventh month it is "the festival of Sukkos, seven days for G‑d" — this is the content of (the festival of) the seven days.

And for this very reason, the command "You shall dwell in sukkos seven days" is not stated immediately after "the festival of Sukkos" (as mentioned above), because then one would have thought (as with the festival of Matzos) that it is called the festival of Sukkos merely because of the dwelling in the sukkah on it. That, however, is not the content of the entire festival.

6. The explanation of this: The fifteenth day of the month of Nissan is distinguished as a special time (mainly) not because the mitzvah38 of eating matzah applies then, but because it is "יום צאתך מארץ מצרים" ("the day of your going out from the land of Egypt") — and consequently it becomes a festival and Yom Tov: "והי' היום הזה לכם לזכרון וחגותם אותו חג לה' לדורותיכם" ("This day shall be for you a remembrance, and you shall celebrate it as a festival for G‑d throughout your generations").39 And its being (a Yom Tov) a special time is the cause of the mitzvos of the day [?],40 including the mitzvah of eating matzah.41

Whereas the seven days "on the fifteenth day of this seventh month" are not a time that is special and set apart in itself; on the contrary — [they become special] because of the obligation and mitzvah of dwelling in the sukkah for seven days:42 since during these seven days there is the mitzvah of dwelling in the sukkah (especially in a manner that the mitzvah of sukkah encompasses the whole person and all his affairs throughout the seven days — "'You shall dwell' — in the manner that you live," as mentioned above, so that he "lives in the sukkah all seven days, both by day and by night") — these seven days thereby become special days, a festival for G‑d.

[In a somewhat different style: On every Shabbos and Yom Tov we say (in prayer) "a remembrance of the Exodus from Egypt." There is, however, a difference in this: On the festival of Pesach this is because "זכור את היום הזה אשר יצאתם ממצרים" ("Remember this day on which you went out of Egypt"),43 and therefore "you shall celebrate it as a festival for G‑d throughout your generations," as mentioned above — that is, (the remembrance at the time of) the Exodus makes the time a festival.

This is not so on Shabbos and Shavuos. And even more so —

Regarding the festival of Sukkos the Torah says,44 "למען ידעו דורותיכם כי בסוכות הושבתי את בני ישראל בהוציאי אותם מארץ מצרים" ("So that your generations may know that I made the Children of Israel dwell in sukkos when I brought them out of the land of Egypt") — that is, although this is not at the time when "I made them dwell in sukkos" at the Exodus from Egypt, and the Torah does not state this reason when it gives the command of the festival at the beginning of the section, but only on the mitzvah "You shall dwell in sukkos seven days"; on the contrary, precisely because it is not (in the spring) at the time of the Exodus, the mitzvah of dwelling in the sukkah and the festival of Sukkos take place then (as stated in the Tur45).]

7. Accordingly it is understood that the commands regarding the festival and its details that appear at the beginning of the section — "On the first day is a holy convocation; you shall do no work of labor. Seven days you shall bring a fire-offering to G‑d, etc." — are not separate matters that have no connection with the obligation of dwelling in the sukkah (as one might think, as mentioned above); on the contrary — the definition of "the festival of Sukkos" relates to and applies to them as well.

Whereas with the festival of Pesach, which is a festival as a matter in its own right, apart from the matzos — all these matters, namely its being a "holy convocation," the command "כל מלאכה לא תעשו" ("you shall do no work"), and the bringing of the offerings during the seven days of the festival, are not connected with the matter of the matzos on it,46 but with the festival itself.

8. According to the above, it is also understood regarding the fulfillment of the mitzvah of dwelling in the sukkah, and the relation of the mitzvah of taking the lulav to the mitzvah of sukkah:

As mentioned above, in the command "You shall dwell in sukkos seven days" it is not stated ("You shall dwell in sukkos in the seven days") that these are the seven festival days mentioned earlier — because the obligation to sit in the sukkah for seven days is not because these are seven festival days, but the opposite: "You shall dwell in sukkos" creates the definition of seven festival days, as explained above at length.

