008

Classes, Nitzavim - 008

עמידה איתנה ותנועה קדימה, הפרדוקס הרוחני של נצבים וילך

Standing Firm and Moving Forward: Netzavim and Vayelech’s Spiritual Paradox

This shiur explores the unique combination of Netzavim and Vayelech, highlighting their paradoxical themes of standing firm and moving forward. Drawing on Chassidic teachings and the Rambam, it emphasizes how every mitzvah can tip the scale for ourselves and the world.

1. The Structure of the Torah Reading Cycle

This week, we read two portions: the seder—Torah reading—of Netzavim and Vayelech. Whenever we read two portions together, the Wednesday reading, known as Revii—the fourth aliyah—serves as the connector between the two. The aliyah of Revii begins with the end of the first portion and continues into the second. This happens several times throughout the year, depending on how the calendar aligns. The main goal is to ensure that we review and complete the entire Torah once a year, culminating in Simchas Torah. That’s why there is such joy on Simchas Torah—we celebrate having had the privilege and merit to finish all of Torah. Some people even carry this joy throughout the year.

To maintain this annual cycle, adjustments are sometimes necessary, such as combining certain portions when holidays affect the regular schedule. For example, this year Yom Kippur falls on Shabbos, so there will be no Shabbos between Yom Kippur and Sukkos. Sukkos will fall in that same week as Shabbos, resulting in one fewer Shabbos than usual. In some years there is an extra Shabbos in between. That’s why Netzavim and Vayelech are combined this year. After Rosh Hashanah, Shabbos follows immediately with Parshas Haazinu, and then comes Zos Habracha, which is reserved for Simchas Torah.

On Shabbos Chol Hamoed Sukkos, we don’t read from the regular weekly portion but instead have a special Torah reading for Sukkos. This arrangement explains why Netzavim and Vayelech are read together this week.

2. The Paradox of Netzavim and Vayelech

If you look at the names of these two portions, they seem to present a paradox or even opposites. What does Netzavim mean? Netzavim means “standing,” specifically standing firmly in one place—a strong and anchored kind of standing. It’s not just omed—standing—which would simply mean being upright or present. If it said “Atem Omdim Hayom,” it would mean “you are standing today.” But Netzavim implies a much firmer stance: you cannot be moved, you are stationary and rooted.

According to inner teachings, “Atem Netzavim Hayom”—“You are standing today”—also refers to Rosh Hashanah, which is called Yom Hadin Rabbah—the Great Day of Judgment. It represents that the Jewish people stand very firmly before Hashem on this day, secure and certain that Hashem will bless us with a good and sweet year.

On one hand we have Netzavim (standing), but immediately following is Vayelech (going). Here we combine both staying put and moving forward in one reading cycle.

3. Standing Firm vs. Moving Forward: Insights from the Text

This year’s combination is reflected even in today’s Wednesday portion (Revii). In Netzavim’s very second verse, we read: “Re’ei nosati lefanecha hayom es hachayim ves hatov ves hamoves ves hara—Behold I have set before you today life and good, death and bad.” The next verse says: “Asher anochi metzavecha hayom le’ehava es Hashem Elokecha leleches—that I command you today to love Hashem your God to walk in His ways.”

Even while still within Netzavim (the portion about standing), we’re already talking about walking in Hashem’s ways (leleches bidrachov). This is found in Netzavim’s seventh aliyah when read alone or becomes Revii when combined with Vayelech.

The beginning of Vayelech then opens with Moshe Rabbeinu saying: “B’me’ah v’esrim shana anochi hayom—I am 120 years old today.” Rashi comments that “hayom”—“today”—means it was his birthday: Moshe was born on 7 Adar and passed away on 7 Adar.

4. The Deeper Meaning of Standing and Going

During our lifetime (Olam Hazeh) we are instructed to go (leleches)—to grow spiritually by doing mitzvos and accomplishing good in this world for ourselves and for others. Our job here is action: “Hayom la’asoysom u’lemachar lekabel secharam”—“Today [in this world] is for doing [mitzvos], tomorrow [in Olam Haba] is for receiving reward.”

The work can only be done here in Olam Hazeh—a person can no longer do mitzvos after their time has come to an end. That’s why Moshe Rabbeinu says at 120 years old that he can no longer go out or come in—a transition from action to completion.

This creates an interesting dynamic: at the end of Netzavim (about walking) comes Vayelech (about standing still), yet spiritually these concepts are intertwined.

5. Chassidic Perspective: True Movement Requires Firmness

The Chassidic interpretation teaches that true going (vayelech) means moving beyond your previous state entirely—a non-measured leap rather than incremental progress relative to where you started. If someone only moves relative to their previous position but remains fundamentally connected to it, they haven’t truly gone anywhere new.

The real level of vayelech, then, is achieved by leaving behind your prior limitations entirely to reach a deeper or higher level spiritually.

This applies even though our perception here is limited—we may feel like we’re only taking baby steps spiritually while alive in this world (Nitzavim). Yet every mitzvah actually accomplishes tremendous things on spiritual levels far beyond what we see or understand.

6. From Strength Comes Infinite Growth

If someone is truly anchored in Torah and Yiddishkeit—if they are Nitzavim, standing strong—then when they begin to move forward (vayelech) they do so powerfully and without limit because their foundation is secure.

The strength gained from being firmly rooted enables unlimited spiritual growth later on. While our actions here may seem limited or unrewarded at times, after 120 years when our soul leaves this world (Nitzavim ends/Vayelech begins) that’s when true movement begins: endless ascent through spiritual realms as a result of our efforts here below.

Moshe Rabbeinu’s passing marks not an end but a new beginning—Vayeilech Moshe: Moshe started going upward through infinite spiritual levels based on his lifetime accomplishments.

7. Olam Haba: Present Reality Through Our Actions Now

The Rambam explains that Olam Haba—the World to Come—is not something distant or future-oriented simply because it follows physical life—it exists now as a spiritual reality accessible after life ends here below.

The soul joins those higher realms immediately upon leaving this world—so much takes place beyond what we perceive now but it all stems from what we accomplish through mitzvos while alive.

This highlights how valuable every mitzvah truly is—whether davening once more, learning Torah again, putting on tefillin one more time—each act has immense impact both for ourselves and for all creation.

8. Tipping the Scale: The Power of One Good Deed

The Rambam writes that each person should view themselves—and indeed all humanity—as if balanced exactly halfway between merit and guilt (50-50). One extra good deed tips not only their own scale but also that of the entire world toward merit.

This perspective gives tremendous significance to every action—we never know which mitzvah will tip everything for ourselves or for everyone else!

The hope as we approach Rosh Hashanah (Tav Shin Ayin Hey) is that our extra deeds will tip the scale fully toward good—bringing merit for ourselves, redemption with Mashiach Tzidkeinu, blessings for a happy, healthy year filled with success and fulfillment of all our heart’s desires—and above all joy (freilachkeit) as Hashem blesses us all in everything we do.

Leave Feedback