Accordingly, Rashi's wording regarding Shemini Atzeres is all the more appreciated: On the Gemara's statement47 that it is "רגל בפני עצמו" ("a festival in its own right"), separate from the festival of Sukkos, Rashi explains, "שאין יושבין בסוכה" ("for one does not sit in the sukkah"): the festival of Sukkos is the (outcome and) matter of dwelling in the sukkah;48 the very essence of the festival consists in "sitting in the sukkah."49

In other words: the festival is brought about through the actual dwelling in the sukkah50 for seven days — "'You shall dwell' — in the manner that you live."

On the other hand, regarding the lulav it says, "ולקחתם לכם ביום הראשון" ("You shall take for yourselves on the first day"), etc.: the mitzvah of taking the lulav is because this is the "first day" of the festival of Sukkos.

Consequently it is understood that the "time of the mitzvah" and the "name of mitzvah" upon the Four Species "חל" ("take effect")51 on the first day.52 The holiness of the festival of Sukkos causes the obligation and the name of mitzvah upon them.53

And since the completeness of the definition and holiness of the festival comes through the actual dwelling in the sukkah, it is understood that when one takes the lulav in the sukkah, this is not merely a law in the "manner that you live" of sukkah, through which something is added to the mitzvah of sukkah; rather it is a law in the taking of the lulav: it adds54 completeness to the "name (and fulfillment of the) mitzvah" of the lulav — "the choicest manner of the mitzvah."55

9. The explanation of all the above in the inner dimension of the matters and in man's service of G‑d:

What was explained above — that the time of "the fifteenth of this seventh month" becomes a festival by virtue of the mitzvah "You shall dwell in sukkos seven days" — contains an advantage56 over the festival of Matzos, where the time is set apart57 in itself:

When the holiness of the festival is brought about by man's actions below, it has an effect upon the world, since it also affects time (the world) as it is in itself, having no connection to holiness; whereas this is not so when the time is intrinsically set apart from Above.

This difference is expressed in the distinction between the two mitzvos themselves — eating matzah and dwelling in the sukkah: eating matzah is, by its nature, an eating of mitzvah; it is not an eating that he would have done anyway, not for the sake of the mitzvah.

Whereas with the mitzvah of dwelling in the sukkah, these are not new activities done for the sake of the mitzvah; on the contrary — "in the manner that you live" — these are matters that belong to the ordinary routine of life of every person, having no connection to Yiddishkeit and to Torah and mitzvos — and yet with them he fulfills a mitzvah (of dwelling in the sukkah).

And this is the special quality of the festival of Sukkos: All year one needs great effort to stand in a state of "כל מעשיך יהיו לשם שמים" ("All your deeds should be for the sake of Heaven") and "בכל דרכיך דעהו" ("Know Him in all your ways"); but when the festival of Sukkos comes, it is brought about that all his conduct in everyday life, just as it is, becomes a matter of mitzvah.

That is why this comes down also physically: the whole person, from head to foot, together with his clothing, is in the sukkah — whereas with no other mitzvah do we find that a person's entire being and all his affairs should be surrounded by a mitzvah of the A-lmighty.

10. To this the Alter Rebbe adds and emphasizes that the mitzvah of taking the lulav in the sukkah is the choicest manner of the mitzvah of lulav58 — "לפיכך בבקר קודם שיתפלל בעודו בסוכה יברך" ("Therefore, in the morning, before he prays, while he is still in the sukkah, he should recite the blessing"), the blessing being on the taking of the lulav:

For one might think that the need to be encompassed by the mitzvah of sukkah — by the Supreme Will — pertains (mainly) to those who are occupied with material matters and needs, but not to those who are in the category of the lulav (palm branches), "שיש בו טעם — שיש בהם תורה" ("which has taste — those who have Torah"),59 since they are constantly bound with the A-lmighty through their Torah study.60

And similarly in the service of every person, one may think to himself: It is understood that "his eating and his drinking, etc." must be included in and surrounded by the mitzvah of sukkah — but why should there be a need for the caution that the mitzvah and Supreme Will of sukkah should encompass his study and comprehension of Torah? He must indeed also fulfill mitzvos, for "כל האומר אין לי אלא תורה, אפילו תורה אין לו" ("Whoever says 'I have only Torah' does not even have Torah"),61 but that is due to the matter of the sukkah, whose definition is "you shall dwell" — to encompass the person entirely; this, however, is seemingly not a matter that applies to the taking of the lulav — the very study and comprehension of Torah — since through it he is already bound with the wisdom of the Holy One, blessed be He.

We are therefore told that "the mitzvah of taking it in the sukkah" is "the choicest manner of the mitzvah": this pertains to his understanding and comprehension of Torah:62 he takes the wisdom of the Torah, which is the wisdom and will of the Holy One, blessed be He, when he senses and feels that what he studies is something that encompasses him and is incomparably higher than he,

and consequently he has the self-nullification and the yearning to absorb the Torah of the Holy One, blessed be He, which is "hidden from the eyes of all living," into his understanding and comprehension.

And similarly in general — when he has not only actual occupation in Torah, but also the endearment and preciousness of the Torah, "ברכו בתורה תחלה" ("reciting the blessing on the Torah first"),63 the opposite of "אבדה הארץ" ("the land was lost")64 is brought about — and we merit, very soon indeed, "ופרוס עלינו סוכת שלומך" ("Spread over us the sukkah of Your peace"), in the building of the Beis HaMikdash, of which it is written "ויהי בשלם סוכו" ("His sukkah was in Shalem"),65 which will be built by Moshiach Tzidkeinu,66 speedily in our days, indeed.

(From the sichos of Simchas Beis HaSho'eivah, 5724)


Notes

1) Our parshah, 23:34.

2) This is the reading in the printed editions of Toras Kohanim and in the manuscripts of Toras Kohanim before us (New York 5717, Jerusalem 5733). In Yalkut Shimoni here: "Why is 'seven days' stated?" See below, note 6.

3) Our parshah, 23:42.

4) This is the reading ("And on the fifteenth") in the printed editions of Toras Kohanim before us, and in the above-mentioned Jerusalem manuscript. But in the above-mentioned New York manuscript and in Yalkut Shimoni there: "On the fifteenth" (as in the verse).

5) Korban Aharon on Toras Kohanim; Malbim. See also Rabbeinu Hillel. In a somewhat different manner in the commentary of the Raavad and of R. Shimshon of Sens on Toras Kohanim, and in Beis Ra'anan on Yalkut Shimoni there, as in the following note.

6) In the commentary of the Raavad (and similarly in R. Shimshon of Sens) on Toras Kohanim: "That is, for it was already stated below, 'But on the fifteenth day of the seventh month, when you gather in the produce of the land, etc.'" Seemingly he explains that the entire verse quoted by Toras Kohanim is superfluous. According to his explanation, one must say that the verses (35–36), "On the first day is a holy convocation… seven days…," should have been stated afterwards. Beis Ra'anan explains, according to the reading of Yalkut Shimoni, "Why is 'seven days' stated": "for it is written afterwards, 'Seven days you shall bring a fire-offering to G‑d.'" Apparently the question is only on the words "seven days" — that it should not have said "seven days" (compare what is stated earlier (23:6), "the festival of Matzos"; see below in the text, section 5). This is not the place to elaborate.

7) In Rabbeinu Hillel: "But another verse is written, 'You shall dwell in sukkos seven days.'" This implies that he explains the question to be that "Sukkos, seven days" is superfluous here.

8) 23:39.

9) Note the wording of the Chinuch here (mitzvah 325): "The mitzvah of sukkah — that we were commanded to dwell in the sukkah seven days, as it says, etc., and the first day is the fifteenth of Tishrei." He does not mention the festival at all — unlike what he writes regarding lulav (quoted below, note 11). In the enumeration of the mitzvos at the beginning of the Yad (positive mitzvah 168), the Rambam writes, "To dwell in the sukkah seven days, as it says, etc." And similarly there regarding lulav (positive mitzvah 169). But seemingly one cannot prove (this detail) from there, since: a) they wrote with the utmost brevity; b) they come in sequence after resting on the festival of Sukkos, etc. See his wording in Sefer HaMitzvos (quoted below, note 12). Perhaps one should not be so precise in the wording of the above-mentioned books.

Note the difference in the Rambam: in the Yad, the "Laws of Shofar, Sukkah and Lulav" come as separate laws, while the mitzvos and laws of resting and the prohibition of work on Yom Tov (Pesach, Shavuos, Rosh Hashanah, Sukkos and Shemini Atzeres) come together before it, as separate laws — "Laws of Resting on Yom Tov." On the other hand, in the order of the enumeration of the mitzvos (in Sefer HaMitzvos and in the enumeration of the mitzvos at the beginning of the Yad), he lists the mitzvos of each Yom Tov in order (Pesach, (counting the Omer,) resting on Shavuos, on Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur (to fast on it and to rest on the day of the fast), Sukkos) together with the mitzvos of resting on them* — positive mitzvos 156–170 (apart from the mitzvah of sounding the shofar, which he writes at the end, after the mitzvah of taking the lulav).

*) Except that for the festival of Matzos he first lists the mitzvah (telling of the Exodus and eating matzah) and afterwards its resting; whereas for the festival of Sukkos it is the reverse — first the mitzvah of resting, and afterwards its mitzvos (dwelling in the sukkah and taking the lulav).

10) Especially since, before the command regarding the Four Species and sukkah, it concludes (23:37), "These are the festivals of G‑d which you shall proclaim, etc." See Ramban 23:39, 44; Abarbanel here; Rashbam there, end of 43; Sforno, end of 39; and in many places in the commentators on the Torah.

11) 23:39. See the wording of the Chinuch here (mitzvah 324): "The mitzvah of lulav — that we take it on the first day of the festival of Sukkos." See the sources in the previous note.

12) See Tosafos, s.v. Nichnas (Sukkah 46a), and the Rosh and Ran there (cited in Beis Yosef, Orach Chaim, end of sec. 641), that since the sukkah "comes on account of the festival,"* it is logical that its Shehecheyanu, etc., exempts also for the festival. See Rema there. Note also the opinion of the Bach (in Responsa, sec. 132 [?], cited in Ba'er Heitev there, subsec. 2), also the reverse: that if he recited it for the festival, it exempts the Shehecheyanu for the sukkah.** See also the Shulchan Aruch there; below, note 42.

Note also the wording of the Rambam in Sefer HaMitzvos (positive mitzvah 168), who emphasizes the connection of sukkah to the festival: "That He commanded us to dwell in the sukkah seven days, in the days of the festival" (and in the Kafich translation: "in all the days of the festival"). And in the enumeration of the mitzvos in the Yad (as in the heading to the Laws of Shofar, Sukkah and Lulav): "To dwell in the sukkah all seven days of the festival" (and similarly he writes regarding lulav there: "To take the lulav in the Mikdash all seven days of the festival"). And so he writes there within the laws themselves (6:7): "Eating in the sukkah on the night of the first Yom Tov is an obligation."

*) This is the reading in Tosafos, Tosafos HaRosh and the Ran there. In the Rosh before us: "since the sukkah is made on account of the festival." See the next marginal gloss.

**) Except that the main reasoning of the Bach there is: since it is the time of its mitzvah, and his intention was to bless also on the sukkah, he need not bless again. He brings proof from the opinion of Tosafos and the Rosh. After quoting the words of Tosafos he explains: since his intention at the time of the blessing was also for the festival, because the "zman" of the sukkah comes on account of the festival — then all the more so in our case, etc.; see there. This is not the place to elaborate. See below, marginal gloss to note 42.

13) See the wording of R. Shimshon of Sens in his commentary on Toras Kohanim there, at the end: "Sukkah and lulav are one festival." Similarly in the commentary of the Raavad there: "Lulav and sukkah are a festival for them."

14) See below, note 42.

15) 23:6.

16) On the plain meaning, see Malbim here: that it was necessary to leave the notification of the laws of sukkah, which are many, for the end; whereas the matter of matzah and its details was already explained in Parshas Bo. But it still requires examination, for the details "every native in Israel…" and "so that your generations may know…" could have been left for the end, with "You shall dwell in sukkos seven days" written at the beginning of the section, as with matzah.

17) "Laws of the Lulav" (before Hallel).

18) The wording in the Siddur: "By law one should recite the blessing on the lulav after the prayer, before Hallel; but since the mitzvah . . choicest, and it is impossible to leave the synagogue because of onlookers, therefore in the morning, before he prays, while he is still in the sukkah, he should recite the blessing." See below for the wording of the writings of the Arizal.

19) Pri Etz Chaim, Shaar HaLulav (Shaar 29, ch. 3), the matter of taking the lulav. Shaar HaKavanos, Derushei Chag HaSukkos, at the beginning. Siddur HaArizal (kavanah of the lulav and its shakings). Mishnas Chassidim, tractate Yemei Mitzvah VeSukkah, beginning of ch. 5.

20) In the Shelah (245b), after citing from Seder HaYom the two approaches (whether to take it in the sukkah or specifically in the synagogue), he writes: "And I say, one who fears Heaven fulfills both, etc.; he should not divert his attention from it, etc., from the synagogue to the sukkah, and shake there to the six directions. And so I practice on all the days of Sukkos." Afterwards he cites from the writings of the Arizal (in the wording of Pri Etz Chaim given in the next note) and concludes, "Let the one who chooses, choose." This is cited in Magen Avraham, sec. 651, subsec. 17;* sec. 652, subsec. 3; and in Ba'er Heitev there in the name of the Shelah. In the Siddur of the Yaavetz he writes that his father practiced so.

See also Bikkurei Yaakov, Orach Chaim, sec. 644, subsec. 1: "Therefore, what men of deeds practice — to take the lulav in the morning in the sukkah, before going to the synagogue — is a proper custom, not only for the reason that according to Kabbalah one should take the lulav in the sukkah, but also for the reason that the zealous hasten to [perform] the mitzvah of lulav."

*) In Magen Avraham there: "The Shelah writes that one should shake in the sukkah before going to the synagogue; see there." It requires slight examination why he did not write that one should bless in the sukkah, as stated in the writings of the Arizal, and as he himself writes in sec. 651 there (the Shelah in the name of the Arizal). In Ba'er Heitev: "The Shelah writes that one should shake in the sukkah and bless, and afterwards the other shakings should be in the synagogue." This is not the place to elaborate.

21) Pri Etz Chaim begins (cited in the Shelah there): "It is good to bless first, before the prayer, while you are in your house, in the sukkah itself, etc.; and it is better to bless after the Amidah, before Hallel, while you are in the sukkah, but because of onlookers, do as above." Shaar HaKavanos begins: "It is good, etc., and how good it would be if you prayed in the sukkah, so that you would pray and take the lulav with its blessing at the time appropriate for it." In Siddur HaArizal (and similarly in Mishnas Chassidim) the wording is: "By law it is fitting that immediately after the Amidah, before Hallel, one bless on the lulav inside the sukkah, but because of onlookers, etc." But it is understood that the intention of "by law" is only regarding blessing on it at its appropriate time (after the prayer, before Hallel), as is explicit in the wording of the Alter Rebbe in the Siddur, who omitted "in the sukkah" at the beginning of his wording.

22) Sukkah 28b ff. Rambam, Laws of Sukkah 6:5 ff. Tur, Shulchan Aruch and the Alter Rebbe's Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim, beginning of sec. 639, and 52 [?].

23) Wording of the Alter Rebbe there, par. 4.

24) Sukkah there. Rambam there, halachah 9. Tur and Shulchan Aruch (and the Alter Rebbe's) there, par. 4.

25) See Bechoros 10a; Rashi, Beitzah 26b, s.v. Chalah. See Encyclopedia Talmudis, entry "Isuro Chashivo."

26) As is evident even more from what is stated in the writings of the Arizal there.

27) See Bikkurei Yaakov (cited above, note 20). But according to him this is on account of taking it before the prayer, not on account of taking it in the sukkah.

28) See Sukkah 28b, in the Mishnah; ibid. 29a. Rambam there, halachah 10. Tur and Shulchan Aruch (and the Alter Rebbe's) there, par. 5 ff. (par. 7 [?]; par. 21).

29) See the Alter Rebbe's Shulchan Aruch there (par. 25–26). And [OCR unclear] even more than this.

30) See the Alter Rebbe's Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim, sec. 94, end of par. 5: "In order to fulfill the mitzvah in the choicest manner, it is proper that he wait, etc., and this does not involve [the principles of] 'one does not let a mitzvah become stale' and 'the zealous hasten to mitzvos,' since his intention is to fulfill the mitzvah in the choicest manner." See Sdei Chemed (Kelalim, letter Zayin, rule 1) similarly regarding taking the Four Species — that it is proper to wait in order to fulfill the mitzvah in the choicest manner. Encyclopedia Talmudis, vol. 12, p. 418, and sources cited there.

31) Regarding the festival of Shavuos it says (23:15, 21): "Until the morrow of the seventh week you shall count fifty days, and you shall bring, etc. And you shall proclaim on this very day a holy convocation, etc." Regarding Rosh Hashanah: "It shall be for you a day of rest, a remembrance of sounding [the shofar]" (ibid., 24). Regarding Yom Kippur: "It is the Day of Atonement" (ibid., 27); "It is a day of atonement" (ibid., 28).

32) Similarly in Pinchas (28:17): "On the fifteenth day of this month is a festival; seven days matzos shall be eaten." And in Mishpatim (23:15): "You shall keep the festival of Matzos; seven days you shall eat matzos." And similarly in Ki Sisa (34:18). But it does not say "the festival of Matzos, seven days." In Nach too (II Chronicles 30:21; similarly ibid. 35:17; Ezra 6:22) this is not said of the name of the festival itself, but of what the Jewish people did: "The Children of Israel… kept the festival of Matzos seven days with joy, etc."

33) Similarly in Re'eh (16:13): "You shall make the festival of Sukkos for yourself seven days."

34) All seven (eight) days — and not only the fourteenth and fifteenth of Nissan, which are called Pesach also in the Written Torah (see the discussion, etc., in the book HaMoadim BaHalachah by Rabbi S. Y. Zevin, p. 215 ff.). See also the Haggadah, Kehot edition (5746 printing and onwards), p. 668, in the notes.

35) Apart from the names based on the seasons of the produce (Bachya, Mishpatim 23:16): "the season of the month of spring," "the festival of harvest," "the festival of ingathering." This is explained in Or HaTorah, Mishpatim, p. 1178 ff.; Likkutei Sichos vol. 29, p. 232 ff.

36) Or simply "the Festival": in the Talmud and in common parlance (including Shemini Atzeres — see Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh De'ah, sec. 220, par. 4). In the Written Torah — also Pesach and Shavuos.

37) Therefore the expression "festival of Matzos" is stated (mainly) only regarding the sixteenth [?] day, as mentioned in the text, since the mitzvah of eating matzah is only on the first night, when the verse established it as an obligation, whereas on the other days it is only optional (Toras Kohanim, our parshah there; Pesachim 120a). See Taz, Orach Chaim, sec. 668, near the beginning: "Why should all the days be called the festival of Matzos? They should have been called by the prohibition of chametz! Rather, everything is drawn after the first night, and the other days come on its account, etc."

38) Similarly with the festival of Shavuos (see 16:14 [?]), which is not because of the obligation and fulfillment of the mitzvos (offerings) of that day, but (as emphasized in its name — also in our parshah) because of "You shall count for yourselves… until the morrow of the seventh week you shall count fifty days, etc." (our parshah 23:15, 16; and similarly in Re'eh there, 9) — because of the time and the count of seven weeks. Therefore a new meal-offering is brought on it, unlike the expression "on the day of the first fruits" (Pinchas 28:26; see Rashi there). But on account of this it is not called by the name "festival" in Scripture.

39) Bo 12:14. See there, 42, and Rashi: "That is the night of which He said to Avraham, 'On this night I will redeem your children.'"

40) See Likkutei Sichos vol. 16, p. 107 ff., and sources cited there.

41) See the wording of the Rambam (regarding eating matzah) in the enumeration of the mitzvos at the beginning of the Yad, positive mitzvah 158; mitzvah 7 in the heading to the Laws of Chametz and Matzah. On the other hand, in Sefer HaMitzvos, positive mitzvah 158, and in the Yad, Laws of Chametz and Matzah, beginning of ch. 6: "To eat matzah on the night of the fifteenth."

42) As is emphasized in halachah in the reason given for the opinions which rule that when one recited Shehecheyanu at the time of making the sukkah before the festival, he does not recite it on Yom Tov for the festival, whereas, on the other hand, if he recited it for the festival on the first night in his house, he must recite Shehecheyanu when he eats in the sukkah — "since he recited it at the time of making [the sukkah], and the essence of Yom Tov is only because of the sukkah," the blessing of the sukkah "counts for Yom Tov and for the sukkah" (Sefer HaHashlamah on Sukkah 46a, cited in Sefer HaMichtam on Sukkah there; Kol Bo, end of the Laws of Lulav; Orchos Chaim, end of the Laws of Sukkah (and similarly in the Meiri, Sukkah there)). Accordingly they distinguish the other festivals, Pesach and Atzeres, where one recites Shehecheyanu on Yom Tov [?]. See Birkei Yosef, Orach Chaim, sec. 643, who writes that this is the halachah.

*) In Tosafos HaRosh and the Ran the wording is the reverse (as above, note 12). But in Birkei Yosef there, sec. 643, he writes that they hold of one approach. But see Responsa Masas Moshe (Orach Chaim, sec. 5, cited in Ba'er Heitev and in Birkei Yosef there), who writes on the reasoning of Tosafos: "Since it comes on account of it, when he blesses on the sukkah it is as if he specified the sukkah and the festival, for they are of one name; but where he recited Shehecheyanu on the festival itself, this [?] does not exempt the Shehecheyanu of the sukkah, for the festival is not revealed in the mitzvah of making the sukkah"; see there. This is not the place to elaborate.

43) Bo 13:3, and in many places in that section. See Rambam, Laws of Chametz and Matzah, beginning of ch. 7.

44) Our parshah, 23:43.

45) Orach Chaim, sec. 625. See at length Beis Yosef and Bach there. Note that Rashi too, in his commentary on our parshah on this verse, writes simply "clouds of glory" (see the commentators on Rashi). See the Alter Rebbe's Shulchan Aruch there.

46) As is emphasized in the law (Alter Rebbe's Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim, sec. 491, par. 3, from Magen Avraham and Chok Yaakov there) that one whose meal extended into the night after the last day of Yom Tov of Pesach, until after nightfall, is permitted to eat chametz at that meal,* since "eating chametz is not at all dependent on the holiness of the day." See above, p. 36.

*) Accordingly one must say that in what the Alter Rebbe writes in sec. 432, par. 3 (from the Rosh, Pesachim ch. 1, sec. 14 [?], and elsewhere) — "Why is Shehecheyanu not recited before the search? Because this mitzvah is for the needs of the festival, to prepare the house and eliminate the chametz from it for the needs of the Moed; therefore it is exempted by the blessing of Shehecheyanu recited on the festival at the night Kiddush" — the intention of "for the needs of the festival," "for the needs of the Moed," is not the holiness of the Moed, but the time of the festival. Note that he changes there from the wording of the Rosh, that "we rely on the 'zman' of the festival, just as one who makes a sukkah and lulav for himself, who is obligated to recite Shehecheyanu when making them, but we rely on the 'zman' of the festival" (and so the Alter Rebbe himself writes in sec. 641, end of par. 1, regarding sukkah: "because we rely on the blessing of Shehecheyanu recited at the Kiddush of the day, etc., and one blessing counts for both"), and writes instead, "therefore it is exempted, etc." See Bach there, sec. 432; Taz there, end of subsec. 2. This is not the place to elaborate.

47) Sukkah 48a, beginning.

48) According to the above it is also understood that there is no contradiction from the fact that in tractate Yoma (3a), and similarly in Chagigah (17a), he explains "for the name of the festival of Sukkos is not upon it" — for it is one and the same.

49) See also Taz, Orach Chaim, end of sec. 668.

50) Accordingly perhaps one can explain why "on the first night of the festival . . one must eat inside the sukkah even while it is raining, and even though he is distressed, etc.; on the first night he is obligated to eat in the sukkah" (Alter Rebbe's Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim, sec. 639, par. 17, and sources cited there), although on the other days of the festival he is not obligated — since through this the completeness of the holiness of the festival is brought about.*

*) Accordingly one can explain (at least by way of allusion) the wording of the Alter Rebbe there: "But on the first night of the festival, that is, the night of the fifteenth of Tishrei (one must eat, etc.)."

51) Wording of Rashi, s.v. VeLulav (Sukkah 33a), and s.v. Ha Garsinan (ibid., 33b).

52) Except that according to Rashi it takes effect immediately once the day is sanctified, [OCR unclear] deferral.

53) And "its binding (before the festival) is not a designation that would make the name of lulav take effect, so that a disqualification would defer it, etc., until the day is sanctified upon it" (Rashi, Sukkah there, s.v. VeHa Garsinan). Unlike sukkah,* where there is a mitzvah in making it, as it says, "You shall make the festival of Sukkos for yourself" — see Rashi, Makkos 8a; Alter Rebbe's Shulchan Aruch, sec. 641, par. 1 (Taz there); sec. 625 (from the Rema and Magen Avraham there); HaEmek She'elah on the She'iltos, She'ilta 169; and elsewhere. See Tzafnas Pa'neach, Laws of Oaths 5:15, where he distinguishes between matzah and sukkah before the festival.

*) See Sukkah there, 33a, and sources cited there; and Rashi there, s.v. Lulav. This is not the place to elaborate.

54) Similar to (and all the more so than) the principle that Shabbos "is effective" for the daily offerings, and several similar cases (Zevachim 91a, beginning). And similarly [?] Yom Kippur, which "is effective" for all the offerings of the day, which is why all the services of Yom Kippur are valid only through him (the Kohen Gadol) — Yoma 32b, end, and sources cited there.

55) According to the above, the Chabad custom of taking care to bind the lulav in the sukkah (on the Eve of Yom Tov) is also understood.

56) Similar to the special quality of the second day of Yom Tov of the Diaspora relative to the first day of Yom Tov (Likkutei Torah, Shemini Atzeres 92b, beginning, ff.; Derech Mitzvosecha 114a–b; Likkutei Sichos vol. 9, p. 235, and in the notes there).

57) Although relative to Shabbos, on every Yom Tov it is "Israel, who sanctify the times" (Berachos 49a).

58) On the Chassidic explanation, see Siddur 263, end of col. c, ff.; Hemshech VeKachah 5637, ch. 84; Hemshech 5666, p. 32; and elsewhere. See also Likkutei Sichos vol. 9, pp. 360–361.

59) Vayikra Rabbah 30:12.

60) See at length Likkutei Sichos vol. 4, p. 1160 [?] ff.

61) Yevamos 109b.

62) See the Alter Rebbe's Laws of Torah Study 4:3; Likkutei Sichos vol. 15, p. 139.

63) See the Students of Rabbeinu Yonah, cited in the Ran, Nedarim 81a; Alter Rebbe's Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim, beginning of sec. 47.

64) Nedarim there; Bava Metzia 85b, beginning.

65) Tehillim 76:3. See the Targum on the verse; Midrash Tehillim there.

66) See Pesachim 5a: "In reward for three 'firsts' (the resting on the festival of Pesach, the resting on the festival of Sukkos, and the taking of the lulav, which are called 'first' — Rashi there) they merited three 'firsts', etc. — the building of the Beis HaMikdash, and the name of Moshiach." See Chiddushei Aggados there, and at length Likkutei Sichos vol. 19, there [?].


Key Lesson

Sukkos is unique: its holiness is created by the ordinary acts of daily life — eating, drinking, sleeping — performed inside the sukkah, so that a person's entire routine becomes a mitzvah. Even one whose life is Torah study, bound to G‑d's wisdom, must "take the lulav in the sukkah": approach the Torah with self-nullification, sensing that it encompasses him and is infinitely above him — and this hastens "the sukkah of Your peace," the building of the Beis HaMikdash by Moshiach.

Leave Feedback

{# Keyboard shortcuts: Alt+Left = previous shiur, Alt+Right = next shiur. Ignored while typing in a box or editor so Alt+arrow word-jumping still works there. #}